Many struggling Pennsylvania families, health care providers, food banks and state and local leaders are bracing for the impacts of President Donald Trump’s and Republican allies’ tax and policy bill that became law Friday, with nonpartisan research groups and nonprofits predicting damaging cuts to Medicaid, the Affordable Care Act and federal food assistance.
Republican lawmakers say the “big beautiful bill” makes good on a number of Trump’s promises that helped the GOP sweep all three branches of government in November.
They tout the law for providing tax relief by permanently extending broad tax cuts, ramping up investments in border security and defense, phasing out Biden administration clean energy tax breaks, and implementing new state funding mandates and work requirements to social safety net programs they claim are rife with fraud or abuse.
But state officials, including Gov. Josh Shapiro, argue programs such as Medicaid and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program are already protected from fraud or abuse and are falling victim to Trump’s push for tax breaks to the wealthy. They warn that the deep cuts to the programs and additional work requirements will lead not only to burdensome paperwork but also to lost benefits for thousands of families, seniors, women, children, veterans and disabled Pennsylvanians.
Here are a few of the ways the bill could impact Pennsylvania and the thoughts of some Pittsburghers about its potential ramifications.
Medicaid and SNAP
The bill calls for more than $1 trillion in cuts to Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program over the next decade, and it shifts substantial Medicaid expansion and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program funding to the states.
Combined with the bill’s proposed changes to the Affordable Care Act, the bill could lead to almost 17 million people nationwide losing their health coverage, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a progressive think tank. That includes more than 480,000 people in Pennsylvania.
Medicaid cuts are expected to slash federal spending in the Keystone State by $53 billion by 2034, according to an analysis by KFF, a nonprofit, nonpartisan health policy outfit based in Washington, D.C.
“On behalf of tens of thousands of nurses and health care workers across Pennsylvania, we strongly condemn the passage of the largest health care cuts in American history in order to pay for massive giveaways to billionaires,” Matt Yarnell, president of SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania, said in a statement Friday.

Mr. Shapiro said Thursday that 310,000 Pennsylvanians would lose Medicaid coverage and at least 140,000 Pennsylvanians would lose SNAP benefits due to the bill.
Starting in 2027, states will need to cover three-fourths of SNAP’s administrative costs compared to the current even split with the federal government.
On top of the new administrative expenses, states with error rates in their SNAP payments greater than 6% will have to cover between 5% and 15% of the cost of the food benefits. The national error rate is almost 11%.
U.S. Rep. Glenn Thompson, R-Centre, who chairs the House Agriculture Committee, accused Mr. Shapiro of “mismanagement” in administering SNAP, and he argued that the new work requirements protect the program from benefitting those who don’t deserve benefits.
Officials with the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services said the SNAP error rate is not a measurement of fraud or misuse, but a measure of paperwork errors linked to administrative requirements. The federal cuts and shifts of costs to the state could threaten the sustainability of the program, they said.
Pennsylvania’s error rate in 2024 was 10.76%, under the national average for the first time since 2019.
“The Department of Human Services will continue our work to lower the SNAP error rate and effectively serve Pennsylvanians who rely on food assistance to support themselves and their families,” DHS spokesman Brandon Cwalina said in a statement.
Some sellers of fresh produce, however, said Saturday that the bill could strip SNAP beneficiaries of their ability to afford healthy food.
Pearl McCann, 29, works the Who Cooks For You Farm stall, a fresh produce pop-up that accepts EBT payments, at the Bloomfield Saturday Market every weekend. She estimates that a quarter of her customers are SNAP beneficiaries.
She said Saturday that people using SNAP typically struggle to budget for organic produce and tend to live in “food deserts,” areas without grocery stores and fresh food options.
“It makes me nauseous,” she said, referring to parts of the bill affecting the health of low-income people. “I’ve had periods of my life where I couldn’t afford fresh food and my energy level was just so low.”
Ms. McCann, who said she has lived most of her life on the poverty line, used food stamps to buy fresh fruit and vegetables until last year.
“Being poor is the most exhausting position to be put in,” she said. “It’s juggling so much, and it’s a weight that slows down parts of myself that I want to share.”
Ms. McCann also said she had used Medicaid in the past but now earns a little too much to qualify.

While pondering the slashes to Medicaid benefits, she grappled with the realization that millions more could face her situation: “If I were to get in a car crash, my car would be protected and my body would not be protected whatsoever.”
Marie Barcic, a 33-year-old farmer staffing Be.wild.er farm’s vegetable stall at the market Saturday, said she fears cuts to SNAP and Medicaid could exacerbate the farm’s financial struggles as a result of a post-pandemic dip in business.
“It’s getting harder for people to buy organic, healthy vegetables,” she said. “Health is everything for people – I just think this country does so little for it in comparison to other wealthy nations.”
Concerning Medicaid, she said she worries that the agricultural labor pool could dwindle if farmers, who endure “taxing” and injury-prone work, lose their health insurance.
“It’s pressure from every end,” she said.
Taxes
The first Trump administration’s 2017 tax cuts will now be permanent.
Republicans argued that the budget bill prevented one of the largest tax hikes in history because those cuts were set to expire at the end of the year. Many economists and nonpartisan researchers said both the 2017 tax cuts and the new bill making those cuts permanent disproportionately benefited the wealthy..
Pennsylvania Republican U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick argued that the bill effectively prevented the average Pennsylvania family’s tax bill from rising by $2,500.

Combined with new spending on border security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, and the Pentagon, the tax cuts will lead to the national deficit rising by more than $3.3 trillion over the next decade, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office.
The bill increased the standard deduction by $750 ($1,500 for couples), bumped the child tax credit by $200, expanded the business interest deduction, and increased and made permanent the estate and lifetime gift tax exemption.
The bill limits deductions for gambling losses to 90% — rankling professional poker players, horse racing enthusiasts and other gamblers.
It also temporarily caps itemized federal tax deductions for state and local taxes at $40,000 per household (it will revert to $10,000 in 2030), and permanently extends the home mortgage interest deduction limit to the first $750,000 in debt.
The package also created a tax credit for contributions made to organizations that provide scholarships and other funds for children to attend private schools — provisions that Republicans including Mr. McCormick touted as a victory for school choice. States are allowed to opt out.
Tax on tips, OT, Social Security
The bill seeks to make good on a Trump promise to allow workers to deduct overtime (capped at $12,500) and tips (capped at $25,000) from taxable income, along with a deduction for up to $10,000 on new car loan interest.
But Democrats mocked the provisions, arguing that the caps were too small and that the benefits would be offset in many families who could see their health care costs and grocery bills rise if they lose their health or SNAP coverage.
And unlike the permanent extensions of tax cuts that disproportionately benefit the wealthy and corporations, the provisions on tips, overtime and car loans that Trump pledged repeatedly during the campaign expire after 2028.
Jennifer Bradford, 39, has tended bar and waited tables at Caliente Pizza & Draft House in Bloomfield for five months and said she makes most of her income off tips.
She called the bill’s no tax on tips provision an "insignificant breadcrumb” meant to distract restaurant staff from hikes in prices caused by tariffs and a “fear culture” fostered by Trump-era immigration policies.
“We are deporting our migrant workers, the cost of cheese has tripled,” she said Saturday, adding, “I’m lucky enough to fall into a demographic where I don’t have to be in mortal fear because of what’s in that bill.”
She said her initial reaction to the bill was “angry bewilderment.”
“It’s meant to be confusing,” she said. “It might not be affecting me personally at this moment, but it will – if anybody has their freedoms under threat, none of us are free.”
Hospitals
At least 11 hospitals in Western Pennsylvania — seven owned by UPMC — would see funding cuts totaling $467.7 million over the next decade, the Harrisburg-based Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania found.
State-directed payment provisions in the bill would reduce Pennsylvania hospital payments by about $4.5 billion over the next decade, according to HAP, which said the bill would “destabilize Pennsylvania hospitals and communities.”
Energy
Republicans and energy industry leaders say the bill includes several beneficial provisions for Pennsylvania.
Democrats and environmental groups disagree, with Mr. Shapiro and others saying the targeting of clean energy tax credits will cost the state jobs and potentially spike utility bills.
The bill provides investments and beneficial tax changes for oil and gas companies, as well as companies in nuclear, hydrogen, geothermal and carbon capture. It also allows for expedited environmental reviews for energy projects.
Mr. McCormick, who is poised to host Trump in Pittsburgh for an energy summit July 15, said the bill will help to unleash “energy dominance” in a way that can help Pennsylvania.
Mike Sommers, president and CEO of the American Petroleum Institute, previously told the Post-Gazette that the Trump administration would help Pennsylvania by opening the door to more liquefied natural gas exports and streamlined permitting.
“This historic legislation will help usher in a new era of energy dominance by unlocking opportunities for investment, opening lease sales and expanding access to oil and natural gas development,” Mr. Sommers said in a statement.
The bill eliminates or phases out hundreds of billions of dollars linked with climate change action plans and environmental justice grants, and it rescinds funds or tax credits and deductions meant for energy efficiency, clean vehicles, solar, wind and geothermal. These changes could cost Pennsylvania more than $6 billion in future projects and 26,000 jobs, Mr. Shapiro says.
With Trump and the GOP backing the fossil fuel industry, the bill calls for an almost $200 billion phaseout of tax credits for investments in zero-emissions electricity sources, starting next year.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.