WASHINGTON — A Turtle Creek plant is expanding, creating 1,000 new jobs. Amtrak plans a second daily roundtrip between Pittsburgh and Philadelphia. Almost $1 billion will go to expand Montgomery Locks and accommodate new, larger barges for river freight transport.
All are significant economic investments in Western Pennsylvania.
But voters in November weren’t impressed. Some question how much they were even aware. Voters continued to see high prices at the supermarket and voted to return Donald Trump to the White House despite record job growth, record stock market earnings and $1 trillion in private investment spurred by President Joe Biden’s infrastructure, clean energy and manufacturing laws.
“It’s a disconnect that voters had about perception versus reality on the economy,” Rutgers University pollster Ashley Koning said. “This was a big problem for the Biden administration. The message was not getting across to the voters and politics is all about messaging. If they're still not seeing change in their own wallets and pocketbooks, then it doesn't matter how much the administration has done in the past four years.”
Just last Friday, the U.S. Labor Department announced that the economy had added 227,000 jobs. President Biden recently took what may be his final victory lap before leaving office next month.
As Democrats grabble with the results of the November election, that disconnect is key.
Read More
Berwood Yost, director of the Franklin & Marshall College poll, said Democrats should have been listing specific accomplishments rather than talking generally about the economy.
“Instead of talking about things the administration did, they accepted the narrative that people were dissatisfied,” he said. “Instead of talking generally about the economy, you could talk about specific plans or policies that directly affected local communities. …How many bridges were rebuilt? How many roads were repaved? Those were the specific kinds of messages they needed.”
For example, Americans initially didn’t like the Affordable Care Act — until Democrats talked about details like protections for pre-existing conditions or allowing children to remain on their parents’ health plans until they were 26.
“When you talked about the specific things that were included, people were wildly supportive,” Mr. Yost said.
Administration officials traipsed through Pennsylvania, the most populous swing state, announcing billions of dollars in federal spending. Among the highlights:
— $4.3 billion in private sector investment in industries such as batteries, semiconductor manufacturing and clean energy. Eos Energy Enterprises is spending $500 million to expand a battery manufacturing facility in Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania, creating 1,000 new jobs.
— $15 billion for roads, bridges and other infrastructure, including $6.7 million to help raise the seawall between Parkway East (I-376) and the Monongahela River along the stretch of highway known as the Bathtub. That was in addition to $142.3 million for improvements to I-376, nearby highways and the Martin Luther King Jr. East Busway, which Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg announced on a trip to Pittsburgh in January.
— $143 million for improvements to the tracks that connect Pittsburgh to Harrisburg and Philadelphia, enabling Amtrak to begin twice-daily service between the cities.
— $961 million to improve and expand the Montgomery Locks on the Ohio River to accommodate modern, larger barges. The work would support 13,400 jobs.
— $925 million for a hydrogen hub in Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Kentucky, known as Arch2, to produce clean hydrogen and reduce carbon emissions. The effort would create 18,000 construction jobs and 3,000 permanent jobs.
— $1.3 billion to improve clean water, including $394.6 million to remove lead pipes. Vice President Kamala Harris traveled to Pittsburgh twice to tout the efforts to replace the lead-lined water lines.
— More than 565,300 new jobs were created in the state, 95,700 Pennsylvanians saw $4.9 billion of their student debt canceled, and 2.9 million Medicare beneficiaries would see lower prescription drug costs, according to the White House.
Even Democrats acknowledge that the message never got through.
“The problem is we don’t know how to communicate,” Democratic consultant Julie Roginsky said. “Part of the problem is they spent no time communicating with voters and meeting them where they're at. That is a massive problem for the party. Unless the Democratic Party decides to change course immediately, we will continue losing elections.”
Longtime Philadelphia-based Democratic strategist and ad maker J.J. Balaban said the administration needed to repeat its accomplishments over and over again.
“The people who needed to hear it didn’t hear it, and it turns out that putting out press releases in today's environment is insufficient to the task at hand,” Mr. Balaban said. “If you hear about something only once, it’s not necessarily credible. The next time there’s a Democratic president, there will be more thought into how an administration's accomplishments are really heard by the people.”
All that talk of job growth, low unemployment, and rising stocks didn’t resonate with voters, said Christopher Borick, a political science professor who directs the Muhlenberg College poll.
“The difference between what macroeconomic indicators say and what the public says is crucial,” Mr. Borick said. “In the last few years, those measures have really not been as aligned as they historically have been. That, of course, was to the dismay of Democrats in the last cycle.”
Mr. Borick said that people are still feeling the effects of the high inflation that erupted as the U.S. rebounded from the pandemic.
“There is a big disconnect that we see because of the impact of the inflationary period that Americans were exposed to for the first time in generations, leaving some scars,” Mr. Borick said. “Those scars don't heal quickly. It certainly wasn’t in time for Democrats to benefit.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.