After one of the most intense campaigns in history, former President Donald John Trump captured the White House for a second time, ending Vice President Kamala Harris’ bid to ascend to the presidency.
The win, which the Associated Press called in the early hours of the morning on Wednesday, makes him only the second person in history to win the office in two nonconsecutive elections — both times carrying the crucial battleground of Pennsylvania.
Republicans also won control of the U.S. Senate, and Trump predicted they would hold the House as well, which would give the party unified control of the federal government.
“America has given us an unprecedented and powerful mandate,” Trump said in a speech declaring victory early Wednesday morning in West Palm Beach, Fla. “This will truly be a golden age of America.”
The results came after voters swamped the polls across a tense and deeply divided country on Tuesday in a high-turnout election that came down to a handful of closely divided battleground states.
The historic choice — between Ms. Harris, who would have been the first Black and Asian woman elected president, and Trump, a twice-impeached ex-president — swung in Trump’s direction by slim margins, similar to his narrow 2016 win over Hillary Clinton.
Read More
For the second time in three elections, the so-called Blue Wall of Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin — a Democratic bulwark against Republican gains elsewhere in the country — has crumbled.
Trump also won the swing states of Georgia and North Carolina, and was leading in the battleground states of Arizona and Nevada, leaving open the possibility that he would sweep all seven of the most closely divided states in the country.
From Pittsburgh to Philadelphia, and throughout the vast rural swaths of a swing state that has been blanketed by the campaigns, people stood in lines that stretched through parking lots and around city blocks, sometimes waiting hours to vote.
For months, the polls showed a race that remained deadlocked through a series of historic shakeups: a former president convicted of felonies and awaiting trial on other charges; an attempted assassination in Butler and another thwarted in Florida; the sitting president dropping out with only a few months left in the race; the elevation of Ms. Harris to be the party nominee, despite never having won a single Democratic primary.
“We like to throw around the word unprecedented, but this really is unprecedented,” said Republican consultant Nachama Soloveichik, the communications director for former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley’s unsuccessful campaign for the 2024 GOP presidential nomination.
Ms. Harris appeared to be doing worse among Black voters than President Joe Biden did four years ago, winning them 90% to 9%, according to early exit polls reported by NBC. Mr. Biden had a 93% to 7% advantage over Trump in 2020.
But the largest difference appeared to be a dropoff in Hispanic support, where she was winning that key voting bloc by only 57% to Trump’s 42%, compared with Mr. Biden’s 69% to 27% edge.
And while she carried female voters by 55% to 43%, Trump won male voters by 57% to 41% — up from 55% to 44% four years ago, the polls show.
In Pennsylvania, “multiple” polling locations and municipal buildings received bomb threats, but there was “no credible threat to the public,” Gov. Josh Shapiro said shortly after polls closed.
A judge of elections in Fayette County attempted to defy state law and conduct a hand count of ballots, prompting a state judge to order him to comply with the law — or have a sheriff escort the ballots and a poll worker to the county’s main counting facility.
In Cambria County, voting machine malfunctions led another judge to extend voting hours there from 8 p.m. to 10 p.m.
Despite a few isolated incidents, however, voting unfolded relatively smoothly around the country.
The thin margin separating the candidates comes after a frantic sprint to Election Day by the campaigns, particularly in Pennsylvania.
Ms. Harris, who became the Democratic nominee after Mr. Biden withdrew from the race in July following a dismal debate performance that exacerbated concerns over his age, was counting on a massive get-out-the-vote operation to carry Pennsylvania’s 19 electoral votes, the biggest prize of the seven swing states.
That operation included 50 offices and almost 400 paid staffers.
She and her allies spent almost half a billion dollars nationwide on advertising through Oct. 27, according to the Wesleyan Media Project, with more than 70% of the ads focused on abortion and women’s rights.
In Pennsylvania alone, the Democrats and their allies spent more than $327 million in ads, including when Mr. Biden still was in the race, according to the ad-tracking firm AdImpact.
Republicans countered with more than $279 million, pushing total spending in the state to $600 million for the presidential race alone.
A stunning $92 million of that spending came during just the final week of the presidential campaign.
The money was part of more $1 billion in total campaign advertising that flooded Pennsylvania’s airwaves in races from the top of the ticket on down — more money than any state has ever seen in a single election cycle, according to AdImpact.
“Even before Biden stepped down, they had a plan to bring their voters to the polls,” Democratic consultant Glenn Totten said.
Just eight years ago, Trump shocked the world by carrying Pennsylvania and the other Blue Wall states, Michigan and Wisconsin, which also have large numbers of white, working-class voters. Mr. Biden, a native of Scranton, returned the three states to the Democratic column in 2020 but Ms. Harris was unable to hold the crucial coalition together.
In recent months, Trump and running mate Sen. JD Vance, R-Ohio, held rallies across the state, including a July event in Butler in which a gunman tried to assassinate him. Trump was grazed, one spectator was killed and two were seriously wounded.
Trump returned to the site for another rally in early October, accompanied by Elon Musk, the world’s richest man, who has spent more than $100 million to re-elect him.
Just the second president to win non-consecutive terms in U.S. history, Trump, at 78, would also be the oldest person to win the office.
Ms. Harris would have been only the fifth sitting vice president to ascend to the presidency (Mr. Biden, who served as Barack Obama’s vice president, had been out of office for four years before winning his term in 2020).
During the campaign, Ms. Harris emphasized her support for abortion rights following the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision overturning Roe v. Wade. Trump had fulfilled a 2016 campaign promise and nominated three U.S. Supreme Court justices who voted to overturn the landmark decision, throwing the issue back to the states.
Outrage over the decision helped Democrats defy the polls and avoid a threatened Republican landslide in the 2022 midterms, and Ms. Harris counted on a massive turnout by female voters and others upset with the loss of their constitutional right.
Trump focused on immigration, promising to deport millions of unauthorized migrants in speeches that became increasingly dark as the campaign wore on. He called the border crossings an invasion, and said immigrants were “poisoning the blood of our country.”
In recent months, Trump raised more alarm when he promised to go after his political opponents, including suggesting that former Republican U.S. Rep. Liz Cheney, of Wyoming, who investigated the Jan. 6 insurrection and later endorsed Ms. Harris, have guns “trained on her face.”
“The advantage of Trump’s persona is he has crafted this personality that allows for people to say, ‘Well, that’s Trump.’” Ms. Soloveichik said. “It’s sort of baked into the cake.”
Polls showed voters trust Trump to handle immigration more than they do Ms. Harris, who was part of an administration that saw a record surge of migrants crossing the border.
And on the economy — the top issue for many — the high inflation that followed the pandemic during the early years of the Biden administration continued to weigh on voters’ minds. Polls showed Ms. Harris had improved her standing with those voters during her abbreviated campaign, but many still preferred Trump, who spent years carefully cultivating an image as a successful businessman.
“No matter what your nationality or race, you still have to put food on the table and gas in your car,” Republican strategist Vince Galko said. “Do you feel you're better than you were four years ago? …They can live with his antics and his rhetoric as long as he’ll go down there and get things back on the right track.”
Mr. Biden’s efforts to tout the economic progress over the last four years fell on deaf ears. Even though more than 16 million jobs were created during that time, unemployment was near record lows and inflation was down to pre-pandemic levels, the perception of a dismal economy never faded.
“It’s really about people’s perceptions when they get to the grocery store and pay their bills. It’s not about the latest quarter’s GDP,” Ms. Soloveichik said. “Even when the inflation rate goes down, it doesn't erase inflation. Nothing goes back to costing what it did four years ago and people still remember what it cost four years ago.“
Ms. Harris acknowledged the higher prices, and her campaign focused on proposals she said were designed to lower costs, including an expanded Child Tax Credit, federal help for down payments for first-time home buyers, a $50,000 tax credit for new small businesses, and a middle-class tax cut.
Economic concerns were top of mind for voters in Appalachia and the Midwest, areas of the country that were a key focus for both campaigns.
Ms. Harris bypassed Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro as her pick for vice president, but chose Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, who had strong union support and had a history of getting backing from the working-class and rural voters during his races for the U.S. House and governor.
Trump picked Mr. Vance with an eye toward wooing those same working-class voters in Pennsylvania that he represented in neighboring Ohio.
Trump also sought to increase his support among traditional Democratic constituencies including Blacks, Latinos and Jews.
But Trump was making what Democratic consultant Modia Butler called “unforced error after unforced error.”
During his only debate with Ms. Harris, he falsely claimed that Haitians who had emigrated legally to Springfield, Ohio, were eating their neighbors’ cats and dogs.
Then, a speaker at a Trump rally at Madison Square Garden described Puerto Rico as “a floating island of garbage in the middle of the ocean.”
While the comment personally offended many Puerto Ricans, and prompted celebrities to endorse Ms. Harris in the race’s final weeks, it’s unclear whether that swayed enough voters in key states.
In the closing weeks of the campaign, second gentleman Douglas Emhoff, who is Jewish, came to Pittsburgh and marked the sixth anniversary of the worst antisemitic attack in U.S. history by pledging that Ms. Harris would “continue to stand with Israel and with the Jewish community — our community” and “reject antisemitic hate and the notion that Israel does not have the right to exist.”
At the same time, many Arab Americans, upset over U.S. support for Israel after the Jewish state unleashed a fierce response to an attack launched by Hamas on Oct. 7, 2023, threatened to oppose Ms. Harris.
Ms. Harris received endorsements from hundreds of Republican officials, many of whom served in the Trump administration. Former Vice President Dick Cheney said he would vote for her, and his daughter, former Rep. Liz Cheney, R-Wyo., campaigned alongside her.
She painted Trump as a danger to democracy, at one point agreeing with his former White House chief of staff, John F. Kelly, and his former chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, retired Gen. Mark A. Milley, that he could be described as “fascist.”
Ms. Harris delivered her closing argument Oct. 29 at the same Washington, D.C., site within view of the White House that Trump spoke at on Jan. 6, 2021, when he first urged rally goers to “peacefully and patriotically make your voices heard” and then told them to "fight like hell. And if you don't fight like hell, you're not going to have a country anymore.”
Trump’s closing rally at Madison Square Garden featured antisemitic and racist remarks that led his critics to draw comparisons to the 1939 pro-Nazi rally at the original Garden.
“Nobody goes into an event of that magnitude without having a pretty good idea of what was going to be said,’’ Mr. Totten said. “It was not just that one remark. The language in that assembly was absolutely beyond the pale.”
But on the campaign trail, Trump’s stump speech sought to bring the conversation back to pocketbook issues, beginning with the question famously asked by Ronald Reagan in his 1980 campaign against Jimmy Carter.
“Are you better off now than you were four years ago?”
Mike Wereschagin contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.