WASHINGTON — The House of Representatives on Tuesday voted in favor of repealing a Biden administration energy rule that lawmakers and industry leaders applauded last month but that a Western Pennsylvania congressman says still threatens a Butler County electrical steel plant.

The Department of Energy’s latest standards on the steel manufactured for electricity distribution transformers, which play a critical role in the nation’s power grid, were announced in early April. The agency called for a reduction in the current market dominance of grain-oriented electric steel — made in just one domestic facility operated by Cleveland-Cliffs, in Butler — from 95% to 75%, while carving out a smaller share for newer amorphous metal products over the next five years. 

The rule was seen as a compromise after the Energy Department faced robust bipartisan opposition to an initial proposal last year that suggested a near total swap to amorphous steel in just three years — a move that would have placed the Butler plant and its 1,300 workers at risk. 

But U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, said the revised rule still was not good enough, and that he did not trust the Biden administration’s track record on domestic energy production. His proposed amendment to repeal the rule — attached to a Republican-led bill seeking to blunt Biden administration efficiency standards for home appliances — passed the House Tuesday in a 208-199 vote. 

Advertise with us

“The elimination of this product would eliminate that town,” Mr. Kelly said in a fiery speech on the House floor, standing next to a photo of a transformer on a utility pole. 

He characterized the administration’s agenda as “dumb-headed rule after dumb-headed rule in some type of a make-up fantasy world that this is better. It’s not better.”

The Energy Department is pushing to improve the efficiency of transformers, which help deliver power from high-voltage lines to residential and commercial lines by varying voltage as needed. 

The revised rule, which was delayed from taking effect until 2029, came as a relief to the hundreds of steelworkers, bipartisan lawmakers, Cleveland Cliffs and several industry and labor groups. Gov Josh Shapiro and several lawmakers on both sides of the aisle, including Mr. Kelly, had pressed the Biden administration to protect the jobs at the Butler plant. 

Rep. Frank Pallone Jr., D-N.J., the top Democrat on the House Energy and Commerce Committee, expressed confusion that Mr. Kelly had joined others who celebrated the rule last month only to try to shoot it down on Capitol Hill Tuesday.

Advertise with us

“Any improvements in efficiency can translate to massive energy and cost savings,” Mr. Pallone said. 

He added that the Energy Department “spent 15 months listening” to utilities, manufacturers, industry and labor groups and everyday Americans and “took the feedback very seriously.”

“The final product worked out for everyone,” he said. 

But Mr. Kelly said the long-term life of the Butler plant remained threatened if the rule takes effect as is, because it still calls for a reduction of traditional steel at a time when transformers are in short supply. 

"I said it then and I'll say it again: I was encouraged by the Department of Energy's final rule, but I was not satisfied," Mr. Kelly said in a statement after the vote. "The Biden administration's track record on domestic energy policy gives me zero reassurance that they will support these 1,300 workers or the Butler community when this final rule takes effect.”

Advertise with us

Cliffs CEO Lourenco Goncalves said last month that he was grateful the Energy Department was receptive to feedback and “adopted major changes” that he expects to increase demand for the company’s product.

The White House on Monday criticized the Republicans’ bill on home appliances efficiency, saying the Energy Department’s regularly-improved standards have saved consumers “an estimated $1 trillion on utility bills, with an average household currently saving $321 annually.” 

The bill effectively would be dead on arrival if it reached President Joe Biden’s desk, which already is unlikely given that Democrats control the Senate.

“This administration is working to issue updated standards that could deliver an additional $1 trillion in savings over 30 years,” the White House said,” arguing the House bill “would threaten these continued savings and create an uneven playing field for American manufacturers.”

Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com: @BenKail