WASHINGTON — Pennsylvania politicians were divided on the $118 billion proposal that would have tightened U.S. border security, with Republicans saying the deal failed to secure the border and Democrats accusing the GOP of buckling under pressure from former President Donald Trump and sabotaging a rare bipartisan effort to crack down on illegal immigration.
The bill, unveiled by a bipartisan group of senators Sunday, would have made it significantly tougher to claim asylum, provided resources for detention, removal, asylum processing and immigration courts, and included $20 billion for new border security agents and asylum officers. The deal also would have created more visas for families and workers, provided funding to reimburse cities and states grappling with an increase in border arrivals, and expanded legal pathways for the children of immigrant workers.
The compromise — packaged with tens of billions of dollars in security assistance to Ukraine and Israel — was killed during a procedural vote Wednesday in the Senate; Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., already had declared it “dead on arrival” in the House.
The bill fell 11 votes shy of the 60 needed to advance to debate Wednesday, but lawmakers say they’ll likely try again later this year. A handful of Democrats who viewed the bill as too restrictive voted against it, while four Republicans including Susan Collins of Maine and Mitt Romney of Utah, voted in favor.
The bill came as immigration, fentanyl and the economy take center stage in an election year in Pennsylvania, where a heated and likely expensive Senate race could help determine which party controls Congress and where winning is pivotal for the campaigns of Mr. Trump and President Joe Biden. It also arose as Allegheny County juggles record immigration court cases and Western Pennsylvania faces declining population and a dire need for migrant workers, according to experts and immigration advocates.
Monica Ruiz, executive director of the Pittsburgh nonprofit Casa San Jose, told the Post-Gazette that both the state’s economy and immigrants striving to live and work in the region legally are caught in a “political ping pong” without comprehensive, humane legislation.
Read More
“We have such a decline in population and workforce, how can we have healthy communities if we don’t have young people in them?” she said. “We have to provide better pathways for folks to come here so they aren’t forced to risk their lives to come here. And then provide resources to places like Pittsburgh or Allegheny County to help support folks that are migrating.”
Michelle Mittelstadt, spokeswoman for the Migration Policy Institute, a Washington, D.C. think tank, said the nonpartisan group does not take a position on legislation. But she said the bipartisan proposal marked “the first time in more than a decade that the Senate has sought to tackle immigration, and as such represents a serious effort.”
U.S. Sen. John Fetterman, who has encouraged fellow Democrats to engage on border security while making headlines after garnering support from conservatives over his staunch backing of Israel, slammed the Republican Party on Tuesday for largely dismissing the bipartisan immigration bill.
“The supreme irony of my career,” he posted on X. “During the 2022 campaign, the GOP bludgeoned me as a socialist with [an agenda] for an open border. Now I’m here in the Senate demanding a secure border and they won’t take yes for an answer.”
Sen. Bob Casey, a three-term Democratic incumbent up for re-election in November, highlighted the bill’s inclusion of major provisions in his Stop Fentanyl at the Border Act and the bipartisan FEND Off Fentanyl Act, which would declare a national emergency and ramp up sanctions on cartels and linked traffickers or money launderers in Mexico or China.
“This bipartisan bill provides critical steps towards securing our southern border, stopping fentanyl from coming into our nation and destroying Pennsylvania communities, and cracking down on the transnational criminal organizations in the fentanyl supply chain,” Mr. Casey said in a statement before the vote. “It also provides key assistance to Ukraine in the war against Vladimir Putin and to Israel as it works to defeat Hamas, while providing much-needed humanitarian assistance to civilians in Gaza, the West Bank, and around the world.”
But Mr. Casey’s likely Republican opponent, former hedge fund CEO David McCormick, said he opposed the deal.
“This is not a compromise, it’s a capitulation,” said Mr. McCormick, a former George W. Bush administration official, on X. “To protect Americans and fight the scourge of fentanyl, we need to CLOSE the border to illegal immigration.”
U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters, described the bill as “a failing president’s half-baked immigration plan to save his pathetic re-election campaign.”
“Over the past three years, President Biden has systematically destroyed our national security and opened our borders, allowing human traffickers and drug cartels to thrive,” he said. “Any legislation that tolerates a single illegal border crossing into our nation is unacceptable.”
U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, said the bill was more of a foreign aid package “with half of the funding earmarked for Ukraine, not for our borders.”
"This bill does not go nearly far enough to secure our nation's borders, to curb illegal immigration, or to curb illegal human and drug trafficking,” Mr. Kelly said.
Several Republicans have claimed the bill would allow thousands of migrants to cross the border illegally every day. But the bill empowered the president to effectively close the border altogether to entrants seeking asylum if an average of more than 5,000 try to cross unlawfully over the course of a week.
On the Senate floor before the vote Wednesday, an exasperated Sen. James Lankford, R-Okla., sighed as he shot down a series of assertions and misperceptions on the bipartisan bill and called the notion that it allows in 5,000 illegal immigrants daily “completely absurd.”
“It would lead to reduced unauthorized entries because it mandates a higher bar to be considered for asylum and puts in place a swifter screening process with limits on review in case of denial,” Ms. Mittelstadt said. “And there are increased capacities for detention and removal.”
The bill came a month after U.S. Rep. Glenn Thompson and other Republicans returned from a trip to the U.S.-Mexico border and pressed Congress to act on border security. Mr. Thompson said Biden administration policies — including ending Mr. Trump’s policy requiring those seeking asylum to remain in Mexico while applications are processed — paved the way for a surge of migrants.
“It really is a crisis of epic proportions,” Mr. Thompson, R-Centre, said.
But Democrats have refused to consider a bill that has none of their priorities, such as allowing those brought to the U.S. as children — the so-called Dreamers –- to legally remain in the country in which they grew up.
And White House officials point out that House Republicans, as they threatened multiple government shutdowns, demanded cuts that would have left Border Patrol with thousands fewer agents.
Mr. Biden and leading Democrats this week said Republicans were doing Mr. Trump’s bidding as he seeks to deny Mr. Biden a major policy victory ahead of November.
“If the bill fails, I want to be absolutely clear about something: The American people are going to know why it fails,” Mr. Biden said Tuesday at the White House. “I'll be taking this issue to the country … the American people are going to know the reason the border is not secure is Donald Trump.”
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., said Wednesday that the package came about after bipartisan negotiators “worked themselves to the bone” for months after Republicans demanded that lawmakers work on border security before approving aid to Ukraine. He accused GOP lawmakers who’ve criticized the bill of “[cowing] to Donald Trump’s orders.”
“We face tremendous security challenges at home at our southern border and across the globe — including in Israel, Gaza, Ukraine and the Indo-Pacific,” Rep. Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall, said. “Yet House Republicans refuse to meet the moment and put country over party. Instead, they are rejecting a comprehensive, bipartisan proposal to tackle these problems in favor of unserious and purely partisan ploys.”
Ms. Mittelstadt said even if Congress could agree on a narrower deal focused on border security resources, major reforms would still be needed, including improvements to asylum processing where “years-long delays” are leaving people in limbo while others who can’t access other legal pathways add to the asylum application backlog.
“The current border control system remains pointed to yesterday’s challenges — an era dominated by unauthorized Mexican single adults — and cannot effectively address today’s sharply changed picture of a very diverse set of nationalities, families and unaccompanied children unless spending is accompanied by very significant system reform that can only be done through statutory changes,” she added. “This diversification of nationalities, as well as the fact that families and unaccompanied minors represent large shares of the flows, hold deep consequences for the border control system because the U.S. does not have the ability to remove or detain them.”
That shift in the immigration landscape is playing out in Allegheny County, according to Ms. Ruiz.
“Ten years ago, we were seeing a lot of people from Mexico,” she said. “Within the last five years or so, we’ve seen a lot of people from El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador and Brazil.”
In Allegheny County — where there is no longer an operating immigration court — officials expect a historic wave of court cases to continue. The number of new cases last year more than doubled the 1,203 cases filed in Allegheny County in 2022.
Casa San Jose opened its office up last year to host virtual court hearings once a week for those who do not have access to the internet or need help navigating the immigration system.
“We’re seeing a lot more of that happening,” Ms. Ruiz said. “It’s not that these people are running across the border and sneaking in. They’re coming bringing documents and want to prove they have good cases. The backlog is just so backed up.”
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com; @BenKail





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.