WASHINGTON — Call it the battle of the tax cuts.
Western Pennsylvania’s lawmakers are on opposite sides as the U.S. House debates whether — and how — to cut taxes.
The House Ways and Means Committee, including Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, passed a series of three bills June 13 to roll back the corporate tax increases in former President Donald Trump’s 2017 tax law, and to add a bonus of $2,000 for individuals and $4,000 for couples on top of the current standard deduction. Both provisions would expire in 2025 along with the individual tax cuts in the Trump tax law.
Reps. Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall, and Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, instead are co-sponsoring competing legislation to expand the Child Tax Credit. The credit was increased for one year under President Joe Biden’s COVID-19 stimulus law.
The tax cuts being proposed by the GOP could increase the federal deficit by as much as $1 trillion — right after House Republicans brought the government to the brink of default by demanding spending cuts in exchange for suspending the debt ceiling to pay for programs already approved by Congress. That law would reduce government spending by around $1.5 trillion over a decade, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office.
“It is curious timing,” said Kris Cox, deputy director of federal tax policy at the progressive Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
Mr. Kelly, chair of the tax subcommittee, said the new legislation would help the economy. He cited provisions such as creating tax-favored economic opportunity zones in rural areas.
“This new package of legislation builds upon the 2017 tax reform law that created the greatest economy this country had seen in more than a half century,” Mr. Kelly said. “By and large, the package will help families and businesses alike by cutting red tape implemented by the Biden administration so we can create jobs and expand American energy production. This package is in line with my promise to my constituents – I will always fight for pro-growth, commonsense legislation that grows our economy and puts America and American taxpayers first.”
The GOP bill would shrink the federal deficit for two years because the Republicans propose funding it by eliminating the clean energy tax breaks in Mr. Biden’s climate change law. The GOP unsuccessfully sought to cut that spending in the debt ceiling fight.
Having the bill expire in two years allows Republicans to “hide the true cost of tax cuts,” said Steve Wamhoff, director of federal tax policy for the progressive Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy.
“Congress just finished a big debate about the debt ceiling, where people claimed the federal debt and federal deficits were out of control,” Mr. Wamhoff said. “They need to make it appear that it will not increase the deficit.”
But it will, analysts said. Making the new tax cuts permanent would raise the federal deficit by $1.1 trillion over 10 years, according to the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget.
“It’s not actually paid for,” Mr. Wamhoff said. “The tax cuts are going to cost a lot more.”
Making the 2017 Republican tax law permanent would increase the deficit by another $3.5 trillion over a decade, according to the Congressional Budget Office.
Mr. Kelly blamed the deficits on increased spending, not tax cuts.
“Since the 2017 tax reform law passed, the federal government has actually received record revenues,” Mr. Kelly said. “At nearly $5 trillion last year, revenues are higher than they were when we passed the 2017 tax reform law. The deficit has ballooned under the Biden administration because of the Biden administration, not because of the tax reform packages that grow the economy.”
The debate is being waged two years before what’s expected to be a more heated discussion about what to do with the Trump tax cuts. While most of the bill’s corporate reductions were made permanent, tax cuts for individuals are set to expire at the end of 2025.
The new proposal rescinds some of the business tax hikes that were included in the Trump tax law to partially offset the cost of the corporate tax cuts. Even with those increases, the Congressional Budget Office estimated that the Trump tax law initially would increase the federal deficit by $1.9 trillion over 10 years.
The new business tax breaks were combined with a proposal to increase the standard deduction for two years by $2,000 for individuals and $4,000 for couples. All those tax breaks, though, also would expire at the end of 2025 unless extended.
“Lots of tax policy is made temporary in the hope that those temporary provisions become permanent in the long run,” Ms. Cox said.
But “because the policies are temporary, they would not result in long-run growth for the economy, wages, or jobs,” according to the conservative Tax Foundation.
And the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy said 51% of the benefits would flow to the richest 20% of American taxpayers, while just 1% would go to the poorest 20%.
“There could be a meteor coming for Earth, and the GOP plan would be tax cuts for billionaires and huge corporations,” Mr. Deluzio said.
House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Jason Smith said the increased standard deduction would cut taxes for working families.
“In our hearings across the country, we have heard over and over how families need help putting food on their table, clothes on their backs, and gasoline in their cars,” said Mr. Smith, R-Mo.
At the same time, the clean energy tax breaks House Republicans want to repeal “overwhelmingly go to the wealthy, billion-dollar companies, and big banks,” he said.
Progressive groups, though, said the higher standard deduction was of little help to low-income Americans, most of whom don’t earn enough to take advantage of that tax break.
Almost one-third of the benefits of the bonus deduction would go to those earning between $139,700 and $307,300, according to ITEP, while just 15% would go to those earning under $50,800.
Under House Democrats’ Child Tax Credit legislation, 55% of the benefits would go to those making under $50,800 while 9% would go to those earning between $139,700 and $307,300, the ITEP analysis showed.
In Pennsylvania, just less than half — 49% — of the benefits of an expanded Child Tax Credit would go to those making less than $50,800 a year, according to ITEP. That includes 817,577 adults and 757,377 children.
The legislation would increase the credit from $2,000 to $3,600 for children under 6 and to $3,000 to those aged 6-17. In addition, Americans who qualify would get the entire credit no matter how much they earned. The credit would be phased out beginning at $112,500 for single parents and $150,000 for married couples.
During the pandemic, the higher Child Tax Credit cut child poverty in half, ITEP said.
“Our position is the Child Tax Credit is one of the most important ways to help children and families with low incomes,” Ms. Cox said. “The Child Tax Credit should be the top tax priority for any tax legislation that moves.”
That’s the same benefit included in the 2021 stimulus law passed over unanimous Republican opposition and was a major help to poorer families through the pandemic, Ms. Cox said.
“We did see significant benefits coming out of that for children and families,” Ms. Cox said. “We saw families spend their monthly payments on basic needs and we saw significant drops in poverty.”
In the last Congress, Democrats expressed a willingness to approve some corporate tax breaks if Republicans agreed to expand the Child Tax Credit. They could not strike a deal. A permanent Child Tax Credit would add $1.6 trillion to the deficit over 10 years, the CBO said.
“That was a dynamic we saw last year with corporate tax breaks not moving,” Ms. Cox said. “House Republicans have have shown their priorities to be moving the corporate tax breaks without the Child Tax Credit. The bottom line is this tax package prioritizes corporate shareholders and leaves children behind.”
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.