WASHINGTON — Got whole milk?

If U.S. Rep. Glenn Thompson has his way, the answer in schools will again be yes.

Mr. Thompson, chair of the House Agriculture Committee, is the lead sponsor of the Whole Milk for Healthy Kids Act, which again would allow schools to offer whole full-fat milk — or milk with 3.25% milk fat. The House Education and Workforce Committee passed the legislation June 6.

He said the legislation could boost milk consumption and support an industry that, according to the Center for Dairy Excellence in Harrisburg, contributes $12 billion to the state’s economy and supports 47,000 jobs. Pennsylvania ranks 8th in total milk production in the U.S. and has more dairy farms than any state except Wisconsin.

Advertise with us
U.S. Rep. Glenn Thompson, R-Centre. (AP Photo / Keith Srakocic)

“Bad federal policy has kept whole milk out of our school cafeterias for too long,” Mr. Thompson, R-Centre, said in February when he introduced the bill with Rep. Kim Schrier, D-Was., a pediatrician. 

“In order for students to excel in the classroom,” Mr. Thompson said, “they must have access to proper nutrition. It is my hope the Whole Milk for Healthy Kids Act will give children a wide variety of milk options and bolster milk consumption — a win-win for growing children and America’s dairy farmers.”

The bill has been embraced by the dairy industry, which says that more children will drink milk if they can order the full-fat version. In an interview last week, Mr. Thompson said many kids don’t like the taste of fat-free or low-fat milk, leading them to drink sugary beverages such as soda or fruit drinks instead.

But the American Association of Pediatrics says school meal requirements should continue to be aligned with the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, which recommends fat-free and low-fat dairy products.

And Samuel Hahn, a policy coordinator on the school foods team of the Center for Science in the Public Interest, said the guidelines are clear.

Advertise with us

“Anybody who’s two years old and older should only be drinking fat-free and low-fat milk,” Mr. Hahn said. “Kids get a lot of nutrients from milk. But they get that from fat-free milk as much as they get from whole milk. The only thing whole milk adds is empty calories from saturated fat.”

Schools have been required to serve only fat-free or low-fat (1%) milk since the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act became law in 2010. That was part of an effort to combat obesity in children by mandating lower-fat products in federally funded school lunch programs. 

The school breakfast and lunch programs for low-income children supply 77% of the milk that enrolled students drink, according to a USDA study.

Mr. Thompson first introduced the bill in 2021 but it went nowhere in the Democratic-controlled House. He tried again this year, attracting 109 co-sponsors, including fellow Western Pennsylvania Reps. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, and Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters.

And with Republicans in control, the measure reached the House floor.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes it just takes time to get good legislation passed,” said Mr. Thompson, who received more campaign donations from the dairy industry than any other member of Congress during the last election — $75,610, according to the research group OpenSecrets.

Milk producers and groups have lined up behind the bill, including the Center for Dairy Excellence

“Students take less milk and throw away more milk in schools when they do not have milk variety options they like,” the groups wrote in a letter.

Mr. Hahn said chocolate or other flavored milks, not fat content, drives consumption in kids. As long as the flavored milk is low in added sugars, Mr. Hahn said his group is fine with it. The federal guidelines allow schools to offer fat-free or 1% flavored milks, though the U.S. Department of Agriculture is considering a proposal to limit flavored milk to high schoolers.

As for undrunk milk, Mr. Hahn said that’s because kids don’t have enough time to finish their meals, not because the beverage is fat free.

Advertise with us

“We think the best way to address that is not to roll back nutrition standards but give kids the time they need to sit down and eat,” Mr. Hahn said

Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant