Chris Christie tried to ride his tough-talking persona to the White House eight years ago. He was the politician who traded insults with hecklers and told it like it was.

Then came Donald Trump, who talked even tougher, threatened to beat up hecklers and was more blunt than the former New Jersey governor ever was. Mr. Trump won the Republican nomination and the presidency. Mr. Christie became a television commentator.

Now the two men, once friends and political allies, are squaring off again for the Republican nomination, with Mr. Christie joining the race Tuesday. Former Vice President Mike Pence filed paperwork to run Monday, with a formal announcement expected to come Wednesday. North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum also could join the increasingly crowded field this week.

Unlike the others, Mr. Christie — who in 2016 decimated U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida at a GOP debate and later led an eruption of "Lock her up!" against Hillary Clinton at the Republican convention — is aiming directly at Mr. Trump.

Advertise with us

“There is no path other than going through Trump,” said Mike DuHaime, a Republican strategist from New Jersey who is advising Mr. Christie’s presidential campaign. “Right now, so many people in the race are dancing around Trump and are afraid to criticize him directly. They’re afraid to offend his voters.”

Former U.S. Rep. Charlie Dent, a Republican who represented the Lehigh Valley, said Mr. Christie is doing exactly what he has to do. 

“He’s pulling the gloves off. He’s going into attack mode,” Mr. Dent said. “He understands that in order to win, you have to present a vision and take on Donald Trump directly.”

“I think everyone expects him to deliver pointed contrast,” agreed Harrison Neely, another New Jersey-based Republican consultant.

The same “telling it like it is” slogan that adorned his 2016 campaign website will lend its name to his allied super PAC for the 2024 campaign. Bill Palatucci, a Republican national committeeman from New Jersey who’s leading the outside group, said it’s an obvious name for the PAC.

Advertise with us

“The governor’s reputation for telling it like it is is well known,” said Mr. Palatucci, a former law partner of Mr. Christie’s who chaired his successful 2015 re-election campaign.

Mr. Christie has the advantage of having done this before. He’s the only candidate other than Mr. Trump who previously ran for president. He’s the only candidate who knocked off a strong Democratic incumbent, ousting Gov. Jon Corzine in 2009. And he’s gotten the band back together for this run.

“Experience matters a lot in presidential politics,” said Alex Conant, a Washington-based Republican consultant who has advised Mr. Rubio and isn’t aligned with a candidate this time. “It’s a real advantage. He also has the most experienced team surrounding him, which is not to be underestimated.”

In the meantime, the former president only has gotten stronger in the polls despite an indictment for allegedly falsifying business records to cover up a hush-money payment, a jury verdict in a civil case finding him liable for sexual abuse, and ongoing criminal investigations into his handling of classified documents and his attempts to stay in power after losing the 2020 election.

“Christie is going to be willing to throw whatever he can against Donald Trump,” said Patrick Murray, a pollster at Monmouth University in New Jersey. “The real question, is there anything you can come up with that will hurt Donald Trump? We haven’t seen it yet.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Christie is well equipped to come up with something. He distinguished himself during the 2016 presidential debates, even when his initially low standing in polls relegated him to a second-tier debate.

“He’s very good on his feet,” said former U.S. Rep. Leonard Lance, R-N.J., part of Mr. Christie’s 2016 campaign leadership team. “He would probably be the strongest debater on stage.”

Mr. Rubio can attest to that. After Mr. Rubio’s allied super PAC spent $4.9 million attacking him and curtailing his rise in pre-primary opinion polls, Mr. Christie went after the Florida senator in a debate shortly before the New Hampshire primary.

Under fire from Mr. Christie, Mr. Rubio robotically repeated the same stock lines that the former New Jersey governor ridiculed as "the memorized 25-second speech."

“Christie is a very gifted politician who knows how to throw a punch,” said Mr. Conant, who was Mr. Rubio’s spokesman during his presidential campaign.

Advertise with us

At the 2016 convention, Mr. Christie, a U.S. attorney before running for governor, was tapped to fire up the delegates by attacking Mrs. Clinton in a primetime speech.

“As a former federal prosecutor, I welcome the opportunity to hold her accountable for her performance and her character,” he said. “We must present those facts to you, a jury of her peers, both in this hall and in living rooms around our nation.”

Mr. Christie, though, brings plenty of negatives to the race as well. He left office with record-low approval ratings, and even now is anathema to many Republicans.

He was the only current or potential GOP presidential candidate in negative territory in a Monmouth University poll of Republican and Republican-leaning voters released May 30. Mr. Christie was viewed unfavorably by 47% and favorably by only 21%.

“He’s so disliked by a huge bunch of Republican voters, will they even listen to him?” Mr. Murray said of Christie.

Advertise with us

Many Republicans never forgave Mr. Christie for his embrace of Barack Obama when the president came to New Jersey before the 2012 election to tour the damage wrought by Hurricane Sandy.

And Mr. Christie was plagued by the scandal known as Bridgegate, when his political allies blocked traffic at the George Washington Bridge after the mayor of Fort Lee refused to support his re-election bid. Even after the U.S. Supreme Court threw out the convictions of Mr. Christie’s former aides, it didn’t change the narrative.

“On the surface, it looks like a scandal that's very easy for others to understand,” said Ashley Koning, a pollster and professor at Rutgers University in New Jersey. “It’s about traffic. It could be a very easy issue for any of the other contenders to pick up and use against him.”

Then again, Mr. Christie started his first run for president with the same negatives, and moved into positive territory as he made his case to the voters.

“That’s what campaigning does,” Mr. DuHaime said.

Advertise with us

There’s also the question of whether there is room for a Republican who has a record of working across party lines, not just with Mr. Obama but with a Democratic legislature during his time as governor.

“Christie has this different brand of Republicanism,” Ms. Koning said. “Whether it's going to play well with the base remains to be seen. Potentially, his time has passed both for him as a candidate and for his brand of Republicanism.”

Mr. Christie also will have to explain his change of heart. He was the first prominent Republican to endorse Mr. Trump after ending his own presidential campaign, sought to become his vice president, led his transition team before being dumped unceremoniously after the election, was floated for several positions in the administration, and helped him prepare for his debates in 2016 and 2020.

The permanent break occurred after Mr. Trump lost the 2020 election, falsely claimed it was stolen and riled up supporters who stormed the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, to overturn the results.

Mr. Christie went so far as to use his perch at ABC News to call Mr. Trump’s legal team “a national embarrassment” for continuing to make evidence-free claims of voter fraud.

Advertise with us

Ms. Koning said Mr. Christie should have little trouble explaining his new position.

“Chris Christie does have a gift with words and his no-holds-barred persona,” Ms. Koning said. “It can be as simple as him saying opinions change and minds change. It would be very easy for him to craft a story that seems like a logical answer on why he has turned the tables on Trump.”

It wasn’t an accident that Mr. Christie decided to announce his 2024 campaign in New Hampshire, a key early test of a presidential candidate’s viability. Mr. Christie was surging before the 2016 primary until Mr. Rubio’s super PAC began attacking him. 

Indeed, if Mr. Christie has any chance of breaking through this time around, it will be in the first-in-the-nation primary, where independents can vote and there still are plenty of establishment-friendly Republicans.

“New Hampshire is a good state for a candidate like Chris Christie,” said Jim Demers, a long-time New Hampshire Democratic consultant. “New Hampshire Republicans are not all extreme Republicans and the independent vote could be a significant amount of the primary vote.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Christie’s first try for the presidency saw him transverse the state holding town hall-style meetings, a format that plays to his strengths.

“Certainly, he’s got the reputation of being able to tell what he thinks about things,” said former New Hampshire Senate President Peter Bradgon, a Republican who endorsed Mr. Christie in 2016 and said he would support him again in 2024. “People feel that’s refreshing. He talks the way people are thinking. Tell it like it is. A lot of people like that. They appreciate the candor.”

Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant