U.S. Sen. John Fetterman and other Democrats are urging President Joe Biden to consider invoking the 14th Amendment to the Constitution to sidestep a fight with Republicans over raising the debt ceiling.
In a letter to the White House on Thursday, Mr. Fetterman, D-Pa., and several other Democratic senators chastised GOP leaders for seeking spending cuts and other concessions to lift the debt limit. The lawmakers argued that a provision in the 14th Amendment — which in 1868 granted citizenship to formerly enslaved people and guaranteed equal protection under the law — empowers the president to order that the nation’s debts be paid, and to effectively ignore Republican demands.
“The entire GOP debt ceiling negotiation is a sad charade, and it’s exactly what’s wrong with Washington,” the lawmakers wrote to Mr. Biden. “We’re playing with fire and the livelihoods of millions just for the GOP to try and turn the screws on hungry Americans. This is the whole reason why the 14th Amendment exists, and we need to be prepared to use it.”
The debt ceiling caps how much money the federal government can borrow to pay for spending Congress already approved. Republicans, who lifted the limit multiple times when Donald Trump was president without conditions, have insisted on spending cuts, new requirements for aid programs and roll-backs of parts of Mr. Biden’s legislative agenda to do so this time. Mr. Biden, who long insisted that Republicans raise the debt limit without conditions, has more recently engaged in negotiations.
The letter comes as Mr. Biden and House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., are negotiating against a tight deadline. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has warned that the debt ceiling must be lifted before June 1 or the federal government could run out of cash and default on its debts, triggering an economic crisis.
Lawmakers and some scholars have pointed to Section 4 of the amendment, which reads: “The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned.”
But many legal experts are skeptical of that argument, and the move would surely ignite a court battle. Even Ms. Yellen told reporters in a news conference that “there would clearly be litigation” over invoking the 14th Amendment, which would be “legally questionable whether or not that’s a viable strategy.”
Still, the lawmakers said Thursday that “we cannot let these reckless Republicans hold the economy hostage. And, if our unelected Supreme Court Justices try to block the use of the 14th amendment and blow up our economy, that’s on them.”
Bruce Ledewitz, a law professor at Duquesne University, said that invoking the 14th Amendment has “always been a theoretical matter… nobody’s wanted to test it.”
“Everything that Biden might do is required,” Mr. Ledewitz said. “It’s required that he not borrow money beyond the debt limit, but it’s also required he pay social security and contracts. The obligations are in direct conflict. Past administrations have taken the position that the debt limit is primary among those obligations — but that in and of itself is a theory, too.”
For his part, Mr. Biden — a longtime Delaware senator and bipartisan dealmaker — has voiced confidence that his aides and top Republicans can hammer out a budget framework that would advance a bipartisan vote to raise the debt ceiling.
“If America were to default on its debt, nearly eight million Americans could lose their job, retirement accounts would be devastated, and we’d fall into recession,” he said Wednesday. “It’s disappointing that [in] our discussions with congressional Republicans [they] have not been willing to discuss raising revenues, but policy differences between the parties should not stop Congress from avoiding default.”
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said in a statement that there’s “only one way to defuse the looming crisis,” and that’s “the normal and routine thing” of negotiations — not a unilateral move like invoking the 14th Amendment.
“The American people voted for divided government,” McConnell said. “President Biden refusing to compromise is not an option. Unconstitutionally acting without Congress is not an option.”
Mr. Fetterman said Thursday that he also plans to cosponsor legislation by Sen. Brian Schatz, D-Hawaii, that would “repeal the debt ceiling once and for all.”
Mr. Ledewitz described the debt ceiling as “nonsensical” and argued that lawmakers would be wise to get rid of it. The debt limit artificially arises as an issue “at exactly the wrong point,” he said — not when Congress is looking to authorize upcoming spending, but when the government’s bills have to be paid.
House Democrats, looking to force debt ceiling legislation without spending cuts or other policy changes, are collecting signatures for a so-called discharge petition to get around Republican leaders, The Washington Post reports. The move would let a majority of the House force a debt ceiling vote. But at least five Republicans would have to sign the petition, along with all 213 Democrats, to trigger such a vote.
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com, @BenKail





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.