WASHINGTON — Legislation to improve rail safety following the East Palestine derailment in February passed its first test Wednesday as a key U.S. Senate committee approved the measure and sent it to the full chamber.

A Norfolk Southern freight train derailed just over the Pennsylvania border in the small Ohio village on Feb. 3. The subsequent release of the toxic chemical vinyl chloride raised fears of contamination in Beaver County, leaving residents afraid to drink the water and farmers saying customers were afraid to buy meat from them.

The bipartisan bill was introduced in response to the derailment by U.S. Sens. Bob Casey and John Fetterman, D-Pa.; Sherrod Brown, D–Ohio; and J.D. Vance, R-Ohio. Similar legislation has been introduced in the House by U.S. Rep. Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall.

It passed the Senate committee Wednesday largely along party lines, 16-11, with Mr. Vance and U.S. Sen. Eric Schmitt, R-Mo., joining every Democrat in supporting the measure.

Advertise with us

“No community should have to go through the trauma and evacuation and environmental damage that East Palestine had to go through, especially when you can prevent these from happening,” said U.S. Sen. Maria Cantwell, D-Wash, the committee chair.

The bill would require railroads to install equipment along tracks to detect potential flaws in train cars, such as the wheel bearings that eventually failed in East Palestine; add vinyl chloride and other toxic gasses to the list of chemicals transported by rail requiring speed restrictions and spill response plans; increase inspections and maintenance; and let communities know which chemicals are being carried on trains passing by.

In addition, the legislation would require trains carrying such chemicals to have two crew members on board, and it would increase the maximum penalty for violating rail safety laws — from $100,000 to $10 million.

The panel’s ranking Republican, U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas, said the bill would give too much power to government regulators to set rules for transporting hazardous materials by rail, including coal, oil and natural gas. He said the legislation is too onerous to attract the nine Republican senators needed to break a filibuster, let alone win a majority in the GOP-controlled House.

“I remain concerned this bill is overly and needlessly prescriptive,” Mr. Cruz said.  

Advertise with us

Mr. Vance differed with his fellow Republican.

“There will be another East Palestine in this country if we do not pass the Railway Safety Act,” Mr. Vance said. “We have allowed the rail industry to socialize the risk of their business while privatizing the rewards. The people of East Palestine are going to deal with the cost of what Norfolk Southern did for the next generation.”

He said railroads should be required to pay more for safety.

“The least that we can do is make it less likely that the next East Palestine happens in our communities,” Mr. Vance said. “We cannot on the one hand acknowledge that Ohio taxpayers and Ohio citizens are bearing the costs of this accident and on the other hand say it is ridiculous to require the rail industry to do a little more on safety. They should be doing more on safety. They should be incurring some additional costs so another East Palestine does not happen again.”

The industry’s trade group said it supports parts of the bill but opposes others, including the requirement that at least two crew members be on board trains carrying certain chemicals.

Advertise with us

“Railroads support items of this bill and remain fully committed to working with the committee and all members of the Senate to build on these improvements, with the ultimate goal of ensuring all provisions result in meaningful data-driven safety advancements that all can support,” said Ian Jefferies, CEO of the Association of American Railroads.

“At the same time,” he added, “challenges remain with certain provisions, including those that mandate crew staffing models, expand hazmat transportation operating requirements, micromanage detector networks, and unnecessarily broaden manual inspections. In a piece of safety legislation, each provision should be clearly designed to rectify a current safety challenge. As reported out of the Committee, this bill falls short of that goal.”

The derailment occurred when dozens of cars of a Norfolk Southern train, many of them carrying toxic chemicals, went off the tracks in East Palestine. The controlled release and burn of toxic chemicals days later prompted the evacuation of the small Ohio village, sent a plume of black smoke into the skies over Beaver County, and left residents on both sides of the border fearful of the long-term health effects.

On Tuesday, Mr. Cruz said that Norfolk Southern would make up the difference in price if residents in and around East Palestine sell their homes for less than they were worth before the derailment. Norfolk Southern agreed to make the payments to homeowners within a five-mile radius of the derailment, which includes some Pennsylvania residents in Beaver County.

Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com; @JDSalant