WASHINGTON — As Senate Democrats protest the leaked Supreme Court opinion that signals a likely end to the constitutional right to abortion under Roe v. Wade, anti-abortion Democratic Sen. Bob Casey — whose father was at the center of the high court’s other landmark abortion decision — has remained silent except for a short statement released Tuesday.

Mr. Casey was absent when dozens of his Senate colleagues gathered on the Capitol steps Tuesday to decry the Supreme Court’s forthcoming decision, and from the all-day fiery rhetoric brainstorming a speedy legislative path, albeit futile, to codify abortion rights.

Despite lacking the votes to meet the 60-vote hurdle, or enough votes to change that standard, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., said he intended to hold a vote.

“Every American is going to see on which side every senator stands,” he said on the floor, vowing to hold his colleagues’ feet to the fire.

Advertise with us

Mr. Casey, in his short statement Tuesday, expressed “serious concerns about what overturning almost 50 years of legal precedent will mean for women in states passing near or total bans on abortion.”

Stopping short of picking a side, the senator continued: “Congress should be working to reduce the number of abortions and unintended pregnancies and doing much more to support women and families.”

Mr. Casey on Wednesday morning kept his comments on the Senate floor to Ukraine, food insecurity and the chamber’s forthcoming conference with the House on legislation aimed at out-competing China in the advanced technology race.

“There seems to be less and less room for a principled pro-life Democrat, and so, Sen. Casey is getting squeezed,” said Bruce Ledewitz, Duquesne University law professor specializing in religion and law.

Mr. Casey’s record doesn’t fit a black-and-white approach, observers say.

Advertise with us

Historically anti-abortion, he has supported banning federal funds for abortions, and in 2018 he voted for a Senate bill that would have banned abortions after 20 weeks. The bill failed, as expected and as it did in 2015, but allowed Mr. Casey to reaffirm his position on the issue.

However, of all his votes cast on issues that matter to abortion rights advocates — including women’s health care, family planning and contraception — 67% line up with the views of the Planned Parenthood Action Fund, according to its legislative scorecard.

This past February, Mr. Casey voted to advance legislation prohibiting government restrictions on abortion access.

“Given the recent Supreme Court rulings, potential rulings this year, and the Republican Party’s clear and unrelenting use of this issue as a political weapon, I will vote ‘yes’ to allow debate on this bill. I have long worked to reduce the number of unintended pregnancies and abortions, and I hope that as part of this debate we will also focus on new and substantial funding for pregnant women, infants, and children,” he said in a statement at the time.

As expected, the bill failed to get enough support in the 50-50 Senate.

Advertise with us

Whether fair or unfair, the senator is linked to his father’s anti-abortion campaign. Robert P. Casey Sr., former Pennsylvania governor, was a central figure in the 1992 Supreme Court decision in Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey.

At issue was Pennsylvania’s law that imposed restrictions on women seeking abortions, including a waiting period as well as spousal and parental consent.

The 5-4 Casey decision upheld Roe but reinterpreted it: No longer did states have to adhere to pregnancy trimester framework established in Roe. They could now restrict abortion based on viability, or whether the fetus could survive outside the womb, generally considered 24 weeks. However, states could not impose an “undue burden,” defined as a “substantial obstacle,” on those seeking an abortion before viability.

Before the high court this year was a Mississippi law that would allow abortion bans at six weeks of pregnancy.

The leaked SCOTUS draft opinion for that case, published Monday night by Politico, generally argues to return all decisions regarding abortions to the states.

Advertise with us

“Casey is the case that laid out this viability framework, this kind of on-off switch,” said Greer Donley, University of Pittsburgh assistant law professor who specializes in reproductive health law. “The Mississippi case is a ban on abortions starting before viability. So for the court to uphold that law, it seems as if it has to overturn not just Roe, but also Casey.”

Legal experts note that draft opinions and votes can change, and have in the past, during negotiations. Although with the court’s conservative makeup, a change on this issue is unlikely. A final opinion is expected in June.

Mr. Casey is currently “trying to thread the needle,” Ms. Donley said, but the likely end of Roe may ratchet up the pressure on him.

“If Roe is gone and there is no constitutional protection, it becomes very different for him because, you know, the next wave is going to be trying to create a federal right to abortion by statute,” she said. “He’s going to have to say whether he thinks one way or the other.”

Mr. Casey was not available for further comment Wednesday.

Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com