COLUMBUS, Ohio — The Buckeye State is no longer seen as the swing state it once was, but all eyes are on Ohio as a possible early indicator of the clout that former President Donald Trump still wields with the Republican electorate.

Will GOP Ohioans show up in what is otherwise expected to be a low-turnout primary Tuesday to hand “Hillbilly Elegy” author J.D. Vance the party's nomination to do battle this fall after getting a late Trump nod?

Will they line up behind the parade of other Republican candidates who've presented themselves as the true Trump conservatives in the race only to come up empty when it came to the endorsement — like former Ohio Treasurer Josh Mandel, Cleveland investment banker Mike Gibbons, and former Ohio GOP Chairman Jane Timken.

Or will they go to the Republican candidate who's made a point of staying off the Trump train — former state Sen. Matt Dolan, of Chagrin Falls, part-owner of the Cleveland Guardians?

Advertise with us

The winner has a chance to replace retiring Republican U.S. Sen. Rob Portman, who has received his share of daggers for not always toeing the Trump line on things like passage of President Joe Biden's infrastructure law.

Whoever prevails will face the winner of a three-way Democratic primary between 10-term U.S. Rep. Tim Ryan, former consumer protection attorney Morgan Harper, and Columbus activist and tech exec Traci Johnson.

“For the Republicans, the big headline is whether Trump still has a stronghold on the Republican Party,” said Mark Caleb Smith, Cedarville University political science professor. “The Senate election won't necessarily determine anything. There could be a lot of different outcomes. The main discussion is what degree will Trump continue to play in GOP politics.

“He's endorsed candidates,” Mr. Smith said. “He's punished candidates. If he's successful, it will only make him more powerful over the next couple of years.”

Mr. Trump twice won Ohio by more than 8 percentage points, so many viewed getting his nod in the Senate race as critical to winning the crowded GOP primary. Instead, when he chose Mr. Vance, it divided the state.

Advertise with us

The endorsement of Mr. Vance came late in the campaign, but with it came a Trump rally in Delaware, Ohio, a week ago. Mr. Vance was not at the top of polls prior to that move, but he surged after.

Still, Mr. Trump raised eyebrows at a weekend Nebraska rally during which he appeared to confuse two different candidates —“J.D. Mandel.”

“If Mandel were to win [in Ohio], I think it still damages Trump,” Mr. Smith said. “He's gone out of his way to endorse Vance. Donald Trump, Jr. has been here. Matt Gaetz and Marjorie Taylor Greene have been here as proxies for that part of the party. If [Vance] were to lose, that's pretty big.”

The race has also seen Missouri Sen. Josh Hawley campaigning for Mr. Vance, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz on the road with Mr. Mandel, and Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul backing Mr. Gibbons.

Kyle Kondik, managing editor of Larry Sabato's political Crystal Ball at the University of Virginia and author of “The Bellwether: Why Ohio Picks the President,” noted the huge amount of money that's been poured into the race by outside groups as well as the candidates' campaign committees and, in some cases, personal wealth. Estimates have exceeded $60 million.

Advertise with us

“The primary's been pretty nasty and has gotten a lot of attention,” Mr. Kondik said. “If Vance wins, Trump's endorsement is part of that. ... Trump getting involved seems like it helped Vance, but it also seems like there's been a late Dolan movement, which is interesting. I imagine it might have to do with his ability to self-fund. It's also possible that there is a small but significant number of Republicans who are tired of Trump and don't like that he's endorsing Vance.”

The Senate race has sucked a lot of the political air out of the room. Somewhat lost in the attention is the fact that incumbent Gov. Mike DeWine is locked in a race against three fellow Republicans trying to flank him from the right — former U.S. Rep. Jim Renacci, Columbus area cattle farmer Joe Blystone, and former state Rep. Ron Hood.

The governor's opponents have made his handling of the coronavirus pandemic, in which he was among the first governors to shut down businesses and schools in 2020, a cornerstone of their campaigns.

Mr. Trump chose not to endorse in the governor’s primary.

Meanwhile, the two Democrats — former Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley and former Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley — have come at the governor on his economic policies and signing of controversial laws seen as expanding gun access and further restricting abortion rights.

Advertise with us

“It doesn't look like DeWine is imperiled,” Mr. Kondik said. “He has spent a considerable amount of money, and his backers have, too. It will be interesting to see if he gets less than 50%. The field is pretty fractured. But below 50% for an incumbent governor is not great. While his problems come from the right, he has crossover appeal [for the general election] because of COVID and other factors.”

The Block News Alliance consists of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, The Blade of Toledo, Ohio, and television station WDRB in Louisville, Ky. Jim Provance is a reporter for The Blade at: jprovance@theblade.com. The Associated Press contributed.