Sharing the same stage for the first time in their run for U.S. Senate, the three leading contenders for the Democratic nomination — Pennsylvania Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, U.S. Rep. Conor Lamb and state Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta — split on climate change, united on eliminating the filibuster, and shared why they think they can win such a high-stakes statewide election.

The occasion — Sunday’s Barbara Daly Danko Political Forum at Carnegie Mellon University — was hosted by the 14th Ward Democratic Committee and the university’s Heinz College of Information.

Mr. Fetterman, Mr. Lamb and Mr. Kenyatta — as well as Jenkintown Borough Councilwoman Alex Khalil, who hasn’t registered by name in recent polling — fielded questions for an hour and a half, giving two-minute answers on each subject area.

Here’s how they answered:

Advertise with us

On abortion

Mr. Fetterman said a “non-negotiable” litmus test for when he’s considering Supreme Court nominees — if elected — would be whether they’re committed to upholding Roe v. Wade. He called for eliminating the filibuster to pass a federal law codifying Roe v. Wade, and warned that Pennsylvania would be in danger of restricting abortion access if Democrats lose the governor’s mansion.

Mr. Lamb said he had co-sponsored a bill upholding abortion rights that the House passed in September of last year but died in the Senate earlier this month. He added that to protect women who are the least advantaged, the Senate should join the House in voting down the Hyde Amendment so that Medicaid can cover abortion and family planning services. Democrats are two votes away from that becoming law if the filibuster goes, he said.

Mr. Kenyatta said the Supreme Court has “tacitly overturned” Roe v. Wade already by allowing Texas’s abortion law to stand. Winning the Senate seat is important, he said, because Democrats can send a message that they value fighting to protect a woman’s right over her own body. He noted that he is co-sponsoring a bill in the state House to remove barriers for people seeking an abortion in Pennsylvania.

On climate change

Advertise with us

Mr. Lamb said of the 58 billion tons of carbon dioxide emitted each year worldwide, the U.S. only accounts for 15% — and although it’s necessary to get that number to zero by 2050, it’s a problem that extends beyond American borders.

He said that goes to show that Democrats need to be “politically realistic” about what can pass, adding that those who don’t agree with the party are usually worried about opportunities. He called for a focus on protecting existing jobs and creating new ones — not just “hypothetical” jobs — in nuclear energy, hydrogen pipelines and semiconductor plants.

Mr. Fetterman said the choice isn’t between addressing the climate crisis and protecting jobs. He insisted that “we still need to make stuff in this country” and that it’s crucial to retain manufacturing and energy jobs in Pennsylvania that currently give the U.S. energy security, too.

The lieutenant governor said it will also take recognizing that the U.S. has to transition away from these fuels to a green energy economy, which must start now.

Mr. Kenyatta accused Mr. Fetterman of changing tunes on climate change, and said Democrats need to pass a bold agenda that will keep Pennsylvania as an energy leader, but one in wind, solar and geothermal.

Advertise with us

On the filibuster

Mr. Fetterman said Democrats who believe the filibuster should remain in place think there are 10 to 12 Republican senators “of conscience” who are suddenly going to come to their senses to pass comprehensive legislation. That’s simply not the case, he added.

“Why can’t Democrats be ruthless and united and get some important legislation passed and done while we can?” Mr. Fetterman asked. “We know the other side, if given the chance, will run the table on us, too.”

Mr. Lamb said he supports getting rid of the filibuster and would vote that way “on day one” if elected. Republicans will do it when it suits their interests, he said.

“If you ask me, I actually think we’re going to have a more productive Senate on both sides of the aisle when the filibuster is gone because there’s going to be more legislative trains leaving the station,” Mr. Lamb said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kenyatta said “some folks up here” on stage waited until poll numbers were beneficial to stand against the filibuster, and said he has been in favor of eliminating it for a while. Republicans have already chipped away at it when it was useful to them, he said.

On the size of the Supreme Court

Mr. Lamb said the issue is a “trap,” and that he’s not in favor of expanding the number of seats. He said voters need to believe that Democrats are fighting for them on issues that actually matter to them — “pocketbook” issues. By winning elections, Democrats can nominate better judges and pass laws codifying Roe v. Wade and changing campaign finance laws — things that are often left to the courts, he said.

Mr. Fetterman said he, too, doesn’t support it — and that Democrats shouldn’t structurally change things just because they’re “frustrated by the current outcome,” referring to the 6-to-3 conservative advantage on the bench.

Mr. Kenyatta said he would favor expanding the court, and that democracy is on the line. He said it’s not a new idea and that it has been done before.

Advertise with us

On what they want to tell voters

Mr. Fetterman said the party has evolved to match many of the policy positions he had taken years ago, and that as a result, he has 190,000 donors with an average contribution of $28. He has donors in 90% of Pennsylvania ZIP codes, he added.

“That’s a new map,” Mr. Fetterman said, “and I believe we’re going to need a new map to win in Pennsylvania in 2022.”

Mr. Lamb said that with such high stakes, it will take someone who has run successful campaigns in similar atmospheres before. He said to win, Democrats need to put their trust in someone who can build a coalition — and who will fight for ideas that would pass in the Senate if the body had more Democrats.

“What I can offer you in this race is, I have voted for every bill on that list and many more, and defended my seat while doing it,” Mr. Lamb said. “I do have the experience of going out and talking to these people whose votes we need.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Kenyatta said a focus on who can win isn’t as important as nominating a candidate whose experiences reflect the concerns of the community, and that if Democrats are looking for someone who can turn out the base — young people, progressives, Black voters — “it’s Malcolm Kenyatta.”

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com