Republican Glenn Youngkin trailed his opponent for much of the Virginia governor’s race, struggling to stir enthusiasm with his criticism of the state’s economy, questioning of U.S. election integrity and self-portrayal as a likeable moderate in a red fleece vest.

But in the late weeks of the campaign — which culminated early Wednesday morning in a close victory for Mr. Youngkin over Democrat Terry McAuliffe — Mr. Youngkin found his footing, surging in the polls as he mined a national vein of parent grievance over what and how schools teach about race, racism and American history. Mr. Youngkin prompted cheers, and apparently earned votes, when he promised at rallies throughout the state to ban critical race theory, a college-level academic framework that holds racism is systemic in America and which is not taught at the K-12 level in Virginia or anywhere else. Sensing success, the governor-elect broadened his approach, vowing to give parents more control in general over what their children learn, or do not learn, in public-school classrooms.

Then came the fateful final governor’s debate. Amid a heated exchange with Mr. Youngkin over parent attempts to remove sexually explicit texts from school libraries, Mr. McAuliffe huffed, “I don’t think parents should be telling schools what they should teach.”

Those 12 words immediately became fodder for a massive Republican advertising campaign. And, said Stephen Farnsworth, a political scientist at University of Mary Washington in Fredericksburg, Va., they likely cost Mr. McAuliffe the governorship.

Advertise with us

“That one less-than-articulately phrased sentence sank his campaign,” Mr. Farnsworth said. “Youngkin was in search of a message that would resonate until it was handed to him in that debate.”

Republican Jack Ciattarelli saw pay-off for similar tactics in the New Jersey gubernatorial race between himself and Gov. Phil Murphy, which Murphy barely won despite being a heavy favorite. The tight finish was a surprise and a disappointment for Democrats, given New Jersey is a reliably blue state that chose Joe Biden over Donald Trump by a large margin.

Rather than speak to local issues, Mr. Ciattarelli campaigned on national concerns, including critical race theory and how much sway parents should hold over school curricula. During a campaign stop at a gun range over the summer, he told a group of parents, “When I’m governor ... we’re not teaching gender ID and sexual orientation to kindergarteners [and] we’re going to roll back the LGBTQ curriculum,” according to a video obtained by news outlet Gothamist. Mr. Ciattarelli added: “It goes too far.”

The Republican gains in Virginia and New Jersey show the efficacy of a new model of conservative politics: appealing to suburban voters by promising greater parental control of schools. In a statement Wednesday responding to the elections, the National Parent Union, a parents’ rights group that often opposes teachers’ unions, laid out a vision of the nation’s political future — and a stark warning.

“This is only the beginning of the parent revolution,” said Keri Rodrigues, co-founder and president of the union. “Politicans will have to make a choice: either work with parents and families on reimagining education, listen to their concerns [and] govern in their best interests ... or get voted out of office.”

Advertise with us

Exit polls in Virginia show that education was one of the top issues for voters in the state — where Republicans also swept downballot elections Tuesday. Republicans regained control of the House of Delegates, where all 100 seats were up for grabs, and Republican Winsome Sears won the lieutenant governor’s race.

About one-quarter of Virginia voters said education was the single most important issue in deciding their vote, according to preliminary network exit polling. Roughly half said that parents should have “a lot” of say over what their child’s school teaches, while another roughly 3 in 10 said parents should have “some” say, according to the polling. Just 1 in 10 said parents should have little or no say over what schools teach, per the exit polls.

Parent anger was on full display at voting stations throughout the day Tuesday. Outside the polls in western Prince William County, one phrase kept cropping up in voters’ conversations with neighbors and reporters: “Parents should have a say.”

“I’d like to not vote for the guy who said it’s not the parents’ responsibility to take care of their kids,” said Michael Smith, just after voting the Republican ticket. “What really motivated me was the statement that parents should not have a say in their children’s education.”

Mr. Smith, who is Black, said schools should “just teach basics” like math and reading, and leave race and gender as topics for parents to discuss with their children at home. The consultant is so troubled by public-school teaching on social issues that he and his wife have decided to homeschool their two younger children, he said.

Advertise with us

Late Tuesday, parent indignation shifted to triumph at Mr. Youngkin’s election watch party, held at the Westfields Marriott hotel in Chantilly, Va. By 10 p.m., the gathering resembled a disco, with Michael Jackson’s “Billie Jean” blaring and elated Republicans dancing and waving a variety of Youngkin signs, including “Small Business Owners for Youngkin,” “Latinos for Youngkin” and “Law Enforcement for Youngkin.” Most plentiful of all were posters reading “Parents for Youngkin.”

A band of about six women stood together wearing sequined blazers over blue shirts printed with the slogan “Fight for Schools,” the name of a Loudoun County parent group that is seeking to recall members of the school board over their alleged violation of Virginia open meeting laws. One of the women, 49-year-old Ronda Nassib, said she is part of an “army of moms.”

“I’m a pissed-off parent that believes that I have the right to a voice in my child’s education,” Ms. Nassib said. “I’m not willing to take a step back.”

Elsewhere in the ballroom, Eric Schnabel gripped a “Parents for Youngkin” sign as he awaited the election results. Mr. Schnabel, who recently retired from the army after serving in Iraq and Afghanistan, said the chaotic pull-out from Afghanistan under Mr. Biden infuriated him, turning him off to Democrats. He was also put off by what he called the party’s “divisive” focus on race, including its support for removing Confederate monuments. He said he believed those should have been left in place as a “stark reminder to never go down that road again.”

But above all, he liked what Mr. Youngkin had to say about parental input into education, and disliked what he was hearing from Mr. McAuliffe.

Advertise with us

“When Terry McAuliffe said I’m not in charge of my daughter’s education — what is he, nuts?” Mr. Schnabel said.

New era in education

Conservative activists and parents hailed Mr. Youngkin’s approaching governorship as the dawning of a new era in Virginia education.

It’s “a win for parents that are looking for a greater role in their children’s education,” said Ian Prior, a Loudoun County father who founded Fight for Schools. “I believe we will see many families keep their children in public schools, and school boards will start collaborating more with parents on the best way forward.”

Victoria Cobb, president of the conservative advocacy group the Family Foundation of Virginia, said Mr. Youngkin “will support policies that recognize moms and dads as essential to the education of our children.”

Advertise with us

But Youngkin — a wealthy 54-year-old former private equity executive whose own children attend or have graduated from private school — is unlikely to usher in much immediate change for Virginia students, education policy experts said.

Continued Democratic control of the state Senate puts broad policy changes requiring legislative agreement out of Mr. Youngkin’s reach, said Mr. Farnsworth, the political scientist. As a candidate, Mr. Youngkin never proposed many specific education policy changes anyway, Mr. Farnsworth added.

“Youngkin’s policy plans were somewhat thin on the details beyond the mantra of greater parental engagement,” Mr. Farnsworth said. “It’ll be interesting to see if education is as high a priority for Youngkin the governor as it was for Youngkin the candidate.”

And Jack Schneider, associate professor of education at the University of Massachusetts at Lowell, said Mr. Youngkin can do very little to increase parental control over school curriculums.

The way public education has long functioned in America, he said, is that schools are not directly accountable to parents but are instead governed by democratically elected school boards. School board members are meant to represent every county resident whose tax dollars fund the public school system, Mr. Schneider said, not just those with children. And the boards have large latitude to determine what children learn in schools, although they must abide by statewide standards of learning in Virginia.

Advertise with us

To grant parents radically increased say in what or how teachers teach, Mr. Schneider said, Mr. Youngkin would have to overhaul the structure of American public-school education.

“If parents alone are deciding what happens inside schools,” he said, “what it would mean is unmaking public education and instead having each individual family pursue their own self-interest in a free market.”

Speeches about critical race theory proved potent campaign fodder, but vague opposition to the theory will not easily translate into actual policies, said Michael Petrilli, president of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, a right-leaning education think tank.

Mr. Youngkin could attempt to add Virginia to the list of eight Republican-led states that have passed laws forbidding the teaching of critical race theory, Mr. Petrilli suggested. But that legislation will face opposition in the Virginia legislature unless it is essentially toothless, he said.

“Doing something on critical race theory that goes beyond the symbolic?” Mr. Petrilli said. “That’s going to be a really tough sell to Democrats.”

Advertise with us

No governor of a state has banned critical race theory via executive order, and it is not clear whether Mr. Youngkin could do so, although he would almost certainly face legal challenges if he tries.

Mr. Farnsworth said the point is moot, given that Virginia does not teach critical race theory: “At the end of his four-year term, Glenn Youngkin will be able to claim credit for keeping critical race theory out of K-12 education — just like it was when he was a candidate.”

Teo Armus, Laura Vozzella and Julie Zauzmer contributed to this report.