WASHINGTON — A U.S. Senate vote to begin debate on what was intended to be a $973 billion bipartisan infrastructure legislation failed on Wednesday, dealing a blow to the prospect for federal investment in roads, bridges, water systems and broadband that the vast majority of Americans agree is sorely needed.
The vote was 49-51, with every Republican opposing it and all Democrats and Independents supporting it. Senate rules require at least 60 votes to proceed. (Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., supported the measure but voted against it so, by Senate rules, he could ask for a motion to reconsider.)
Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., who was part of a separate GOP negotiating team that failed to reach an infrastructure deal in May, voted against opening debate. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., voted for it.
Mr. Toomey said Mr. Schumer’s decision to hold a vote on “a measure that does not yet exist doomed this procedural vote from the start. Despite this, I expect negotiators will continue to work towards an agreement.”
“Should they reach one,” Mr. Toomey added, “I will consider it based on its substance.”
The vote was a disappointment to President Joe Biden and Congressional Democrats, who wanted to press ahead on a bipartisan plan this summer. Mr. Biden and a group of Senate Republicans announced a five-year, $973 billion deal at the White House in June, and legislative text was being worked out among members.
Read More
But Republicans, led in part by Sen. Rob Portman, R-Ohio, argued more time was needed and pressed Mr. Schumer to postpone the vote until next week.
The two parties have disagreed for months on how to raise revenue to pay for the plan. Republicans were opposed to raising taxes on corporations and the wealthy, as Democrats suggested. Democrats were opposed to repurposing yet-to-be-spent COVID-19 economic relief money passed in March, as Republicans suggested.
Disagreements over what counts as “infrastructure” have divided the parties, too. The bipartisan deal was seen as a way to invest in physical infrastructure that Republicans and Democrats agreed on.
The bipartisan framework released by the White House included $400 billion in baseline spending — dollars that Congress already authorized but would require periodic congressional approval. Another $573 billion would be new spending on top of that.
Of the new spending, the plan earmarked $109 billion for roads and bridges, $73 billion for electric grid upgrades, $66 billion for passenger and freight rail, $65 billion for broadband expansion, $55 billion for water infrastructure, $49 billion for public transit, among a slew of other uses.
Advocacy groups, businesses, labor unions, local governments across the political spectrum rallied around the bipartisan deal, arguing the U.S. economy and national security depended on upgrading the country’s infrastructure to keep pace with other countries in the 21st century.
This month, two of the most influential lobbying forces in Washington — the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the AFL-CIO — joined together to endorse the deal. Also this month, more than 2,000 county-level officials gathered in Washington to discuss, in part, the need for a bipartisan infrastructure plan.
The unified stance from the pro-business chamber and the labor federation, which are virtually always at odds, sent a powerful message to lawmakers: “Don’t let partisan differences get in the way of action — pass significant, meaningful infrastructure legislation now,” the joint statement read.
In the Pittsburgh region, local business, labor and civic leaders pressed lawmakers — in a virtual meeting with Rep. Peter DeFazio, D-Ore., chair of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, and in an in-person meeting with Mr. Toomey — to reach a deal.
But politics and a busy schedule got in the way.
Democrats are expected to unilaterally advance a separate $3.5 trillion infrastructure bill that includes a range of health care, education, climate change and energy provisions.
Some moderate Democrats, including Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., and Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Mt. Lebanon, said they wanted to reach a bipartisan deal before moving the Democrats-only package.
Mr. Schumer, the majority leader, wanted to move forward as he faces a busy calendar ahead of a five-week recess in August and September and a debate over the annual federal budget and a five-year surface transportation bill.
On top of that, House-passed measures on voting rights, immigration, police reform and firearm background checks are piling up. Mr. Biden also moved to open debate in Washington on lowering prescription drug prices by the end of the year.
Republicans insisted they wanted a bipartisan deal but needed more time to negotiate before they voted to open debate.
It is unclear what is next for bipartisan infrastructure efforts in Congress.
After the vote, a group of bipartisan senators — 10 Republicans, 11 Democrats and one Independent — signed a statement saying they would continue to work toward a deal.
“We have made significant progress and are close to a final agreement,” the group said. “We will continue working hard to ensure we get this critical legislation right — and are optimistic that we will finalize, and be prepared to advance, this historic bipartisan proposal to strengthen America’s infrastructure and create good-paying jobs in the coming days.”
Some components of that agreement have recently moved forward.
Last week, a panel chaired by Mr. Manchin, advanced an energy infrastructure bill totaling more than $100 billion. Mr. Manchin lauded the bill as “another critical step toward finalizing our bipartisan infrastructure package” after the committee approved it by a 13-7 vote, with three Republicans joining all 10 Democrats on the committee.
The House passed a $547 billion surface transportation bill that included $85 million in funding for 20 transportation projects in the Pittsburgh region. Mr. Schumer had hoped to use that bill, called the Invest in America Act, as a vehicle for the broader plan.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.