WASHINGTON — In 2016, President Barack Obama signed off on a deal to provide $38 billion in unrestricted U.S. aid to Israel over a 10-year period — the largest single pledge of foreign military assistance in U.S. history.

While that funding so far has been authorized in full by Congress beginning in the 2019 fiscal year, the violence that has erupted between Israel and Hamas has split lawmakers in the Democratic majority over whether to add conditions or cut the funding altogether.

Many in the progressive wing openly challenged President Joe Biden’s posture toward Israel as too accommodating. Connecting the Palestinians’ cause to the pursuit of racial justice in the United States, those lawmakers have called out the high civilian death tolls in the Gaza Strip and the bombing of a high-rise building that housed members of the media.

Meanwhile, Mr. Biden, who served as Mr. Obama’s vice president, has said any reduction or restriction on the security assistance to Israel would be “irresponsible.”

Advertise with us

Lawmakers in the Pittsburgh region have generally agreed with that stance.

On April 26, as tensions simmered in Gaza but before the war broke out, U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, signed a letter calling for the full foreign aid to be awarded to Israel. The annual haul detailed by the 2016 agreement includes $3.3 billion in foreign military financing and $500 million for cooperative missile defense programs.

Read More

“We recognize that not every member of Congress will agree with every policy decision of every Israeli government,” Mr. Doyle and other lawmakers wrote in the letter to the top Democrat and Republican on the House Appropriations Committee.

He argued that “reducing funding or adding conditions on security assistance would be detrimental to Israel’s ability to defend itself against all threats.”

He described the aid as “a specific investment in the peace and prosperity of the entire Middle East. U.S. support for Israel makes the region a safer place and bolsters diplomatic efforts aimed at achieving a negotiated two-state solution, resulting in peace and prosperity for both Israelis and Palestinians.”

Advertise with us

Asked this week if the flare-up in violence had changed his views on the funding, a spokesman for Mr. Doyle responded with an emailed statement calling for a ceasefire.

“The international community’s focus needs to be on de-escalating the situation and ending the violence through an immediate cease-fire,” Mr. Doyle stated. “It’s my understanding that the administration has been in contact with both the Israeli and Palestinian leadership — and that it’s working hard to that end.”

Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Mt. Lebanon, said in a statement that “Israel is our ally and they have every right to defend themselves,” while also characterizing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as eroding progress toward peace.

“Our commitment to support Israel is bipartisan and I believe it must continue, even when their democracy produces leaders like Netanyahu who test our endurance and erode progress towards peace,” Mr. Lamb stated. “But the suffering of so many civilians who have done nothing wrong demands that we not give up, and that we work tirelessly to end the fighting.”

On Wednesday, Mr. Doyle and Mr. Lamb signed a letter with 136 other House Democrats calling on the Biden administration to press for a ceasefire.

Advertise with us

“The alternative is an unfolding human tragedy of unimaginable dimensions,” the letter stated. “Too many people have already died.  More will unnecessarily perish if America does not act with the immediacy this violence demands.

Republicans have been in lockstep with the Israeli government, criticizing Democrats that have questioned Israeli attacks in Gaza.

U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters, a member of the House Appropriations Committee overseeing foreign aid, signed a letter on April 22 supporting the full unrestricted aid to Israel.

“Israel has every right to defend itself against state sponsors of terror and violent extremist organizations like Hamas,” Mr. Reschenthaler said in a statement Wednesday. “Unfortunately, radical Democrats jeopardize our alliance with Israel by spreading anti-Semitism and opposing security assistance to our strategic ally in the Middle East.”

“On a daily basis, Israel confronts threats from Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria, and Iran,” he added. “It is clearly evident Israel is our ally and Hamas is our mutual enemy, and anyone who disputes that paradigm impedes U.S. national security at home and abroad.”

Advertise with us

U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, said the country should stand “in proud, unwavering defense of our greatest ally and dearest friend in the Middle East.”

“Hamas is an Iranian-backed terrorist group that is indiscriminately firing rockets at Israeli civilians,” Mr. Kelly stated. “Israel has a right to defend itself, so we must answer their calls for help and stand with them in their time of need.”

Mr. Biden, during a May 2020 campaign speech to Jewish donors, said he would refuse to leverage assistance to Israel to influence its policy. “I’m not going to place conditions on security assistance given the serious threats they face,” he said. Mr. Biden also pledged to reverse Trump administration policies that have led to Israeli plans to annex parts of the West Bank and said he planned to resume assistance to the Palestinians.

Last year, the U.S.-Israel Security Assistance Authorization Act was introduced with wide bipartisan support and was passed as part of the annual defense spending bill in December. (Former President Donald Trump vetoed that bill, and lawmakers in both chambers returned to override the veto with a two-thirds majority in both chambers.)

But in the last week, many Democratic lawmakers, in op-eds and floor speeches, implored Mr. Biden to urge Israel to pull back.

Advertise with us

Rep. Cori Bush, D-Mo., promised to “fight for our rights in Palestine and in Ferguson,” referencing the St. Louis suburb where protests erupted in 2014 after the police shooting of Michael Brown, protests that brought the Black Lives Matter movement to national recognition.

U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., called Israel an “apartheid state.” and U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Mich., called Israel’s attacks on Hamas targets, “terrorism.”

Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., chair of the Senate Budget Committee, called for revisiting and potentially cutting aid to Israel. penned a widely circulated op-ed lambasting the Democratic leadership for being too accommodating toward Israel and Mr. Netanyahu.

“Palestinian lives matter,” he wrote in the New York Times op-ed, citing high unemployment rate, evictions, and a “deepening Israeli occupation in the West Bank and East Jerusalem and a continuing blockade on Gaza that make life increasingly intolerable for Palestinians.”

On Tuesday, Rep. Rashida Tlaib, D-Mich., the first Palestinian-American woman to serve in Congress, told Mr. Biden during the president’s visit to Michigan that “Palestinian human rights are not a bargaining chip and must be protected, not negotiated,” one of her aides told NPR.

Advertise with us

“The U.S. cannot continue to give the right-wing Netanyahu government billions each year to commit crimes against Palestinians,” the aide stated. “Atrocities like bombing schools cannot be tolerated, much less conducted with U.S.-supplied weapons.”

Republicans, hoping to regain control of Congress in the 2022 midterm elections, have sought to deepen the divisions among Democrats.

On Tuesday, the National Republican Senatorial Committee launched a television ad targeting Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., for his “silence” as Ms. Ocasio-Cortez and others criticize Israel.

“Why is Democrat leader Chuck Schumer not defending Israel?” the ad’s narrator asks, then answers: “Schumer’s scared AOC will run against him. He’s been silenced. Schumer would rather save himself than stand up for Israel.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, Twitter @PGdanielmoore