The U.S. Supreme Court is scheduled to announce in as soon as a month whether it will hear the election case of U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, who started his legal fight against the results of the presidential race within weeks after fellow Republican Donald Trump lost the White House to Democrat Joe Biden.
If the high court refuses to hear the case, the rejection will mark the end of another of Mr. Kelly’s legal attempts to challenge universal, no-excuses mail-in voting in Pennsylvania as unconstitutional and thus “illegal,” in Mr. Kelly’s words.
If the Supreme Court decides to hear the case, Mr. Kelly’s claims will remain alive, raising the possibility that he could prevail and upend the same mail-in voting system that the GOP-controlled General Assembly, through Act 77, adopted with widespread bipartisan support in 2019.
Mr. Kelly, of Butler, whose 16th Congressional District includes Erie, wants mail-in voting declared unconstitutional and eliminated unless Pennsylvania voters approve universal mail-in voting by amending the state constitution.
The Supreme Court on Feb. 19 will hold a conference on Mr. Kelly’s case and decide whether to hear it, according to a note entered on the docket of Mr. Kelly’s case last week. Mr. Kelly wants the Supreme Court to agree to hear his case by granting his petition for what is known as a writ of certiorari. The justices are to review a number of such requests at their Feb. 19 conference.
Under Supreme Court procedures, the justices typically announce the disposition of a petition for writ of certiorari on the Monday after the conference at which the justices discussed the writ. In Mr. Kelly’s case, that puts the date of the announcement at Feb. 22. Four of the nine Supreme Court justices must vote to grant a writ of certiorari for the case to proceed.
Read More
The chances are slim that the Supreme Court will agree to hear Mr. Kelly’s case. The Supreme Court each term gets 7,000 to 8,000 petitions for writs of certiorari, known as cert petitions, and grants only about 80, according to www.scotusblog.com, which tracks Supreme Court cases and statistics. The Supreme Court also has shown no inclination to address Mr. Kelly’s claims previously.
The Supreme Court on Dec. 8 unanimously rejected Mr. Kelly’s request that the justices grant an emergency injunction and halt the tallying of Pennsylvania’s Electoral College votes — which Mr. Biden won — in light of Mr. Kelly’s concerns.
On Dec. 11, Mr. Kelly asked the Supreme Court to expedite a decision on whether to grant his cert petition. He argued that the justices needed to hear the case quickly to affect mail-in voting in the spring 2021 primary in Pennsylvania. The Supreme Court on Jan. 11 unanimously rejected Mr. Kelly’s request for expedited consideration, leaving the justices to decide whether to hear the case on a regular schedule.
Mr. Kelly wants the Supreme Court to rule in a way that would eventually get rid of mail-in voting in Pennsylvania, unless lawmakers and voters approve it through the passage of a constitutional amendment, a process that would take years.
Mr. Kelly sued over mail-in ballots in the Pennsylvania appellate courts on Nov. 21, after Democrats who used the ballots helped Mr. Biden defeat Mr. Trump in Pennsylvania. The state Supreme Court unanimously ruled against Mr. Kelly on Nov. 28, and he started his series of appeals before the U.S. Supreme Court. Mr. Kelly was reelected to a sixth consecutive term in November.
Mr. Kelly was one of Mr. Trump’s strongest supporters in Congress. During a debate on the House floor in the early morning of Jan. 7, hours after a pro-Trump mob stormed the U.S. Capitol, Mr. Kelly objected to the certification of the Pennsylvania Electoral College results.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.