As President Donald Trump prepares another tumultuous week in his waning term of office after a mob stormed the U.S. Capitol last week, one of Pittsburgh’s leading constitutional law scholars said a second round of impeachment proceedings is likely to advance.

“The drumbeat for impeachment is so loud now that it’s almost certain that it will move forward,” Ken Gormley, the president of Duquesne University and a former professor of constitutional law, said. “Democrats have a clear majority in the House, and with some Republicans probably joining them, the likelihood of success is very high.”

However, Mr. Gormley said Democrats will need to weigh the benefits of a successful impeachment attempt against the reality of it potentially impeding President-elect Joe Biden’s new administration and its agenda.

Because the purpose of impeachment is to remove an official who engages in conduct that threatens the security of the nation, the framers of the U.S. Constitution anticipated that impeachment may have to happen swiftly, Mr. Gormley said, and as a result, nothing in the Constitution says how long the House needs to deliberate.

Advertise with us

Thus, the House could theoretically take up a vote on impeachment as early as Tuesday, and Democratic leaders have indicated that a vote could happen sometime this week. Internal House rules about committee hearings could also be waived with a simple majority, thus speeding up impeachment proceedings that much more.

However, the problems for Democrats begin when they turn over articles of impeachment to the Senate for a trial. Because the Senate is currently in recess and is not scheduled to resume business until Jan. 19, proceedings would come to a screeching halt until then.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has also recently circulated a memo stating that, due to Senate rules on impeachment, the Senate can not consider the proceedings until 1 p.m. on the day after they are exhibited.

This means that an impeachment trial against Mr. Trump would not begin until Jan. 20, after he has officially left office.

Such a prospect has led some Democratic leaders to suggest that the House may wait several months to send articles of impeachment to the Senate until Mr. Biden’s administration has had time to settle in.

Advertise with us

Though there is no precedence for it, Mr. Gormley said, most constitutional scholars also agree that impeachment could still happen even after a president leaves office, especially if the House had already voted to impeach before the president departs.

Yet despite the bad timing, Mr. Gormley said, removing Mr. Trump from office is not the only benefit of impeachment for Democrats, alluding to the fact that Mr. Trump has openly mulled running for office in 2024.

“[Democrats’] real goal here is to prevent Trump from becoming a sort of villain in a Spiderman movie that rises from the ashes to fight another day,” Mr. Gormley said. “Impeachment doesn’t just relate to removing an official from office. There are provisions that say [the removed official] may be prevented from holding future offices, as well.”

Being removed from office also means that Mr. Trump would be disqualified from benefiting from the Former Presidents Act, which provides former presidents with a pension, security details, staff and travel allowances, a fact that Mr. Gormley said has often been overlooked.

Regarding Mr. Trump’s legal strategy during impeachment, Mr. Gormley said the president’s options are slim.

Advertise with us

Because impeachment is a political process and not a legal one, Mr. Trump has little choice but to observe as the process unfolds.

The political aspects of impeachment, as well as the fact that Chief Justice John Roberts would preside over a Senate trial, also make it extremely unlikely that the U.S. Supreme Court would become involved in any way, Mr. Gormley said.

To that end, Mr. Gormley said, Mr. Trump’s best strategy may be to promise quiet acceptance of his current position rather than retribution.

“My view is that [Mr. Trump] should hire a moving company and officially relocate to Mar-a-Lago as soon as possible,” Mr. Gormley said. “It doesn’t mean that he has to resign, but if he can convince Congress that he is moving on and will stay out of politics in the future, it may save him the trouble of having impeachment further stain his legacy and could even be a formal deal between his legal team and members of Congress.”

Mr. Gormley has written and spoken much about the upheaval and strain on both the political system and American society as a whole that impeachment causes, and, therefore, he strongly cautions its implementation.

Advertise with us

Yet he said Mr. Trump’s case is without precedence.

“I do worry about [the upheaval impeachment may cause],” Mr. Gormley said. “I generally in my years have cautioned against impeachments because they come at a high price. They sap the physical and emotional energy of the whole country, not to mention all three branches of the federal government, and should not be something done lightly.

“At same time, this isn’t the first infraction by Trump, and not his first rodeo in terms of impeachment. [Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine] famously said after Trump’s first impeachment that she thought ‘he had learned his lesson.’ Well, the big concern is that he hasn’t learned his lesson. Doing nothing could set dangerous precedence in this country that says this type of behavior is allowed unchecked.”

Nick Trombola: ntrombola@post-gazette.com