WASHINGTON – Democrats stood firm Thursday against Judge Peter Phipps’s nomination to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals but Republicans advanced him anyway.

The Senate Judiciary Committee sent the Western District of Pennsylvania judge’s nomination to the floor on a 12-10 vote that followed party lines. Senators also advanced William Stickman’s nomination to the Western District bench on a separate party-line vote.

Democrats offered no explanation for their opposition to Mr. Stickman, and spokesmen for Sen. Dianne Feinstein, ranking Democrat, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Ms. Feinstein, D-Calif, explained her objection to Judge Phipps during Thursday morning’s committee meeting.

Advertise with us

He has been a district court judge only eight months, he has no criminal trial experience, and he would add no diversity to a circuit court that serves urban areas with high minority populations, she said.

Democrats are particularly aggrieved that Judiciary Committee Chairman Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., pushed through his nomination over the objection of his home-state senator, Bob Casey, D-Pa.

Traditionally the Judiciary Committee requires both of a nominees’ home-state senators to sign off on blue slips of paper before confirmation hearings are scheduled, but Mr. Graham – like his predecessor Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, -- has not followed the rule since Donald Trump’s election. Instead he has pushed Trump nominees through with or without Democratic home-state senators’ consent.

“In the past, the blue slip was an absolute veto used by one senator to block a nominee, something my Republican colleagues now say cannot happen. The only thing that has changed from them to now is which party is in power,” Ms. Feinstein said.

In 2016 Mr. Grassley allowed U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., to block Obama nominee Rebecca Ross Haywood’s nomination to the Third Circuit.

Advertise with us

“I want to remind my colleagues what’s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander,” Ms. Feinstein said. “Mr. Casey has returned blue slips on 11 district court nominees including Trump nominees. Given his willingness to work with Republicans in the Senate and the White House it is concerning that his blue slip is being ignored in this situation.”

Mr. Casey, who is not on the committee, has previously expressed concerns about Judge Phipp’s “judicial and constitutional philosophy” as well as his limited experience on the bench.

Mr. Casey and Ms. Feinstein both supported his nomination late last year to the Western District of Pennsylvania.

The Third Circuit hears cases on appeal from Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and the Virgin Islands.

Mr. Phipps has been a senior litigator in the federal programs of the Department of Justice’s Civil Division and a civil litigator at Jones Day.

Advertise with us

Mr. Stickman is a partner with the Pittsburgh firm Del Sole Cavanaugh Stroyd, where his practice focuses on commercial and appellate matters.

Confirmation votes of the full Senate have not yet been scheduled.

Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.