WASHINGTON – Three Pennsylvania judicial nominees appeared before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday, but U.S. Sen. Bob Casey introduced only two of them.

Mr. Casey, D-Pennsylvania, told the committee that William Stickman and Jennifer Philpott Wilson are well qualified to serve on the Western and Middle Districts of Pennsylvania, respectively. He made no mention of Pittsburgher Peter Phipps, the Western District judge nominated — over the senator’s objections — to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals.

Judge Phipps was later introduced by U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pennsylvania, as a jurist with a reputation for integrity, trustworthiness, humility, brilliance and professionalism.

It is customary for senators of nominees’ home states to introduce them to the Judiciary Committee, but in Judge Phipps’ case, Sen. Casey said only that “I have strong opinions about the circuit court and blue slips but in the interest of time we’ll save that for another day.”

Advertise with us

By Senate tradition the Judiciary Committee does not advance nominations unless both of a nominee’s home-state senators give their consent by signing blue slips of paper.

Judiciary Committee Chairman Lindsay Graham, R-South Carolina, scheduled a hearing for Mr. Phipps without Mr. Casey’s consent.

In a statement last month Mr. Casey said he believes Judge Phipps has “strong character, great intellect and integrity.” However, he said he has “significant concerns about Judge Phipps’s judicial and constitutional philosophy” as well as his limited experience on the bench. Just six months ago Judge Phipps was easily confirmed — with Mr. Casey’s support — to the Western District of Pennsylvania.

His confirmation to the Third Circuit could prove contentious.

“I am troubled not by your background or record here, frankly, but that the administration has decided to nominate you to a circuit court position after less than a year and after the persistent and vocal objection of your home-state senator, Sen. Casey,” Sen. Chris Coons, D-Delaware, told Judge Phipps during Wednesday’s confirmation hearing.

Advertise with us

Mr. Coons also pointed out the committee’s double standard when it refused to schedule a hearing on Rebecca Ross Haywood, an Obama nominee to the Third Circuit, after Mr. Toomey withheld his blue slip.

The Third Circuit sits in Philadelphia and hears cases on appeal from Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and the Virgin Islands.

In remarks before the committee, Judge Phipps did not sound offended by Mr. Casey’s objection to his nomination. Rather he thanked the senator “for his support of my nomination in the district court and for his gracious and respectful consideration of my nomination to the Third Circuit.”

Mr. Stickman and Ms. Wilson sailed through the committee hearing with just a few minutes each on the hot seat, with most of that time spent introducing family members in the audience. Earlier, senators questioned Judge Phipps for more than an hour in a series of cordial exchanges.

Several questions centered around his view of the Chevron doctrine, a legal principle that gives deference to agency experts when regulations are ambiguous.

Advertise with us

Judge Phipps responded by saying he has evaluated the pros and cons of the doctrine and that he believes it is good in principle.

U.S. Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Connecticut, expressed concerns about whether the scope of Judge Phipps’ experience has prepared him for the appellate level.

Judge Phipps told the committee he has never served as lead counsel on a criminal case and has never had a criminal case before him at the district court.

“Having been a district judge, one of the things that you realize is exactly how broad the reach of the materials that come before a federal court are, and I think every person that comes to any bench realizes there’s an area they may wish they knew more about,” he responded.

Mr. Phipps has served as a senior litigator in the federal programs of the Department of Justice’s Civil Division and as a civil litigator at Jones Day.

Advertise with us

Ms. Wilson is a partner with Philpott Wilson LLP in Perry County.

Mr. Stickman is a partner with the Pittsburgh firm Del Sole Cavanaugh Stroyd, where his practice focuses on commercial and appellate matters.

“All three are well-qualified for the bench, and I enthusiastically support all of their nominations,” Mr. Toomey told the Judiciary Committee.

The committee votes have not yet been scheduled.

Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.