A federal appeals court in California ruled Wednesday that President Donald Trump acted beyond his authority when issuing an executive order attempting to penalize so-called “sanctuary cities” for refusing to cooperate with the administration’s immigration crackdown.
The decision, issued by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, barred the Trump administration from defunding of the cities of San Francisco and Santa Clara, the case’s two plaintiffs, but it did not uphold a nationwide injunction issued late last year by U.S. District Court Judge William Orrick of the Northern District of California. Instead, by a vote of 2-1, the three-judge panel sent the case back to the district court for additional fact finding on the order’s nationwide impact.
Cities and states across the country had varying responses to Mr. Trump’s executive order, which he signed in January 2017: some initiated lawsuits and others introduced noncooperation legislation.
The state California, which has clashed with the administration repeatedly over efforts to curtail legal and illegal immigration, refused to comply with Mr. Trump’s order. In response, the Justice Department filed a lawsuit against California in March. Three state laws, according to Attorney General Jeff Sessions, “intentionally obstruct and discriminate against the enforcement of federal immigration law,” impeding U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) from deporting non-citizens.
“When a president overreaches and tries to assert authority he doesn’t have under the Constitution, there needs to be a check on that power grab,” San Francisco City Attorney Dennis Herrera said in a statement Wednesday. “The courts did that today, which is exactly what the framers of the Constitution had in mind.”
Santa Clara County Counsel James R. Williams said the decision was a victory for a key provision of the U.S. Constitution.
“Today’s divided Ninth Circuit opinion is a victory for criminal aliens in California, who can continue to commit crimes knowing that the state’s leadership will protect them from federal immigration officers whose job it is to hold them accountable and remove them from the country,” Justice Department spokesperson Devin O’Malley said in a statement. “The Justice Department continues to maintain that - as the dissenting judge recognized - the President exercised his lawful authority when he issued the sanctuary city Executive Order.”
Wednesday’s ruling follows Judge Orrick’s November decision that the president’s requirement to hold, detain and turn over non-citizens to the federal government reached beyond his authority. Federal law only requires the sharing of information by state and local governments with federal officials, not more.
The decision is seen as step forward for immigration advocates in their ongoing battle with the Trump administration. “Yet again, the rule of law trumps the president’s efforts to advance his war against hard working families who can’t normalize their status in America,” California state Sen. Kevin de Leon told The Washington Post.
Last month, a federal judge in Sacramento largely rejected a challenge by the Trump administration of three statewide California sanctuary laws.
In April, a federal judge in Los Angeles sided with the city in a ruling that said the administration could not consider sanctuary policies in parsing out police grants.
Chicago and Philadelphia also won court challenges of the administration’s authority to yank law enforcement grants based on sanctuary policies. The 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the decision in the Chicago case.
The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, though, has allowed a Texas law requiring police chiefs and sheriffs to cooperate with federal immigration officials to go into effect. Texas lawmakers passed the requirement in response to the sanctuary city movement.
The U.S. Supreme Court has not yet weighed in on the sanctuary policies or on the legality of the administration’s effort to end protections from deportation for immigrants who came to the U.S. when they were young.
The Supreme Court decided 5 to 4 in June to uphold Mr. Trump’s travel ban, which was a revision of an executive order the president issued shortly after taking office.
The order bans foreign visitors and immigrants from several mostly Muslim-majority nations. Lower courts had struck down the ban.
Los Angeles Times and The Associated Press contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.