Democrats called it abhorrent and cruel. Republicans stood behind it, tacitly, while calling for changes.

That was the party-line reaction from elected officials in Pennsylvania on Monday as criticism mounted over a Trump administration policy that is separating some immigrant children from their parents at the nation’s southern border.

The outrage from Democrats and cautiousness from the GOP underscores the widespread political and humanitarian interest over President Donald Trump’s hard-line immigration stances, which have been a primary and divisive focus of his presidency.

Pennsylvania’s top Republican, U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, walked a fine line between justifying the policy and favoring changes. In two radio interviews Monday morning, Mr. Toomey called the separation of children and parents “heart-wrenching” and “horrendous,” but said the policy shouldn't be reversed.

Advertise with us

“As you know, of course, if a woman in Pennsylvania breaks a law, commits a crime and she's arrested and prosecuted, her children do not go into her prison cell with her,” Mr. Toomey said on Erie’s 1400 WJET. “She is separated from her children. That is a painful exercise, but really, how do you avoid it?”

But, Mr. Toomey added, Congress should look at passing legislation addressing the use of family detention facilities where parents are held in “a humane environment” while their immigration cases are processed.

The Republican's foil in the Senate, Democrat Bob Casey, stood out as one of the most vocal critics of the policy, calling on the president to reverse course and end what he called the "inhumane" treatment of immigrant families.

Mr. Casey’s spokesman, Andres Anzola, said the senator will continue to push for action on a bill introduced by Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., that would prevent the Department of Homeland Security from taking children from their parents at the border. Mr. Casey joined a coalition of Democratic senators in three separate letters sent to the administration over the past five months condemning the policy.

Republican Rep. Lou Barletta, who is challenging Mr. Casey for his Senate seat this November, issued a statement defending the policy.

Advertise with us

“No one wants to see children separated from their parents, and no child should be punished for their parents’ choice to break the law," Mr. Barletta said in a statement. “Sadly, this is the unfortunate, temporary result of any parent who has committed a crime for which they have to be processed, regardless of whether or not they are an American citizen or have entered the country illegally.”

Mr. Barletta, who, like Mr. Trump, is well-known for his hard-line immigration stances, called for a fix to a “broken” immigration system — a “clear, legal path forward” for immigrants, he said — so they aren't encouraged to come to the U.S. illegally and put their families in such a predicament.

Facing an issue that could have political consequences, two Western Pennsylvania Congressmen locked in a tight race called for action in different tones.

Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Upper St. Clair, called on his colleagues in Congress to take bipartisan action to end what he called a “cruel” policy that doesn't make the country any safer.

His opponent for the newly-drawn 17th Congressional District, Republican Rep. Keith Rothfus of Sewickley, said he is committed to "protecting the well-being and safety of all children" -- calling the problem "complex," but one that can be solved "responsibly."

Advertise with us

"I believe it is possible to uphold our nation’s laws and ensure border security while taking steps to look out for the well-being of these children during a difficult situation," Mr. Rothfus said. "I will continue to work with my colleagues to find solutions that minimize the impact on the children involved during unlawful entry into the US including, where feasible, keeping families together."

Elsewhere in Western Pa., Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, blasted the policy — which he said was “Trump’s policy, and his policy alone” — as “abhorrent” and “possibly illegal and unconstitutional.”

Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, talked of his duty to work with his Congressional colleagues to "update our border policies in a way that is fully good for our citizens, tough on criminals and humane to families looking for a better life." He called for a responsible debate absent of "sensationalized rumors, half-truths and falsehoods" on how to best protect his constituents and keep the U.S. safe.

"For instances when the child is verifiably not being exploited or facing any danger, then I agree with President Trump that current policy should be changed to keep family units together," Mr. Kelly said, adding that as a father and grandather, the separation of child and family is "deeply troubling" to him.

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.