WASHINGTON — In an embarrassment for House Republican leaders, conservatives on Friday scuttled a bill that combines stricter work and job training requirements for food stamp recipients with a renewal of farm subsidies popular in GOP-leaning farm country.
With 30 Republicans joining Democratic opponents, the House rejected the bill 213-198. Members of the conservative Freedom Caucus withheld their votes over leaders’ refusal to allow a vote on immigration reform.
Three Pennsylvania representatives – Keith Rothfus of Sewickley, Scott Perry of York and Brian Fitzpatrick of Bucks County – were among the Republicans voting no.
“This bill was a missed opportunity for serious reforms of agricultural subsidy programs,” Mr. Rothfus said in a written statement after the vote. “We must reform our agricultural programs in a manner that limits exposure to the forgotten men and women in our country: the hardworking taxpayer.”
Most Republican “no” votes, however, seemed come out of frustration with leadership’s unwillingness to address immigration rather than out of disenchantment with the content of the farm bill. Members of conservative Freedom Caucus led the opposition from within the party, saying they wouldn’t vote for the farm bill without an immigration vote.
For Democrats, a major sticking point was a work requirement beneficiaries of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, commonly referred to as food stamps, although they had many other objections too, including what they saw as the bill’s failure to do enough for crop insurance, conservation, research and protection from invasive species.
“This body gives money out to rich people all the time and doesn’t ask for any work requirements,” U.S. Rep. Keith Ellison, D-Minn., said in a floor speech. He called the bill an effort to blame and shame the poor.
“Many SNAP recipients face legitimate barriers to enrolling in these programs such as unreliable transportation … and low housing security,” he said. “It is very difficult to stay employed if you are homeless.”
Democrats like U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, said they won’t allow Republicans to cut social service programs like SNAP in order to pay for revenue losses that stem from corporate tax cuts they pushed through in December.
“I’m not going to pay for their tax cuts on the backs of the poor, and that’s what they want to do,” Mr. Doyle said in an interview Friday.
U.S. Rep Ruben Gallego, D-Ariz., called the bill “reprehensible” and a “direct attack on the poor” because it would reduce funding for free school lunch programs.
He said he got free lunches at school as a child, and knew first-hand that kids worried about the next meal faced challenges in succeeding in school.
Republican supporters said the bill’s work requirements provide a compassionate boost to able-bodied SNAP recipients.
“The role of government is not to keep folks trapped in poverty and help make them comfortable living in it, but to try to lend them a helping hand so they can learn a job skill, get a job, and live better lives with more independence,” said U.S. Rep. Bruce Poliquin, R-Maine.
Other Republicans said the work requirements would empower SNAP recipients, reduce unemployment, and instill a sense of pride by helping people become self-sufficient.
“We owe it to families who haven’t been able to connect themselves to the job market to help them do better,” said U.S. Rep. Rob Woodall, R-Ga.
Leaders of the Pittsburgh-based anti-hunger group Just Harvest say there are better ways to do that.
“If Congress wants to reduce the number of people receiving SNAP, they need to look at ways to reduce hunger and poverty,” Just Harvest said in a statement before the vote. “Instead of cutting access to food assistance, they should be strengthening SNAP while also making real investments in job training and education; ensuring that workers are paid living wages; and supporting people’s ability to maintain employment by funding affordable, high-quality child care and medical leave.”
In Pennsylvania, more than 80 percent of SNAP funding goes to households with children, seniors or people with disabilities, according to the state Department of Human Services, which administers the program.
Mr. Rothfus said he would have voted for the bill if it restricted the wealthiest farmers’ use of subsidies through agricultural risk programs designed to stabilize the agricultural industry. Those subsidies are currently available to individuals farmers with annual incomes below $900,000 and couples with income below $1.8 million. Mr. Rothfus wants those limits reduced to $500,000 and $1 million.
“When you have very wealthy folks taking advantage of these programs and you have crop insurance subsidies on top of that, you have to start asking some questions,” he said in an interview Friday.
Although Mr. Rothfus is a former member of the Freedom Caucus, he said his no vote had nothing to do with caucus members’ efforts to leverage an immigration vote.
Friday’s vote was a blow to GOP leaders, who had hoped to tout the new work requirements for recipients of food stamps.
More broadly, it exposed fissures within the party in the months before the midterm elections, and the Freedom Caucus tactics rubbed many rank-and-file Republicans the wrong way.
“You judge each piece of legislation on its own,” said Rep. Tom Cole, R-Okla. “You don’t hold one thing hostage for something that’s totally different and has nothing to do with it. I would say that’s a mistake in my view.”
Key conservatives in the rebellious House Freedom Caucus opposed the measure, seeking leverage to win conservative policies an advantage in a debate on immigration next month. Negotiations with GOP leaders Friday morning failed to bear fruit, however, and the unrelated food and farm measure was defeated.
Conservative Rep. Jim Jordan, R-Ohio, said some members had concerns over the farm bill, but said, “That wasn’t my main focus. My main focus was making sure we do immigration policy right” and “actually build a border security wall.”
House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., took steps to call for a re-vote in the future but it’s not clear when the measure might be revived. A handful of GOP moderates opposed the bill, too, but not enough to sink it on their own.
In any case, Mr. Ryan has an obvious problem on his hands.
“His caucus is in mutiny,” said Mr. Doyle. “It’s a caucus that’s at war with each other. It’s fractionalized and you’ve got a lame duck speaker who just can’t seem to get the ball lined up.”
Opposition came from all corners, including from farmers who visited Capitol Hill this week to lobby against it. Among them were seven members of the Pennsylvania Farmers Union, who opposed cuts to conservation programs, producer grants, programs that promote organic agriculture, and funding for marketing and promotion.
“The farm bill touches all of our lives, and it has major implications for the future of our food system,” PFU President Heidi Secord said in a written statement Friday. “What we’ve seen so far out of the House of Representatives is a piece of legislation that cuts conservation; cuts local, regional and specialty market development; and provides little support to help family farmers and ranchers who are struggling with low farm prices.”
The farm bill, a twice-per-decade rite on Capitol Hill, promises greater job training opportunities for recipients of food stamps, a top priority for House leaders. Democrats are strongly opposed, saying the stricter work and job training rules are poorly designed and would drive 2 million people off of food stamps. They took a victory lap after the vote.
“On a bipartisan basis, the House rejected a bad bill that failed farmers and working families,” said Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif. “Republicans wrote a cruel, destructive Farm Bill that abandoned farmers and producers amid plummeting farm prices and the self-inflicted damage of President Trump’s trade brinkmanship.”
Currently, adults 18-59 are required to work part-time to receive SNAP benefits or agree to accept a job if they’re offered one. Stricter rules apply to able-bodied adults 18-49, who are subject to a three-month limit of benefits unless they meet a work or job training requirement of 80 hours per month.
Under the new bill, the tougher requirement would be expanded to apply to all adults on SNAP, with exceptions for of seniors, pregnant women, caretakers of children under the age of 6, or people with disabilities. Roughly 1.8 million Pennsylvanians receive assistance through SNAP.
The measure would have greatly expanded funding for state-administered job training programs, but Democrats and outside critics say the funding for the proposed additional job training would require huge new bureaucracies, extensive record-keeping requirements, and that the funding levels would fall far short of what’s enough to provide job training to everybody covered by the new job training requirements.
“While I agree that there are changes that need to be made to the SNAP program, this is so clearly not the way to do it,” said Rep. Colin Peterson of Minnesota, top Democrat of the Agriculture Committee. “The bill cuts more than $23 billion in SNAP benefits and will result in an estimated 2 million Americans unable to get the help they need.”
He said it “turns around and wastes billions ... cut from SNAP benefits to create a massive, untested workforce training bureaucracy.”
In addition to food stamps, the measure would renew farm safety-net programs such as subsidies for crop insurance, farm credit and land conservation. Those subsidies for farm country traditionally form the backbone of support for the measure among Republicans, while urban Democrats support food aid for the poor.
On Thursday, supporters of the agriculture safety net easily defeated an attempt to weaken the government’s sugar program, which critics say gouges consumers by propping up sugar prices.
The measure mostly tinkered with farm programs, adding provisions aimed at boosting high-speed internet access in rural areas, assist beginning farmers, and ease regulations on producers. But since the measure makes mostly modest adjustments to farm policy, some lawmakers believe that the most likely course of action this year is a temporary extension of the current measure, which expires at the end of September.
In the Senate, the chamber’s filibuster rules require a bipartisan process for a bill to pass. There, Agriculture Committee Chairman Pat Roberts, R-Kan., promises a competing bill later this month and he’s signaling that its changes to food stamps would be far more modest than the House measure.
Correction, posted May 18, 2018: An earlier version of this story incorrectly identified the party affiliation of Rep. Keith Ellison.
Kate Giammarise and The Associated Press contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.