Now two US federal judges have ordered a freeze on President Donald Trump's newest travel ban this week, saying it was essentially targeted at Muslims in violation of the US Constitution.
Maryland District Judge Theodore Chuang said Wednesday the ban on travelers from over half a dozen countries essentially had not changed from the first two versions, which were shot down in lower courts as discriminating against a single religion.
He issued a somewhat less complete halt on the ban than his counterpart in Hawaii did a day earlier, but in some ways, Chuang’s ruling was more personally cutting to Trump.
He pointed out, as in earlier rulings, that Trump had repeatedly promised a ban on Muslims coming into the country during last year's presidential election.
Chuang ruled that the president’s own words cast his latest attempt to impose a travel blockade as the “inextricable re-animation of the twice-enjoined Muslim ban.”
Chuang was the second federal judge this week to order a block on the open-ended ban, issued in a White House executive order in September and which was set to take effect on Wednesday.
Read More
On Tuesday, Hawaii District Judge Derrick Watson also objected to the ban, saying it illegally discriminated against populations of countries named in the order and would not, as it claimed, add to US national security. But his ruling did not address whether Trump’s intent in imposing the directive was to discriminate against Muslims. He said the president had merely exceeded the authority Congress had given him in immigration law.
“It’s significant that the two judges who examined it found that the ban violated the law in several ways, which gives the appellate courts and ultimately the Supreme Court more options for striking it down,” said Becca Heller, director of the International Refugee Assistance Project, one of the plaintiffs in the Maryland case.
Another challenge is pending in Washington state.
The Justice Department already had vowed to appeal Watson’s ruling, which the White House said “undercuts the President’s efforts to keep the American people safe and enforce minimum security standards for entry into the United States.” Both Watson’s temporary restraining order and Chuang’s preliminary injunction are also interim measures, meant to maintain the status quo as the parties continue to argue the case.
Trump's third set of travel restrictions again named Iran, Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen, and added Chad and North Korea to the list, while also barring many officials from Venezuela.
The administration had cast the new measure as one that was necessary for national security, implemented only after officials conducted an extensive review of the information they needed to vet those coming to the U.S. Those countries that were either unwilling or unable to produce such information even after negotiation, officials have said, were included on the banned list.
“These restrictions are vital to ensuring that foreign nations comply with the minimum security standards required for the integrity of our immigration system and the security of our Nation,” the White House said after Watson’s ruling. “We are therefore confident that the Judiciary will ultimately uphold the President’s lawful and necessary action and swiftly restore its vital protections for the safety of the American people.”
Like Watson’s order, Chuang’s 91-page ruling also found Trump had exceeded his authority under immigration law, but only partially.
The order - which has “no specified end date and no requirement of renewal” - violated a non-discrimination provision in the law in that it blocked immigrants to the U.S. based on their nationality, Chuang wrote.
But Chuang said he could not determine, as Watson did, that Trump had violated a different part of federal immigration law requiring him to find entry of certain non-immigrant travelers would be “detrimental” to U.S. interests before blocking them.
Chuang instead based much of his ruling on his assessment that Trump intended to ban Muslims, and thus his order had run afoul of the Establishment Clause of the Constitution.
Trump has battled with the courts since the first version of the ban, and in June finally gained Supreme Court approval to implement an amended second version for 90 days, which ended last month.
Despite temporary blocks from courts, previous travel restrictions have already affected people with ties to the targeted countries.
“I have friends and colleagues who had to cancel weddings, who had to figure out how they were going to be able to ever see their grandparents again,” said Jamal Abdi, policy director at the National Iranian American Council.
Given past challenges to its travel restrictions, Abdi suspects the Trump administration knew this latest iteration of the travel ban “was not going to pass muster.”
“And my fear is that this is sort of the status quo, and that the administration is actually fine with it — that they have actually achieved what they intended to do, which was to drive down travel from these particular mostly Muslim-majority countries,” Abdi said.
Hundreds of protesters gathered in front of the White House on Wednesday, chanting "no Muslim ban," and "no ban, no wall, freedom for all" — referencing Trump's plans to build a wall on the Mexican border.
Yemeni Fathi al-Huthaifi, 41, told Agence France-Presse his wife is stranded in Saudi Arabia as a result of the ban.
"She's waiting for her visa but the travel ban makes it delayed, delayed," explained Huthaifi, who has five children, all with US citizenship.
On Tuesday, the White House said it would fight the decision from Judge Watson, pointing to yet another likely fight in the Supreme Court.
"We are therefore confident that the judiciary will ultimately uphold the president's lawful and necessary action and swiftly restore its vital protections for the safety of the American people," the White House said.
The Washington Post and The New York Times contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.