WASHINGTON — Standard deductions would double, future profits of offshore subsidiaries could return to the U.S. tax-free, the mortgage-interest deduction would remain for primary residences, and the tax code would be simplified under a Senate Republican tax reform plan unveiled Wednesday.
The plan is sweeping in scope but omits critical, controversial details that are likely to take months to work out in a bitterly divided, GOP-led Congress.
There are no details on how much it would cost, though back-of-the-envelope estimates by outside experts put the tax cuts in the range of $5 trillion over the next 10 years. The net cost to the federal debt would be far less — probably in the range of $1.5 trillion under deal put together by Senate Budget Committee Republicans — and the real battles will come as lawmakers quarrel over which tax breaks might be eliminated to help pay the balance.
“The biggest thing people are going to see is a tax deduction for themselves, a simplification in terms of their filing, and I think they’re going to see a very strong economy. They’re going to see more job opportunities, upward pressure on wages, bigger job gains [and] fewer unemployed people,” said U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., a Finance Committee member who worked with leadership on the framework.
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., describes the plan much differently. “It gives huge tax cuts to the wealthiest and the biggest corporations and socks it to the middle class,” he said.
He and other Democrats say the plan cuts taxes for the wealthy without helping the middle class, and that it will set the stage for cuts to Medicare and Social Security when revenues fall short.
The plan collapses seven individual tax brackets into three with rates of 12 percent, 25 percent and 35 percent and provides an option for Congress to add a fourth bracket for the highest earners. Income levels are not specified. Under current law, rates range from 10 percent to 39.6.
“What this plan does, is the top rate on the wealthiest comes down and the bottom rate on working-class families goes up. What kind of plan is this?” Mr. Schumer said.
Republicans say the increase on the poor will be offset by higher standard deductions and the lower rates for top earners would be offset by ending deductions and closing loopholes.
Their plan would reduce the corporate tax rate from 35 percent to 20 percent. And for five years, companies could further reduce their taxes by immediately writing off investments.
President Donald Trump, whose administration helped craft the plan, said the tax relief would enable businesses to expand, hire more workers and raise wages, all of which help the middle class.
“This is a revolutionary change, and the biggest winners will be the everyday American workers as jobs start pouring into our country, as companies start competing for American labor, and as wages start going up at levels that you haven’t seen in many years,” the president said Wednesday afternoon during a campaign-style speech in Indiana.
Democrats are incredulous.
“The track record says no,” Mr. Schumer said. “For big corporations, profits right now are way up but wages are not. Corporations have plowed all that money into CEO bonuses, stock buybacks and dividends for their shareholders. They’re plush with money already.”
He said Democrats are open to talking about tax breaks for small businesses but not for big corporations.
Republicans say rate reductions will be offset by closing loopholes that allow write-offs, but Mr. Schumer said their plan doesn’t bear that out.
The framework would eliminate estate taxes to provide relief to of multimillion-dollar businesses, investments and real estate.
U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, said the framework is a strong template for reforms to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of tax laws.
U.S. Rep Bill Shuster, R-Bedford, called the proposal “a great step towards leveling the playing field for American workers and providing relief to the middle class.”
But among some of their Republican colleagues, a battle already is brewing over a move to eliminate the deduction for state and local taxes, which is especially valuable to people in high-tax states such as New York, New Jersey and California. Republicans from those states are vowing to fight it.
The plan also does away with most itemized deductions that reduce taxes on affluent families, but retains benefits for charitable giving, mortgage interest, college savings and contributions to retirement plans such as 401(k).
It would seek to help families by calling for an increased child tax credit and opening it to families with higher incomes. The credit currently is $1,000 per child.
Also proposed is a new tax credit of $500 to help pay for the care of the elderly and the sick who are claimed as dependents by the taxpayer.
Mr. Toomey confirmed that the mortgage deduction would remain for primary residences but said there’s a chance Congress will limit deductions, for example, on “a third beach home.”
The mortgage interest deduction “is a very, very popular feature. It’s very, very broadly used, and [eliminating] it would make the job of getting something passed much, much more difficult,” he acknowledged
It’s a must-have for Democrats because of the relief it provides to middle-class homeowners, but they’re looking for even more help for the middle class.
The Republican plan “contains massive tax cuts for the super-rich, big corporations and Washington special interests, which won’t create jobs or grow incomes for middle class families,” said U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa.
He wants to “scrap these tax giveaways … and instead work in a bipartisan way to put the middle class and our small businesses first in any tax reform proposal.”
Mr. Trump said he believes Democrats will come along because “it’s the right thing to do, and I know many of them and they’re telling me it’s the right thing to do.”
The White House was deeply involved in creating the plan along with Republican leaders in Congress, and the president plans to travel the country to promote it as a smart alternative to the current taxes that have become barriers to global competition. He began his tax tour Wednesday.
“We want our companies to hire and grow in America and to raise wages for American workers and to help rebuild American cities and towns. That is how we will all succeed together and grow together as one team,” he said in Indianapolis.
It doesn’t sound that way if you listen to Mr. Schumer, who said his caucus is united in the believe that “not one penny of tax relief should go to the top 1 percent.”
The political stakes are high for Republicans and for Trump, whose agenda has largely stalled as the GOP abandoned efforts to repeal the Obama-era health law. Republicans see tax overhaul as a once-in-a-generation opportunity that could produce a large political payoff, though some polls show the public is skeptical that average Americans will benefit much.
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said his party has a “once-in-a-generation opportunity to fundamentally rethink our tax code” and to “unleash the economy – promoting growth, attracting jobs, and improving American competitiveness in the global market.”
The Senate is expected to vote on the federal budget in the next two weeks, and that would clear a path for tax reform later this fall. If it passes a conference committee would likely reconcile it with a separate version the House is working on, then return it to both chambers for up-or-down votes. Mr. Toomey hopes it to be signed into law by year’s end.
Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.