WASHINGTON — As its long-running and often hostile presidential nominating process drags on, Republican National Committee chairman Reince Priebus delivered an impassioned appeal for party members to close ranks behind whomever wins the nomination.

“It’s essential to victory in November that we all support our candidate,” Mr. Priebus said in a speech Friday to the party’s leadership gathered in Hollywood, Fla. “This goes for everyone, whether you’re a county party chairman, an RNC member or a presidential candidate.”

“Politics is a team sport and we can’t win unless we rally around whoever becomes our nominee,” he told an audience of 168 members of the RNC brought together for the last time before the party hosts its national convention in July.

The plea didn’t sway prominent anti-Donald Trump Republicans, one of whom chose to echo his words.

Advertise with us

“Politics is a team sport,” agreed Liz Mair, a former RNC spokeswoman who founded the anti-Trump PAC Make America Awesome. “It’s just that some of us see the teams as being ‘liberals’ and ‘conservatives,’ or in some cases, ‘moderates’ or ‘libertarians,’ and some of us are more concerned about principles winning as opposed to parties, which aren’t inherently tied to particular principles.”

Rory Cooper, a senior adviser to #NeverTrump PAC, rejected Mr. Priebus’ call, arguing that “Trump is not capable of unity nor victory in November, period.”

“Donald Trump would set back the historic victories and gains made under Chairman Priebus in the House, Senate, state legislatures and Governor’s offices by harming all down ballot candidates,” Cooper said. “We are aiming to protect the party’s positions, principles and values by being resolute in our opposition to someone who does not represent what it means to be a Republican.”

Brian Baker, a co-founder of Our Principles PAC, shrugged off Mr. Priebus’ comments, saying “it’s the chairman’s job to cheer-lead for even the most unpopular Republican.”

“And he’s going to do his job until he’s replaced by Trump on or before July 20th,” Mr. Baker said in an interview, referring to the third day of the convention. He said that if the party selects Mr. Trump as the nominee, “we might as well save the money and swear in Hillary Clinton on July 21st,” the convention’s final day.

Advertise with us

“It’s a waste of energy and breath” to help Mr. Trump as the nominee, Mr. Baker said. “He’s going to lose 49 states. He’s simply that bad.”

While members of his organization have vowed to never support Mr. Trump, including co-founder Katie Packer and adviser Tim Miller, Mr. Baker said the group hasn’t taken that step. “We don’t have to take a position on Trump in November, because he can’t win the presidency,” Mr. Baker said. “He’s so fatally flawed he’s stillborn.”

On Friday, Mr. Priebus said the RNC is preparing for an open convention based on the chance that Mr. Trump fails to gather enough delegates beforehand.

“As our nomination process goes on, we are preparing for all possible scenarios,” he said. “We might have a nominee by July, or we might have a nominee through the balloting process at the convention.”

As Mr. Trump continues to argue that he should win the nomination because he has the most delegates, Mr. Priebus gave no ground on the possibility that another candidate could win the race through a series of votes at the convention.

Advertise with us

“The rules say you have to have 1,237 delegates to be the nominee. We aren’t going to hand the nomination to anyone with a plurality, no matter how close they get to 1,237,” he said. “Close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades.”

Mr. Priebus pledged that the party would run a “fair, democratic and transparent convention” in Cleveland, as he pointed to Abraham Lincoln’s nomination as well as his own.

“It took Abraham Lincoln three ballots to get a majority in 1860,” he said. “Heck, it took me seven ballots to become chairman of the RNC.”

The chairman also pointed to Lincoln’s own administration as a model for his currently fractured party, saying that the president’s rivals “didn’t just take their marbles and go home” when they did not win. Instead, they “worked together because they knew it was the right thing to do for the country.”

Targeting the Democratic presidential front-runner, Mr. Priebus presented Ms. Clinton as the relic of the past and pointed to the controversy surrounding her private e-mail server.

Advertise with us

“We know she wants to appoint a left-wing justice to the Supreme Court who will make President [Barack] Obama’s lawless presidency permanent and treat the Constitution as a doormat,” he said. “Our party is focused on the future, but she wants to drag us back to the 1990s again. I’m sure her server probably still used Windows 95.”

Mr. Priebus’ comments came a day after reports arose that Mr. Trump’s chief adviser assured Republican insiders his boss was ready to tone down his over-the-top persona.

He’s been “projecting an image,” Paul Manafort told the GOP officials. “The part that he’s been playing is now evolving.”

The latest talk from Mr. Manafort comes at a crucial moment in Trump’s campaign, as he seeks to unite the Republican Party behind his candidacy and hold off efforts to potentially snatch the nomination away if the race goes to a contested national convention.

South Carolina GOP chairman Matt Moore attended Mr. Manafort’s presentation in Florida, and emerged confident that Mr. Trump was prepared to make necessary changes.

Advertise with us

“He has an opportunity to reinvent himself as a more presidential front-runner for the party. And I hope he does that,” Mr. Moore said.

But Mr. Trump’s critics, including rival Ted Cruz, tried to use Mr. Manafort’s assertion that he has simply been “playing a part” as an opportunity to undercut the front-runner’s core strength: that he’s authentic to a fault and says what he believes, regardless of the political repercussions.

Speaking to reporters after an event in Williamsport, Pa., on Friday, Mr. Cruz said Mr. Trump’s advisers had “gone down and told Republican Party bosses that everything Donald has said on the campaign is just a show, he doesn’t believe any of it.”

If there’s an abrupt change, some supporters might feel the same way.

“If he suddenly changed, it would be really disappointing,” said Irene Mallabar, 67, a retired antique dealer from Milford, Del. “That’s not who he is,” she said at a Trump rally at the State Fairgrounds in Harrington. “It wouldn’t feel real. Or maybe we wouldn’t know what was real.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Cruz trails Mr. Trump in the delegate count, but is banking on being able to keep the front-runner from reaching the 1,237 delegates he needs to secure the nomination. That would push the GOP race toward a contested convention.

Mr. Trump wants to avoid a complicated floor fight, and top aides are promising a more traditional campaign — and candidate — to try to persuade party leaders to stick with him even he’s just shy of the delegates he needs.

Mr. Trump has hired a handful of more experienced advisers, including Mr. Manafort. The notoriously thrifty billionaire is also plunging $2 million into television advertising in Pennsylvania and Indiana, states that hold primary contests over the next two weeks. One traditional-looking spot features Mr. Trump talking directly into the camera about his policy proposals. The other appears aimed at softening his image, presenting him as a father and grandfather.

Next Wednesday, Mr. Trump will deliver a formal address on foreign affairs, the first in a long-promised series of a policy speeches meant to infuse his campaign with a degree of seriousness. But underscoring the push-and-pull between Mr. Trump and advisers who want him to assume a more presidential aura, it’s taken months of cajoling to get that first speech on the books.

Even as recently as Tuesday, campaign manager Corey Lewandowski — whose responsibilities have been curtailed since Mr. Manafort’s hiring — was questioning the necessity of policy speeches, saying that’s not what voters care most about.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think the voters really have as much concern, but I know you guys are dying for one,” he told reporters.

Darrell Scott, the CEO of Mr. Trump’s new National Diversity Coalition, is among those says there’s a gracious, humble private man beneath the brash exterior. That’s “the Trump I’ve always known,” Mr. Scott said.

“Trump has to make the transition from public figure to public servant,” he added. “He’s growing into this role.”

Associated Press contributed.