WASHINGTON — Patient satisfaction with pain management translates into more federal dollars for hospitals, and that has raised concerns that doctors are over-prescribing opioids to preserve their hospitals’ funding.
The problem is an unintended consequence of a provision in the Affordable Care Act that ties reimbursements to patient satisfaction, and a bipartisan group of senators in Washington wants to do something about it.
The provision was meant to reward hospitals with good results on surveys that ask hospital patients, for example, whether providers treated them respectfully, responded to call buttons promptly, listened to concerns and explained things clearly.
For lawmakers trying to stem drug abuse, the problem is that the 32-item survey includes questions about pain control, including whether hospital staff did “everything they could to help you with your pain.”
Hospitals with high scores get a greater share of funds distributed through the Hospital Value-Based Purchasing program administered by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). Distribution of about $500,000 — about 1.5 percent of all CMS reimbursements to hospitals — is based on patient satisfaction surveys.
That’s enough to give physicians and hospitals an incentive to over-prescribe opioids, said U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., who took his concerns to the Senate floor on Wednesday.
He is encouraging his colleagues to support legislation sponsored by Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wisc. A vote has not been scheduled.
Mr. Johnson’s bill would prohibit Department of Health and Human Services from considering the results of the pain questions from its calculation of Medicare reimbursement.
“We need to separate the reimbursements from Medicare from the question about dealing with pain,” Mr. Toomey said.
Others, including Pennsylvania Health Secretary Karen Murphy, are separately working on the issue. Dr. Murphy and health officials from several other states have asked hospital accreditors to reconsider standards for pain management.
CMS researchers, meanwhile, say there is no empirical evidence that failing to prescribe opioids lowers survey scores.
“Like all data, the [Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems] survey must be used responsibly,” three CMS researchers wrote last month in an article for the Journal of the American Medical Association.
“The survey is designed to assess the entire hospital experience and culture of patient-centeredness. When used as designed HCAHPS provides high insights about the patient experience that could enable and promote total quality of care improvement,” Lemeneh Tefera, William Lehrman and Patrick Conway wrote in their article.
Still, agency spokeswoman Nicole Black said CMS is reviewing how pain management is evaluated on patient satisfaction surveys in light of concerns about opioid prescribing.
Physicians like A. Jack Kabazie, director of the Institute for Pain Medicine at West Penn Hospital, said hospitals should keep asking questions about pain management but CMS should not use the responses to make funding determinations. He said some patients base their responses on medications prescribed at discharge rather than those given in the hospital.
He said he knows of no doctors who consciously consider CMS funding when they prescribe, but it could affect them subconsciously.
“No one is saying ‘We need to write for opioids to keep patients happy so their satisfaction scores are up,’ but we’re only human,” he said.
Mr. Toomey said CMS needs to find a balance that prevents over-prescribing while ensuring that people who need pain medication get it.
“I don’t know anyone who has a cavalier attitude about patient suffering from pain. I wouldn’t want my family members, myself or anyone else to be suffering from pain needlessly,” he told reporters on a conference call Wednesday. “I don’t know anyone suggesting that there’s not a place for prescription opiods … but I’m very concerned we are creating financial incentives to prescribe opioids when it may not be the optimal way to treat pain.”
Over-prescribing can lead to narcotic abuse, a gateway to heroin addiction, he said.
“The scale of the problem is shocking. The increase in the number of people that are overdosing and that are becoming addicted is really, really disturbing,” Mr. Toomey said.
Dr. Kabazie shares the senator’s concern.
“How did there get to be an opioid epidemic? Too many doctors were prescribing for too long for too many patients too quickly,” he said. “Physicians want to do the right thing for their patients. They want to prescribe appropriately, and sometimes prescribing appropriately can mean not prescribing.”
Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.