WASHINGTON — The man standing between Supreme Court nominee Judge Merrick Garland and a Senate hearing on his confirmation said Tuesday that an hourlong meeting with Judge Garland had done nothing to change his mind.
Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, the Judiciary Committee chairman, hosted Judge Garland for breakfast in the private Senate Dining Room in what was the most anticipated meeting yet between a GOP senator and President Barack Obama’s choice for the high court.
Judge Garland kept silent upon leaving, as is customary for Supreme Court nominees, and Mr. Grassley left through a back door without speaking to reporters. His office later issued a statement calling the meeting “cordial and pleasant” but one that did not change Mr. Grassley’s determination not to act.
“As he indicated last week, Grassley explained why the Senate won’t be moving forward during this hyper-partisan election year” and “thanked Judge Garland for his service,” read the statement. The only publicly released photo of the meeting came via Mr. Grassley’s Instagram account.
“Had pleasant bfast w Judge Garland this morning. Explained why the Senate won’t be moving fwd w his nomination. Next prez will decide after the ppl have a voice.”
The meeting and its predictable outcome highlighted the risks and the limits of what White House officials have described as a “play it straight” strategy — to treat Judge Garland’s confirmation process in the most typical way despite the atypical circumstances.
That has included an effort not only to secure courtesy meetings with Republican senators but also to build support for action on Judge Garland’s nomination from luminaries in the legal community. This week, for instance, 15 former presidents of the American Bar Association called on Senate leaders to take action on Judge Garland’s nomination.
As the gatekeeper to further Senate action on Judge Garland’s nomination, Mr. Grassley has acted in lockstep with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., who has vowed to leave the vacancy created by Justice Antonin Scalia’s February death to be filled by the next president.
That decision, the former Bar Association presidents wrote in a Monday letter, “injects a degree of politics into the judicial branch that materially hampers the effective operation of our nation’s highest court and the lower courts over which it presides.” The signers represent 15 of the past 24 presidents of the ABA, which plays a formal role in the Supreme Court confirmation process by rating nominees’ qualifications.
While the ABA has not made a formal assessment of Judge Garland, the former presidents noted that “Democrats and Republicans alike have noted Chief Judge Garland’s sterling credentials.”
“The President has fulfilled his constitutional duty, and it is time for the members of the United States Senate to fulfill theirs by holding a fair hearing and timely vote for the President’s nominee,” they said.
William Neukom, who served as ABA president in 2007 and 2008, told reporters in a conference call arranged by the White House that blockade of Judge Garland’s nomination is “frankly appalling.”
“This is a very unseemly instance of one branch of a three-branch government hobbling a second branch, the judiciary,” he said. “How dare one branch under-resource a second branch and keep it from doing its job.”
Another ex-president — Dennis Archer, the former Detroit mayor — said he expected everyday Americans to take a more active role in the protesting the blockade, to the point that they might influence the coming election: “I think it’s going to be much more, if it gets stretched out, that will take place.”
The White House and Senate Democrats have continued to follow a confirmation game plan aimed at keeping pressure on Republican senators who are up for re-election this year.
Judge Garland met with three of them Tuesday. After finishing breakfast with Mr. Grassley, he returned to the Senate Dining Room to meet with Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska. In the afternoon, he met with Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., who faces a potentially difficult re-election this fall.
Like Mr. Grassley, Ms. Murkowski and Mr. Toomey have lined up behind Mr. McConnell in saying no nominee should be considered this year.
And Mr. Toomey emerged from the hourlong meeting even more convinced that the most prudent course is to wait. In remarks to reporters, he made his first substantive charge against Judge Garland, expressing doubts that the nominee would rein in presidential overreach.
“I am concerned he would not adequately discharge the role of being a check on the executive branch,” Mr. Toomey told reporters after the meeting.
He also said he has “some concerns” about Judge Garland’s record and judicial philosophy. He did not elaborate.
However, he said, he found the judge to be intelligent, pleasant and likable.
Ultimately, though, “in the process of this discussion, he did not assuage my concerns,” Mr. Toomey said. “I am more convinced now than I was before that this is a choice that should be made by the next president.”
He said Judge Garland is much different than Justice Scalia, his would-be predecessor.
“If he were to be put on the court, that would change the balance of the court,” Mr. Toomey said.
Democrats characterized the meeting as an empty gesture by a partisan Republican set on blocking Mr. Obama at every turn.
Katie McGinty, Democratic state Senate primary candidate, said Mr. Toomey is playing politics with the judiciary in the hopes that GOP front-runner Donald Trump will have the opportunity to fill the vacancy.
“Sen. Toomey’s willingness to do Trump’s bidding – coupled with his commitment to support the GOP nominee even if it is Donald Trump – speak volumes about his priorities,” she said in a written statement. “Until Toomey puts partisanship aside and calls for a full and fair hearing and an up-or-down vote for Judge Garland, he is not doing his job.”
Said Preston Maddock, spokesman for the Pennsylvania Democratic Party: “This is another chapter in a record of obstruction that will undermine Toomey’s re-election. … Toomey has stood with Mitch McConnell against the will of Pennsylvanians” who overwhelmingly think Judge Garland deserves a hearing and a vote.
Mr. Toomey, meanwhile, said Pennsylvanians are divided.
“It is not possible to come to a conclusion that would satisfy everybody about this so I have made the best judgement that I can. For something as important as the fundamental balance of the court for a generation, the American people should have the maximum say.”
The Judicial Crisis Network, a conservative foundation that tracks the judiciary, supports Mr. Toomey’s position.
“Judge Garland would be a reliable liberal vote in a liberal majority on the Supreme Court for the next generation,” said Carrie Severino, chief counsel and policy director.
Obama spokesman Eric Schultz declined to detail what was discussed at the meetings Tuesday but said that Judge Garland “has enjoyed this process.”
“He finds these conversations to be instructive and helpful and thoughtful and very substantive,” he said.
Those three senators all say they will continue to hold fast against Judge Garland, and they have backing from a vocal and well-funded group of conservative activists who fear the impact he could have on the high court in replacing a stalwart conservative like Justice Scalia.
Carrie Severino, chief counsel and policy director of the Judicial Crisis Network, thanked Mr. Grassley for his stance after the meeting: “Senator Grassley understands that Merrick Garland will be the decisive fifth vote on the Court to gut the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms and the fifth vote to defer to unaccountable bureaucrats at federal agencies like the EPA.”
But Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., continued hammering away at Mr. Grassley’s refusal to take up Judge Garland’s nomination, calling him out in a Senate floor speech for holding their breakfast “in private, far away from the public eye.”
“These are not the actions of a senator and chairman who is confident with his decision to block a Supreme Court nominee,” he said. “This is the behavior of a senator who knows he’s on the wrong side of the Constitution, and the wrong side of history.”
Washington Bureau chief Tracie Mauriello, Associated Press and Tribune News Service contributed.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.