Republican and Democratic leaders leveled some of their most forceful criticisms yet against Donald Trump on Tuesday, widely denouncing the GOP presidential front-runner’s call to bar Muslims from entering the United States and signaling that Mr. Trump’s anti-immigrant and anti-Islamic rhetoric has agitated both parties more than ever.
At the White House, President Barack Obama’s top spokesman said Mr. Trump’s proposal “disqualifies him” from the presidency, marking a rare administration foray into the 2016 race. On Capitol Hill, House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said the idea was at odds with the values of their party and the U.S. as a whole.
In the space of a day, Mr. Trump’s role as a domestic political provocateur expanded to international agitator as he sent a first-of-its kind signal abroad: The leading presidential contender in the opposition party wants to keep Muslims out of the U.S.
Leaders across the globe — including British Prime Minister David Cameron, London Mayor Boris Johnson and French Prime Minister Manuel Valls — condemned Mr. Trump as officials at home worried about the long-term implications of his actions. Mr. Trump called Monday for a “total and complete” ban on Muslims entering the U.S. until we “figure out what is going on.” He reiterated his overall view on Tuesday.
It was far from clear whether the proposed ban on Muslims would have a negative effect on Mr. Trump’s popularity, which has only grown as he has escalated his rhetoric against illegal immigrants and a host of other groups. Some of his rivals treaded carefully around his remarks, and many of his most vocal critics stopped short of refusing to back him if he is the Republican nominee.
Democrats speak up
Josh Earnest, the White House press secretary, said Mr. Trump’s proposal “disqualifies him from serving as president,” declaring that his rhetoric is “harmful to the country” and makes it harder to “work in partnership” with American Muslim leaders to identify potential threats.
Mr. Earnest said that other candidates and Republican leaders “should say right now that they will not support him for president.”
Tell Donald Trump: Hate is not an American value,” Hillary Clinton wrote on Twitter.
“I don’t know what his motive is, but I know what he’s preaching is a very, very dangerous brew for America,” Vice President Joe Biden said of the Republican front-runner during an interview Tuesday on Air Force Two on the flight home from a two-day visit to the Ukraine.
“Throughout history you had demagogues trying to divert attention away from the real issues,” Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders said Tuesday during an appearance on NBC’s “The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon.”
Mr. Sanders said figures like Trump attempt to “divide” Americans.
“A few months ago we’re supposed to hate Mexicans and he thinks they’re all criminals and rapists and now we’re supposed to hate Muslims, and that kind of crap is not going to work in the United States of America,” he said. “I think what the American people understand is, given the problems that we face, we gotta stand together, come together, and create a decent life for all of our people and stop this scapegoating of one group or another.”
Republicans weigh in
Mr. Ryan, who typically stays out of the GOP presidential contest, made a strongly worded exception.
“Freedom of religion is a fundamental constitutional principle. It’s a founding principle of this country,” Mr. Ryan told reporters. “This is not conservatism. What was proposed yesterday is not what this party stands for. And more importantly, it’s not what this country stands for.”
In a private session with Republican lawmakers Tuesday morning, House Speaker Paul Ryan warned members of Congress that following Mr. Trump down this route could “doom our party,” according to two attendees.
Mr. McConnell called proposals to bar visitors on the basis of their religion “completely inconsistent” with American values.
But neither Republican said he would reject Mr. Trump if he won the nomination, and GOP senators facing difficult re-elections dodged questions about whether they would support the provocative businessman if he won the nomination. Almost all Republicans who were questioned tried to duck that possibility, saying only that they would support the eventual nominee.
“He knows that a lot of Americans agree, to a certain extent, with things that he says,” conservative radio host Rush Limbaugh said on his show Tuesday. “He also knows he’s the only one reaching those people.”
Unbowed, Mr. Trump fired a searing warning Tuesday via Twitter to fellow Republicans carping about his proposal. A majority of his supporters, he tweeted, “would vote for me if I departed the GOP & ran as an independent.”
Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, wary of alienating Mr. Trump supporters as he tries to consolidate the conservative wing of the party, emphasized that he differed with that specific policy proposed by Mr. Trump.
“I disagree with that proposal. I like Donald Trump. A lot of our friends here have encouraged me to criticize and attack Donald Trump. I’m not interested in doing so,” Mr. Cruz told reporters.
Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., a long-shot near the bottom of the field, told a New Hampshire radio station that it is “a mistake to base immigration or moratoriums based on religion,” but added, “I’ve called for something similar.” Mr. Paul was referring to a measure that would suspend the issuance of visas to refugees from about 30 countries “that have large [radical jihadi] movements,” pending strict background checks.
And former S. Rick Santorum, the winner of the 2012 Iowa caucus, seemed to embrace Mr. Trump’s impulse but differed on the details. “I’ve proposed actual concrete things and immigration law that would have — not the effect of banning all Muslims, but a lot of them because we need to get rid of the visa lottery system, which is the way in which a lot of radicals have come into this country,” he said on Sirius XM’s “Breitbart News Daily.”
The Christian Broadcasting Network’s chief political correspondent, David Brody, wrote that Mr. Trump’s position is likely to resonate with Christian evangelicals, as long as he is able to verbalize “the underlying theological problems with Islam and the Quran.” Several prominent evangelical leaders in Iowa and elsewhere who are often quick to comment on the twists and turns of the election declined to comment on Mr. Trump’s proposed ban on Muslims entering the country.
After announcing his proposal — which he said was a response to recent terrorist attacks in Paris and California — he was greeted with adoration by his legion of fans on Twitter and at a raucous rally Monday night in South Carolina. On Tuesday, Mr. Trump conducted a contentious round of morning news-show interviews in which he defended the idea against critics who have deemed it unconstitutional, illegal, racist, dangerous and un-American.
He cast it as a temporary move in response to terrorism and invoked President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s authorization of the detention of Japanese, German and Italian immigrants during World War II as precedent.
Although Mr. Trump’s aides had initially said no one would be exempt from the “total” ban, the candidate began listing exceptions he would make. U.S. citizens who are Muslim and traveling abroad would be allowed to re-enter, along with Muslim members of the U.S. military returning from tours overseas. Muslim leaders of foreign countries would also be allowed in, and exceptions would be made for athletes visiting the U.S. for competitions.
Plan might survive lawsuit
On Monday, many legal scholars were aghast and said that such a ban would certainly be struck down by courts as blatantly unconstitutional.
But on Tuesday, after Mr. Trump clarified his proposal, legal specialists said his distinctions made it far less likely the courts would strike it down.
Under a provision of immigration law, Congress has already delegated to the president broad power to issue a proclamation indefinitely blocking “the entry of any class of aliens into the United States” that he or she thinks would be “detrimental to the interests of the United States.” No president has ever used that power in such a sweeping way, but the text provides a potential statutory basis for a President Trump to carry out his plan, specialists said.
Still, if Mr. Trump won the White House and invoked that power as a justification to bar all foreign Muslims, people affected by that policy inside the United States — like a person seeking reunification with a family member, or a university that wanted to invite someone to come speak — could file a lawsuit challenging it.
Several legal questions would be raised by such a policy.
First, as a matter of international law, a treaty the United States has ratified, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, bars laws that discriminate against people because of their religion. It protects “all persons,” not just citizens of a member state.
But any lawsuit invoking that provision of the treaty would face an uphill struggle, the specialists said, because Congress has not acted to make that provision enforceable by domestic courts. So even if Mr. Trump’s policy clearly violated the provision, it is doubtful that the Supreme Court would decide that the treaty provided the judiciary with authority to strike the policy down, the specialists said.
Second, as a matter of domestic constitutional law, barring foreigners from visiting — or even barring the return of green card-holding lawful permanent residents — would be subject to a different legal test.
Because decisions about which foreigners to permit into the country are closely related to issues of foreign policy, the courts have long adopted an extremely deferential approach to reviewing such policies by Congress and the executive branch.
Indeed, for most of American history, including a famous 1889 Supreme Court decision upholding a statute passed by Congress that barred all Chinese people from coming to the United States, courts would not even review such decisions. That changed in the 1970s, when the Supreme Court began holding that it could review them.
But even after that change, the court adopted an extraordinarily solicitous standard: So long as the government cites a reason that sounds legitimate on its face for barring a foreigner from entering the country, the justices will uphold it without further scrutiny.
In practice, since establishing that standard, the Supreme Court has never overturned a decision to deny entry to someone.
In the interviews, Mr. Trump performed as he usually does — deflecting questions, avoiding specifics and talking over the journalists trying to ask him questions. During an interview on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” that lasted more than 30 minutes, host Joe Scarborough told Mr. Trump to stop talking so that he could ask the candidate a question, then cut to a commercial.
Corey Saylor, a spokesman for the Council on American-Islamic Relations, predicted that Mr. Trump’s comments would make it easier for the Islamic State terrorist group to radicalize potential recruits.
“I think that Trump’s statement is a propaganda coup for [IS],” he said. “No doubt in my mind about that.”
Call reverberates abroad
In Algeria, Rachid Tlemcani, a professor of political science at the University of Algiers, echoed that warning.
“A lot of people in the Middle East think of the United States as the last place we can go if things turn really bad, as it is the place of freedom and liberty,” Mr. Tlemcani said. “I think that sort of comment could even invite some act of violence against America. I think he is not responsible.”
Much of the rest of the world looked at the American presidential election Tuesday with a mix of befuddlement and despair, wondering how the same nation that twice put the black son of a Muslim from Kenya in the White House could now be flirting with Mr. Trump and his divisive, exclusionary stances.
Mr. Trump’s position had its admirers. His stance on Muslim immigration drew several hundred favorable comments on China’s Twitter-like social media site, Weibo, where supporters linked his idea to their own fears of the Uighurs, a minority Muslim group in China’s northwestern region whose violent militancy has become a major concern.
But in many other places, it ignited widespread condemnation that crossed ideological and social lines.
In Britain, Mr. Cameron, of the Conservative Party, called his words “divisive, unhelpful and quite simply wrong.”
Mr. Valls of France, which is still reeling from deadly attacks by Islamic extremists, wrote on Twitter: “Mr. Trump, like others, fuels hatred,” and “Our only enemy is radical Islamism.”
Mr. Trump’s comments were widely shared on social media throughout the Arab world. In a region racked by conflict, his language had an impact, including in Egypt, where he was condemned by the country’s highest religious authority and by many others, who called him an Islamophobe, a racist or, as Reem Khorshid, a 21-year-old engineering student and blogger, put it, “a madman who has no sense at all.”
Worries over Trump widespread
Some Democrats said Tuesday that the Republican Party is partly culpable in Mr. Trump’s rise.
“Republicans today are still saying they will support Trump if he is their nominee. Why? Because they are intimidated by his support and his supporters,” said Paul Begala, a strategist with the pro-Clinton super-PAC Priorities USA Action. “Trump may be the monster, but the GOP establishment is the Dr. Frankenstein who created him.”
Sen. Harry Reid of Nevada, the Senate Democratic leader, went further. “Trump is saying out loud what other Republicans merely suggest,” he said on the Senate floor.
Many Republicans worry that Mr. Trump’s proposals — which have drawn comparisons to those of Adolf Hitler and to the internment of Japanese Americans on U.S. soil during World War II — will do lasting damage to a party desperately trying to cast itself as more tolerant and open than in previous presidential elections.
Tom Ridge, a former Republican governor of Pennsylvania who became the first secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, said Tuesday he would not vote for Mr. Trump. Mr. Ridge said that his anger over Mr. Trump’s popularity has been building for months and that he was frustrated that many fellow Republicans took so long to denounce the candidate’s rhetoric.
“I think the man is an embarrassment to my party,” said Mr. Ridge, who supports Mr. Trump rival Jeb Bush. “He’s an embarrassment to our country. We deserve better than this.”
Implications arise
Mr. Trump’s actions also hold implications down the ballot. Rep. David Jolly of Florida, a centrist Republican running for U.S. Senate who backs Mr. Bush, took to the House floor Tuesday to call for Mr. Trump to end his campaign.
“I think its been a dark day for the country,” Mr. Jolly said in an interview. He encouraged other GOP leaders to “speak up.”
Republican National Committee chair Reince Priebus, who in August called Mr. Trump’s candidacy a “net positive” for the party, pushed back briefly against Mr. Trump’s proposal. “I don’t agree,” Mr. Priebus told the Washington Examiner in an interview. “We need to aggressively take on radical Islamic terrorism but not at the expense of our American values.”
He wouldn’t further elaborate, saying, “That’s as far as I’m going to go.”
Anti-Muslim rhetoric
While Mr. Trump has gone furthest in his rhetoric and proposals, other candidates have given voice to views that Democrats have condemned as anti-Muslim. “Their language may be more veiled than Mr. Trump’s, but their ideas aren’t so different,” Ms. Clinton, the Democratic presidential front-runner, wrote Tuesday on her website.
All of the GOP candidates have called for at least a pause in the acceptance of most Syrian refugees. Retired neurosurgeon Ben Carson has said that a Muslim should not be president and argued that accepting Syrian refugees into the U.S. is “a suspension of intellect.”
Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., seen by many party leaders as the GOP’s best hope for cross-party appeal, has equated Muslims with Nazis and dismissed complaints of anti-Muslim bias.
“Where is there widespread evidence that we have a problem in America with discrimination against Muslims?” Mr. Rubio said on Fox News Sunday night after Mr. Obama’s address to the nation urging tolerance.
The anti-Muslim rhetoric Mr. Trump and some of his rivals have been using stands in stark contrast to the tone struck by then-President George W. Bush after 9/11 terrorist attacks.
In working to tamp down anti-Muslim sentiment that erupted after the attacks, Mr. Bush repeatedly talked about Islam as a peaceful religion and said the terrorists did not represent Muslims around the world. He quoted the Koran during remarks at the Islamic Center of Washington six days after 9/11. Three days after that, he spoke directly to Muslims during an address before a joint session of Congress.
“We respect your faith,” Mr. Bush said. “It’s practiced freely by many millions of Americans and by millions more in countries that America counts as friends.”
On Tuesday, Mr. Trump’s message sounded much different.
“I would want to engage the Muslim community, but the Muslim community has to help us,” he said on “Morning Joe.” “They’re not helping us.”
The New York Times, Bloomberg News and Associated Press contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.