Politicians are accustomed to waiting for the results on Tuesdays, the traditional day for elections. But this Tuesday, several of the members of the big field of Republican presidential candidates will be waiting for a different kind of tally: the averages they have recorded in national polls.

That’s the yardstick Fox News is using to winnow the throng of White House hopefuls into a more manageable format of 10 or so participants in the first official debate of the 2016 election cycle. It will take place at 9 p.m. Thursday in Cleveland, but who will be taking part has yet to be determined.

Fox anticipated the challenge of putting together a coherent format with so many would-be participants in May, when it announced the rules for the debate it is sponsoring along with Facebook and the Ohio Republican Party. Among the keys for eligibility was the demand that “[participants] must place in the top 10 of an average of the five most recent national polls, as recognized by Fox News leading up to Aug. 4 at 5 p.m. ET. Such polling must be conducted by major, nationally recognized organizations that use standard methodological techniques.”

That’s obviously not a problem for the top contenders. To the consternation of many GOP traditionalists, the brash Donald Trump remains solidly atop the polling averages, followed by Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker and former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush. After that, things get more complicated.

Advertise with us

Late last week, RealClearPolitics, which compiles one of the most widely followed polling aggregations, found the rest of the field with scores ranging from 6.8 percent, for Florida Sen. Marco Rubio, to less than 1 percent for former New York Gov. George Pataki.

Mr. Rubio, former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee, neurosurgeon Ben Carson, Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul and Texas Sen. Ted Cruz — all with polling averages between 5 and 7 percent — seem certain to make the cut. That leaves Ohio Gov. John Kasich, New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie and former Texas Gov. Rick Perry competing for what are expected to be the final two spots.

Those who don’t make the cut can still get a measure of Fox News air time, however, as the network also is staging a second-team debate at 5 p.m. Thursday.

This exercise in political triage illustrates the overall logistical challenges posed by the sprawling cast of would-be nominees. It suggests not only the limits of political polling, but the eroding control of political parties as gatekeepers to the competition for the White House.

The difference among Mr. Kasich, Mr. Christie and Mr. Perry in a recent RealClearPolitics average was 1.3 percentage points, with the Ohio governor at 3.5 percent, Mr. Christie, 3 percent, and Mr. Perry, 2.2 percent.

Advertise with us

Charles Franklin, who directs the Marquette University Law School poll and is a leading national expert on survey research, notes that the difference is well within the statistical margin of error for each of the polls underlying the average figure. So, in theory, at least, Mr. Perry could actually be ahead of his Ohio colleague.

“To make such a consequential decision based on such small differences is a real problem,” Mr. Franklin said. “Certainly, no reputable pollster would say that a few tenths of a percentage point is a statistically meaningful difference. And it’s further strained by the fact that polls round to whole percentage points when they report their results. These are truly minuscule differences.”

He said the organizers might have been better advised to randomly split the field, now at 17 and counting with the addition of former Virginia Gov. Jim Gilmore, into two debates with equal billing.

Regardless of how defensible the criteria for participation may be, many Republicans nationally and in the host city are grateful that they appear to be working to allow Mr. Kasich to squeak through. At one point in July, it appeared that he would not make the cut, but he registered between 4 and 5 percent in some of the more recent polls.

Still, the possibility remains that the home state contender could be snubbed as Cleveland gets the first taste of the national attention it will garner as host of next year’s Republican National Convention.

Advertise with us

A spokesman for a candidate who seems certain to be relegated to the second-tier session shrugged off the development.

“Certainly, it’s disappointing the way this has transpired,” said Matt Beynon, an aide to former Sen. Rick Santorum, who won the Iowa caucuses on his way to being the last Republican standing against Mitt Romney in the 2012 race. “Certainly, there were other options on the table, but the big picture is that two days later, who’s going to remember who made it in or out?”

Mr. Beynon also questioned the relevance of national polls at this stage of a race that likely will be redefined in the snows of the early contests in Iowa and New Hampshire.

“The day Sen. Santorum won the Iowa caucuses, he was at 4 percent nationally,” Mr. Beynon said. “He went from 4 to 15 percent overnight.”

And Mr. Beynon offered one more bit of perspective/​consolation for the currently second-tier candidates: “We all know that the 9 o’clock debate is going to be remembered as the Donald Trump show.”

Advertise with us

Of the earlier undercard, he said, “That’s still an impressive group of people and the Fox audience at 5 o’clock is millions of people.”

The big show at 9 p.m. is the first of 12 debates sanctioned by the Republican National Committee in an effort to impose some limit on the multiplicity of debates that characterized the 2012 nominating cycle. In just one week in Iowa, a debate took place in Des Moines, followed days later by a forum in Sioux City. The final weekend before the New Hampshire primary, a Saturday night debate was followed by another Sunday morning.

But this week’s encounters show the difficulty of enforcing such rules amid the anarchy of the nominating process. Before Thursday’s dual encounters, another cattle call will occur tonight with most of the GOP candidates, this one in New Hampshire. The event, sponsored by the Union Leader newspaper, is expected to draw most of the field, although Mr. Trump has said he won’t be among them. To get around the RNC strictures, it’s not, technically, billed as a debate. The candidates will appear on the same stage at St. Anselm’s College one after another, answering a moderator’s questions.

Fergus Cullen, a former chairman of the New Hampshire Republican Party, sees tonight’s event as a harbinger of the way the nominating process will continue to defy national party guidance.

“I’m surprised the system didn’t break down sooner,” he said. “Republicans are the ones that believe in the free market; Republicans are the ones who warn against the problems of unintended consequences.”

Advertise with us

He theorized that the fact that the GOP field remained so tightly grouped was in part a function of the lack of more general debate opportunities so far, pointing out that an early New Hampshire debate, in June 2011, provided a breakout moment for former Rep. Michele Bachman. The same event damaged the candidacy of former Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, then considered one of the GOP front-runners, as he was criticized for pulling his punches in an encounter with Mr. Romney after having previously denouncing him as the author of “Obomneycare.”

“I get what they are trying to do — avoid what happened last time. I'm not criticizing the RNC or [RNC chairman] Reince [Priebus], but it’s not a solution,” Mr. Cullen said.

James P. O’Toole: jotoole@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1562.