Florida Gov. Jeb Bush made headlines when he took an Uber car to a recent campaign stop in San Francisco. Hillary Clinton didn’t mention the ride-sharing behemoth by name, but said she would “crack down” on companies that classify workers as independent contractors rather than employees, as critics contend Uber and its brethren in the share economy have done.
As the 2016 campaign heats up, candidates in both parties are wrestling with the Uber problem. Do it and other companies of its ilk exploit workers or give them new freedoms over schedules? Are they exposing antiquated transportation regulations, or are they flouting laws meant to protect consumers? However candidates decide to position themselves on Uber, Lyft and the on-demand sector, they surely must all tread carefully lest they risk losing the lucrative support of the Silicon Valley crowd.
“It’s been interesting to watch, because it feels like technology is moving faster then regulation these days,” said Matt McDonald, a partner with Washington D.C.-based public policy consulting firm Hamilton Place Strategies.
He co-authored a white paper titled “Congress Votes Uber,” which examined how quickly Uber has risen to prominence as a political issue. Uber, which was founded in 2009, was just getting started during the 2012 election cycle and did not have the market share it commands now.
Uber and Lyft usually move into a market, as they did in Pittsburgh, and ask for forgiveness from regulators rather than permission.
“Everyone thinks of Uber as a disruptor of taxis, but what if it’s a disruptor of regulators?” Mr. McDonald mused. He pointed to the recent clash between Uber and regulators in New York City, when Mayor Bill de Blasio pushed for a cap on Uber’s service. He eventually withdrew the bid under intense pressure from Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Uber itself, which mobilized drivers and supporters to rally for the cause.
Read More
Mr. McDonald said he doesn’t expect that kind of overt presence from Uber or other such companies during the 2016 campaign.
“ I don’t think they need to wade into the political arena ... unless their business is directly challenged like it was in New York,” he said. “On the national level, if there are critiques from Uber, they will be around the edges of the campaign.”
Most companies in the on-demand “gig” economy rely on independent contractors to provide services for a fee, usually via slickly designed apps, for everything from driving (Uber, Lyft) to household chores (TaskRabbit) to home rentals (Airbnb).
Uber and Lyft, whose drivers can work whatever hours they choose (some even working for both), take the earnings they get minus the company’s fee. Both companies, but especially Uber, have seen explosive growth over the past year alone.
For Democrats, ride sharing is particuarly problematic. Some of the party’s staunchest financial supporters are in Uber’s crosshairs, including taxi companies. But the biggest segment of the on-demand economy’s customers are the same people who supported Barack Obama’s grass-roots bid for the presidency. Uber snapped up former Obama adviser David Plouffe as a strategist last year.
For Libertarian-leaning Republicans, however, the anti-regulation economy holds significant appeal.
U.S. Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky opened a presidential campaign office at a San Francisco tech incubator that hosted a 24-hour “hack-a-thon” last month. And Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida’s latest book has a chapter titled “Making America Safe for Uber.”
Clearly the Uber election is underway. But at the state level in Pennsylvania, most elected officials don’t have an awful lot to say about the on-demand economy. Gov. Tom Wolf’s spokesman offered a two-sentence statement in response to a reporter’s query.
“Gov. Wolf supports ride sharing,” Wolf spokesman Jeff Sheridan wrote in an email. “The governor understands that we need to create a structure that permits ride sharing options that encourage competition for customers while making sure we protect both passengers and drivers.”
U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey’s spokesman said the senator “had not yet done his due diligence” to the point where he felt comfortable discussing ride-sharing issues.
However Sen. Bob Casey said it was important that Pennsylvania and the rest of the country “get it right” when it comes to ride sharing. He and Sen. Al Franken of Minnesota, an outspoken critic of Uber’s privacy policies, wrote a letter to Labor Secretary Thomas Perez, voicing their concerns about how workers are classified in the “gig” economy. “The on-demand ecomomy has been an important source of jobs and innovation. At the same time, we need to carefully consider the potential misclassification of workers and its ramification,” the letter states.
“All innovation can have unintended consequences,” Mr. Casey said last week. “We want the Department of Labor to address the unique nature of these companies and be vigilant about protecting workers’ rights.”
As it stands now, both Lyft and Uber are operating in Pennsylvania under two-year temporary licenses in from the Public Utility Commission. But several bills to create a new, permanent category of transportation network company have stalled in the Legislature.
Mr. Casey added that the companies in the share economy are not going anywhere, and politicians who ignore the role of business models like Uber and Lyft do so at their peril.
“In terms of the campaign, it is but one segment of the conversation, about how we grow wages,” Mr. Casey said. “This is not the work of one party.”
The Associated Press contributed. Kim Lyons: klyons@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1241 or on Twitter @SocialKimly.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.