WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama’s best chance at moving his agenda during his last two years in office depends on a handful of fellow Democrats who are campaigning across the country on promises to stand up to the unpopular president.
In Alaska Sen. Mark Begich’s campaign website boasts that he is “taking on the Obama administration.”
In West Virginia, a campaign spokeswoman told the Charleston Daily Mail that Natalie Tennant “does not support the majority of the president’s policies.”
In Kentucky, Alison Lundergan Grimes insists in a TV spot, “I’m not Barack Obama. I disagree with him on guns, coal and the EPA.”
And in Georgia, Michelle Nunn has refused to say even whether she voted him.
The distancing is no surprise to pollsters and political analysts, who note that voters typically use midterm elections to express dissatisfaction with a president they’ve lost enthusiasm for. In 35 of the last 38 midterm elections, the president’s party has lost seats.
Read More
This year it’s just a question of how many. Republicans are six Senate seats way from controlling both legislative chambers, making it much harder for the president to move his agenda or to make judicial appointments.
Their odds are good because of a number of factors. First, because of the wave of Democrats elected on Mr. Obama’s coattails in 2008, Republicans now have fewer seats to defend this cycle. Second, the GOP had luck recruiting strong candidates in purple states that have Democratic incumbents but that supported Mitt Romney in 2012.
And third, this is the first national election since the rocky rollout of HealthCare.gov, the health insurance shopping marketplace that is elemental to the president’s signature domestic policy, the Affordable Care Act.
“Republicans are going to continue to try to tie all these Democratic Senate candidates to the president because that’s what the midterm is all about: backlash against the White House. It seems like a pretty obvious playbook,” said Kyle Kondik of the University of Virginia Center for Politics.
Dartmouth College political scientist Linda Fowler agreed.
“The Republicans have been struggling all season to make this election be about the president, but Democrats have been working equally hard to localize this election and make it be about individual candidates,” she said.
Publicly, at least, the president says he understands why the people who support his agenda in Washington are turning their backs when they go back home.
“This isn’t about my feelings being hurt. These are folks who are strong allies and supporters of me, and I tell them, ‘You know what? You do what you need to do to win,’ ” he told Al Sharpton in a radio interview last week.
The sentiment doesn’t surprise political scientists like Janine Parry of the University of Arkansas.
“Most politicians are eminently pragmatic. It’s a classic case of ‘It’s just business, man.’ It’s more important to the president to keep the Senate majority than to let the lack of attention from candidates like [Arkansas incumbent Sen.] Mark Pryor bother him,” she said.
It’s a delicate balance, said Democratic strategist Paul Begala, who was an adviser to President Bill Clinton.
“Running at a time when the president is unpopular is a special challenge. If you go too far in distancing yourself you risk looking disingenuous, but if you embrace him too closely you risk drowning with him,” he said.
Mr. Begala has been on both sides of that. He remembers working on Democrat Bob Casey’s 2006 successful campaign to unseat Republican Sen. Rick Santorum in Pennsylvania.
“George W. Bush was incredibly unpopular in Pennsylvania, and we wrapped Bush around Santorum’s neck,” he said. “Nearly every ad included the statistic that Santorum voted with Bush 97 percent of the time. Now Republicans are running the same ads against Democrats.”
Republicans have to do more than just win seats; they also have to keep the ones they already have. That could be challenging in places like Kentucky, where Minority Leader Mitch McConnell is a target of voter frustration with the wider federal government.
After watching House Majority Leader Eric Cantor’s loss in the May primary, Mr. McConnell is well aware that today’s voters care less about having one of their own in leadership than about rebelling against symbols of a dysfunctional Washington.
“Voters a generation or two ago, particularly in the South, cared about having someone [from their state] in leadership. Committee chairmanships and those sorts of things were big selling points for a candidate, but now being in leadership is a detriment,” Mr. Kondik said.
“People really do hate Washington, and voters are hostile to leadership,” he said. “I don’t think Eric Cantor would have lost if he wasn’t in leadership.”
Democrats who take the long view may not be disappointed by a loss of Senate control, Ms. Parry said.
“Maybe not from the president’s perspective, but from the party’s perspective, there’s a real cynical view that it may not be a bad thing because it may better position them for 2016 if Democrats can blame Republican majorities in Congress for standing in the way of change. That takes the spotlight off the Democratic executive,” she said.
Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com, 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.