In Pennsylvania's 2008 congressional elections, Republicans weren't clamoring to take on Democratic incumbents.

Across the state two years ago, there was just one contested Republican primary in a district held by a Democrat. Now, GOP primary competitors are throwing elbows at one another all over the state. Nurtured by grassroots conservatives such as the tea party movement, the May 18 ballots will be crowded with the names of GOP House hopefuls.

A half-dozen Republicans are vying to take on Rep. Kathy Dahlkemper, D-Erie, in the 3rd District. Two Republicans are facing off in Rep. Jason Altmire's 4th District, and two more GOP rivals are seeking the Republican nomination for the 12th District seat opened with the death of Rep. John P. Murtha.

The picture is the same at the other end of the state, where Democratic registration growth in the Philadelphia suburbs, the Lehigh Valley and beyond, until recently had fueled Democratic hopes that the state was about to turn reliably blue. But the state's primary picture this year -- dominated by Republicans eager to take on Democrats -- suggests instead that Pennsylvania may be reverting to its classic swing-state reputation.

Advertise with us

The May 18 ballot rosters are a harbinger of what is expected to be the state's most competitive general election for Congress in years, with as many as 10 of the state's 19 congressional districts hosting seriously contested races -- more, by most analysts' reckoning, than in any other state.

The GOP competition reflects the sense within that party that it's going to be a Republican year. Charlie Gerow, of Quantum Communications, a Harrisburg Republican consultant, said the multicandidate field reflects that sense of possibility, along with a cultural shift within a state party whose disciplined, hierarchical traditions are eroding.

"A lot of people who might have been dissuaded [from running] are no longer getting out of the race," he said.

While there are more GOP contests across the state, the May 18 picture also includes two serious Democratic primary contests in the East. One involves Rep. Paul E. Kanjorski, 11th District, the state's longest-serving congressman. Both parties have competitive primaries in the Murtha district, although those nominations have been overshadowed by the concurrent special election for the seat's unexpired term which runs until the end of the year.

In Bucks County's 8th District, four Republicans are vying to take on Rep. Patrick Murphy, the Army veteran who, while a member of the relatively moderate Blue Dog Coalition of congressional Democrats, was also one of only two House members who endorsed President Obama in the 2008 primary.

Advertise with us

The leading GOP candidate is Michael Fitzpatrick, who held the seat until Mr. Murphy defeated him amid the big Democratic House gains of 2006. Mr. Fitzpatrick has had to contend with opposition of some tea party adherents. Tea party veteran Gloria Carlineo is the best funded and probably most prominent of his GOP competitors.

In Northeast Pennsylvania's 10th District held by Rep. Chris Carney, another member of the Democrats' class of 2006, three Republicans are vying to advance to the general election ballot.

Thomas Marino, former U.S. attorney for the state's middle district, is one of three former federal prosecutors seeking GOP House nominations across the state. The others are Mary Beth Buchanan, who faces Keith Rothfus in the 4th District; and Patrick Meehan, who is unopposed for the GOP nomination in the 7th Distinct, the suburban Philadelphia seat opened with Rep. Joe Sestak's run for the U.S. Senate.

While Mr. Marino is the most prominent name in the race, he has been criticized for ties to casino interests. And in contrast to some state GOP races where established political figures are competing with political neophytes, the other contenders here have political track records. Malcolm Derk is a Snyder County commissioner and David Madeira is a former state Senate candidate.

"You have two credible candidates running against Marino, who has some issues," Mr. Gerow said. "Having said that, [a Marino loss] would be an upset."

Advertise with us

In the adjacent 17th District, a seat now held by Democratic Rep. Tim Holden, state Sen. David Argall, of Schuylkill County, is supported by much of the GOP establishment. But he is opposed by three other GOP hopefuls who have tried to use his Harrisburg background against him -- Francis X. Ryan, a businessman and retired Marine colonel; Allen Griffith, a former Baptist minister and an advocate of term limits; and Joshua First, a Harrisburg businessman.

Two Republican incumbents -- Rep. Charles Dent in the 15th District and Rep. Jim Gerlach, who withdrew from the GOP competition for governor, in the 6th -- face token primary opposition from conservative challengers rooted in the tea party movement. They also are the only two GOP incumbents in the state seriously targeted by a Democratic Party focused on holding on to recent House gains. Bethlehem Mayor John Callahan, unopposed for the Democratic nomination in the 15th, has already raised more than $700,000 for his bid for the Lehigh Valley seat.

In a district that has been trending away from the GOP in national and statewide elections, Mr. Gerlach has long been a Democratic target, but an elusive one. He won his last three elections by margins of 52 percent to 48 percent -- in the face of the Obama landslide -- and 51 percent to 49 percent in each of the two prior contests.

Hoping to reverse those narrow margins this year are two substantial Democratic contenders, Douglas Pike, a former Philadelphia Inquirer editorial writer, and Manan Trivedi, a physician and Iraq war veteran. Mr. Pike, a prodigious fund-raiser, was the early favorite for the Democratic nomination, but Mr. Trivedi has won attention and high-profile party endorsements with a compelling biography as the son of struggling Indian immigrants.

"Pike, early on, got all the endorsements ... then Trivedi came along, and people looked at him and said he's pretty impressive," said Larry Ceisler, a Philadelphia-based consultant. "[But] Pike has a huge financial advantage and he hasn't gone on TV yet."

Advertise with us

The other most noteworthy Democratic primary is in Northeastern Pennsylvania's 11th District, where Mr. Kanjorski -- dean of the state's delegation since Mr. Murtha's death -- faces an energetic challenge from Lackawanna County Commissioner Corey O'Brien and Brian Kelly, whose positions echo the agenda of the tea party movement.

Mr. Kelly is not regarded as a significant factor in the race. Mr. O'Brien has waged an aggressive campaign, contending that Mr. Kanjorski would be unelectable in November against a repeat challenge from former Hazelton Mayor Lou Barletta, the anti-immigrant crusader who narrowly lost to him in 2008.

There has been no public polling in the race, but Christopher Borick, a Muhlenberg College political scientist and pollster, said it was "maybe the only one with an incumbent where there seems to be a truly competitive environment."

"Paul Kanjorski is an institution in the 11th, about as known an entity as can be, [but] over the last few election cycles, a lot of chinks in his armor have come to life -- ethical issues, the way he's managed his office," Mr. Borick said.

Mr. Kanjorski also could be vulnerable to a national anti-incumbent environment that's been exacerbated by a wave of local prosecutions and scandals involving judges and political figures at the state and local levels, the analyst said.