In the face of sharp criticism from his Democratic challenger, U.S. Sen. Arlen Specter on Saturday denied that he promised unquestioned support for Bush administration Supreme Court picks in exchange for former Sen. Rick Santorum's support for his 2004 re-election.

Mr. Santorum described such a quid pro quo in a weekend appearance before Republican conservative activists in New Orleans. Mr. Santorum's support, along with that of the Bush White House, was crucial to Mr. Specter's ability to survive a Republican primary challenge from Pat Toomey six years ago.

As he explores a bid for the GOP presidential nomination in 2012, Mr. Santorum has issued repeated mea culpas for his energetic support of his former Pennsylvania colleague. During an appearance Saturday at the Southern Republican Leadership Conference, he again was challenged by conservative activists over his 2004 campaign role.

According to an account of the exchange on the Washington Post's website, Mr. Santorum told a questioner, "The reason I endorsed Arlen Specter is because we were going to have two Supreme Court nominees coming up. I got a commitment from Arlen Specter that no matter who George W. Bush would nominate, he would support that nominee."

Advertise with us

The report prompted an immediate attack on Mr. Specter from his primary challenger, U.S. Rep. Joe Sestak, along with a firm denial from the incumbent.

"I never made any promise to Sen. Santorum about this. I would never make a promise on a vote like this under any circumstances," Mr. Specter said in a statement issued by his campaign.

That followed a statement from Mr. Sestak calling Mr. Santorum's account "stunning confirmation that Arlen Specter sold his influence as chairman of the Judiciary Committee for a political endorsement.''

"There are few people in this nation who have a greater impact on the lives of the American people than the men and women who serve lifetime appointments on the Supreme Court," Mr. Sestak said. "For Arlen Specter to take his marching orders from Rick Santorum and George W. Bush and pledge to support any nominee -- no matter how partisan, no matter how unqualified -- in order to win an election is a stunning betrayal of his duty as a public servant."

In the past, Mr. Santorum has described his 2004 support for his then Republican colleague as a tactical calculation to protect the Republicans' Senate majority.

Advertise with us

"We had a game plan," Mr. Santorum said in a 2004 interview with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. "And part of that was not to create an open [Senate] seat in Pennsylvania." Some people in Pennsylvania may not like that and I understand that.

"You can argue with my tactics, and trust me, people do, but you can't argue with the results," he added. That interview took place after Mr. Specter was forced to campaign furiously within the GOP caucus to retain his chairmanship of the Judiciary Committee. He had drawn conservative ire in a post-election interview with the observation that any high court nominee who did not support Roe v. Wade would have a tough time being confirmed.

Many conservatives interpreted it as a slap at the White House that had helped him retain his seat. Mr. Specter acknowledged then that he had promised his Republican colleagues speedy and fair hearings for any of Mr. Bush's Supreme Court choices. He went on to preside over confirmation hearings for Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito.

After Mr. Specter issued his denial, a spokeswoman for Mr. Santorum said he stood by his remarks that Mr Specter made a commitment to support the Supreme Court nominees.

"And there was no better illustration of that commitment than Senator Specter's ardent defense of both Justices Alito and Roberts during their confirmation hearings," said Virginia Davis, a Santorum spokeswoman.

Mr. Santorum's remarks Saturday apparently did not stir much enthusiasm among the Republican gathering in New Orleans. In a straw poll of the activists' 2012 presidential choice, he came in last among nine contenders, with the support of just 2 percent of the crowd.