The same day a judge ruled that a search warrant served on the city of Pittsburgh last month will remain sealed, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. — whose investigators served the warrant — indicated the inquiry is related at least in part to money previously earmarked for youth violence programming.

Mr. Zappala discussed the search warrant, which will remain sealed per Common Pleas Judge Jill Rangos’ orders hours earlier, at an unrelated media event Wednesday in West Mifflin.

“When Mayor [Corey] O’Connor started looking at his budget … he found several other sources that the accounting just does not make sense,” Mr. Zappala said when asked about the scope of the search warrant, a reference to the budget passed late last year by the Gainey administration. “A lot of the funding that we’re concerned about was identified for youth, at risk, in minority communities. That money wasn’t being spent on any youth.

“And you’re talking about a lot of my [COVID-19 relief money],” he continued. “All the COVID money that was spent — we’re taking a look at every dime of that, and it’s a great deal of money.”

Advertise with us

Asked if he was drawing a connection between the budget concerns and the money earmarked for at-risk youth, Mr. Zappala said he was.

“You come in and you tell the public, ‘I need x number of dollars to run this type of programming in this at-risk community,’ who’s going to argue with that? Especially if it’s for children?” he said. “That’s not how the money has been used.”

The district attorney declined to say whether he was speaking specifically about the Stop the Violence Fund, which has come under scrutiny for a perceived lack of oversight amid rapid expansion into a multimillion-dollar budget line item that funds anti-violence initiatives geared toward young people.

The result was a change regarding how community groups and nonprofits are chosen to receive funds and how those funds are tracked once they’re distributed.

The fund was cut from $10 million annually to $5 million last year amid budget constraints. That cut remained when Mr. O’Connor reopened the 2026 city budget earlier this month to reconcile what was passed by the Gainey administration with what his administration said is the dire reality.

Advertise with us

Mr. Zappala otherwise remained coy as to where the investigation might go next.

He declined to say whether a parallel federal investigation is playing out but said: “I know we have some agents that we’re working with.”

Asked if any evidence would be presented to a grand jury, Mr. Zappala said he’s “assuming there was a grand jury already impaneled,” but then noted, “I can’t speak to that.”

‘An initial step’

Mr. Zappala said the decision to seal the search warrant stemmed from concerns about revealing too much about the investigation, the safety of witnesses, and the reputations of those targeted by the affidavit’s allegations.

They were the same reasons laid out hours earlier in Judge Rangos’ courtroom by Assistant District Attorney Jon Pittman, who argued successfully for the records to remain sealed: protecting the investigation, protecting witnesses, and protecting the reputations of individuals who are at the center of the supporting affidavit’s allegations —  some of whom Mr. Pittman described as “public figures.”

Advertise with us

“While further investigation may ultimately lead to information becoming public … at this stage of the investigation, it would be premature to make that information public,” the judge said.

Mr. Pittman told the judge that not everything has been turned over to investigators yet.

“I’m not saying the city is not complying,” he said. “The Commonwealth asked for a lot of documents, so we do not have all the documents yet.”

First Amendment attorney Adam Tragone, representing Post-Gazette journalist Michael Wereschagin as an intervenor seeking to get the records in the case unsealed, said the news media and the public “have a presumptive right of access to court and judicial documents, which includes search warrants and probable cause affidavits.”

He said the burden was on the commonwealth — in this case, Mr. Pittman — to prove that sealing the search warrant was so necessary that it outweighed public access. Allowing public access, he said, “discourages perjury, is a check on the issuing authorities, and it also encourages sufficient probable cause [exists before filing].”

Advertise with us

Mr. Pittman said that disseminating the contents of the search warrant could jeopardize the entirety of the investigation.

“This search warrant could be the first step in a very lengthy investigation depending on what the city of Pittsburgh produces to the District Attorney’s Office,” he said. “If this case goes forward, this is probably the first step in a very lengthy investigation.”

If witnesses or investigative targets know what the DA’s office is looking for, he said, that could jeopardize evidence — either through “the destroying of evidence and possibly even the creation of evidence.”

Mr. Pittman said the witnesses who are cooperating in the DA’s inquiry have “expressed actual fear of retaliation,” and, while they know that their identities will be made public if the case moves forward, they requested “that we do everything we can to protect their identity so that they do not face any kind of retribution for their cooperation in this investigation.”

It’s not clear who those witnesses could be, including whether they are current or former city employees or politicians.

Advertise with us

In the same vein, it’s not clear against whom the search warrant’s allegations are being made. Mr. Pittman described some of those individuals as “public figures,” noting that the allegations in the affidavit supporting the search warrant could be “salacious or damaging to certain individuals’ reputations.”

He said if the allegations turn out to be untrue or can’t be proven, “that damage is already done.”

Judge Rangos, who signed off on the search warrant and on sealing the records, agreed with Mr. Pittman that the risk was too high, pointing specifically to the fears of witnesses and the potential harm to reputations should the case not move forward. She noted that it was clear from the “lengthy” affidavit supporting the search warrant that this is “an initial step.”

Mr. Tragone argued that Mr. Pittman’s assertions weren’t specific enough to warrant sealing the records, and he plans to appeal the decision to the Superior Court.

Pushing for info

This is not the first time the DA’s office has sought information from the city — or felt the need to compel it to turn it over.

Advertise with us

In August 2023, Mr. Zappala submitted a right-to-know request for records involving the city and the Matrix Consulting Group — the consulting firm that conducted the city’s police staffing study. The city chose the consulting group without going through the normal contract bidding process.

The request asked for all contracts between the two entities dating back to Jan. 1, 2019, as well as all records to Matrix’s consulting on police-litigation matters in the city.

“A number of concerns have been brought to my attention from public and private officials pertaining to the city’s public safety,” Mr. Zappala said at the time. “Our office intends to thoroughly look into this to the best of our abilities.”

The DA’s request came a week after City Council members moved to launch their own investigation.

Council gave final approval to the contract with Matrix in June 2022. But Matrix’s report stated that “the project began in March 2022.” Legislation approving the contract did not appear on council’s agenda until June 7.

Advertise with us

A so-called waiver of competitive process, which eliminates a requirement for other contractors to competitively bid on a project, had been filed. It said Matrix was the “only known company” to do this type of work and that Matrix already was a consultant for the city on “police-related litigation.”

But in the contract, which ultimately was signed on July 12, 2022, the consulting group said it had not provided services to the city in the past three years.

A year later, Mr. Zappala’s office served the city with a search warrant for records related to alleged misuse of a city credit card. The affidavit in support of the search warrant claimed the city initially denied the DA’s office access to certain documents from the Office of Municipal Investigations — the city office that handles internal investigations.

The affidavit said OMI officials informed the DA’s office it would have to seek permission from the city solicitor. The search warrant noted in its probable cause section that “it is not standard procedure for OMI to require the solicitor to sign off on” turning over an investigative file. It also noted that the city solicitor at the time, Krysia Kubiak, told investigators from the DA’s office that she wouldn’t turn over the files unless presented with a subpoena or search warrant.

The probe stemmed from thousands of dollars in payments doled out to Mario Ashkar, a then-contractor working with the city’s farmers markets, which are part of the Parks and Recreation Department. City Controller Rachael Heisler and some council members had raised concerns regarding the payments, which were made using city credit cards, known as p-cards.

The city’s internal investigation found that no city policies were violated, although “honest mistakes” were made. No criminal charges were ever filed in connection with the DA’s investigation.