With millions of dollars in private gifts headed toward Pittsburgh for new emergency vehicles and snow removal equipment, the local Republican committee is calling for greater transparency in how the money is spent.
Last month, UPMC pledged $10 million to help the city buy new ambulances. The money will be split evenly over two years. The PNC Foundation quickly followed with its own gift of $2 million for snow removal equipment.
For years, Pittsburgh’s fleet of vehicles has been languishing: Ambulances are breaking down with patients in the back, and the near-foot of snow that fell on the city in January laid bare the problems with the snowplows.
But as the financial contributions arrive as Pittsburgh faces scrutiny over its finances after City Council approved a 20% property tax increase, some are arguing that the city must clearly document how the funds are used.
“The size of this gift — and the current state of the city’s finances — demands clear guardrails, transparency and accountability from the moment these funds are received through their final use,” Todd McCollum, chairman of the City of Pittsburgh Republican Committee, wrote in a letter sent to the city controller’s office. “The reality is that Pittsburgh’s finances are widely understood to be in disarray, and past experience has shown that simply trusting that funds will be used as intended is not sufficient.”
Mr. McCollum asked the controller to create and put together a “clear, itemized ledger” for the funds tracking how and when the money is allocated; which vendors are selected and why; and any remaining balances, delays or reallocation of the money.
Read More
He suggested that the ledger could be set up similarly to the city’s engage pages, where it posts updates about ongoing capital projects, with a timeline for when vendors are chosen, when manufacturing starts and when the city receives the vehicles.
The request wasn’t meant to add “unnecessary bureaucracy” but is focused on “restoring and maintaining public trust,” the letter said.
“Transparency ensures confidence. Accountability ensures results,” Mr. McCollum wrote in his letter. “And when millions of private dollars are entrusted to the city of Pittsburgh for specific purposes, the standard should be nothing less than full public visibility — dollar for dollar.”
When the PNC Foundation announced its gift, City Controller Rachael Heisler said that she would “make sure that these partnerships are accountable to the public and that every contribution benefits the entire community.”
The office plans to do an annual audit of the gifts, independent of the yearly fleet review, according to the controller’s spokesperson.
Mr. McCollum sent his letter to the controller two weeks ago and had still not heard back as of Wednesday afternoon, he said.
A spokesperson for the controller’s office said the office “does not engage with political parties prior to doing our business, and this is no exception."
“I want to be clear: this is a good deal for the city,” Mr. McCollum wrote in the letter. “The ability to acquire critical vehicles and resources without directly increasing the burden on taxpayers is a positive outcome, and the willingness of private institutions to step up in support of public safety and essential services should be welcomed.”
City officials have already convened an emergency meeting of the Equipment Leasing Authority — which handles all purchases and leases of city vehicles — to determine how the funds should be spent. As of Wednesday morning, nothing had been purchased yet, according to City Councilman Anthony Coghill, who is a member of the ELA board.
Whenever purchases are made by the ELA, council will have to approve the contracts so that the authority can access the funds.
The legislation accepting the gifts, approved by council last week, states that the funds should be used for ambulances in the case of the UPMC gift and snow removal equipment for the money from the PNC Foundation.
“Whenever there is anything related to government, there is always concerns for transparency,” said Miracle Jones, the policy and advocacy director with 1Hood Media, a local nonprofit activist group that has previously worked and advocated for greater government transparency laws, particularly around community investment.
She also underscored the fact that for years the city has been attempting to get some form of payment from the city’s largest nonprofit organizations, one of which is UPMC.
“Given the issues connected with UPMC and how there is a policy demand to tax nonprofits, I think people are on a high level of requiring more information about any type of high-dollar donation to the city,” she said.
Mayor Corey O’Connor has described the $10 million as strictly a gift while saying discussions about establishing reoccurring contributions from major nonprofits remain ongoing.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.