Pittsburgh City Council members squabbled over a possible agreement with Munhall to assist in the city’s snow removal efforts during a meeting Wednesday afternoon.
The agreement would provide city street sweeping services for Munhall in exchange for snow and ice removal services in neighborhoods such as Lincoln Place, Hays and New Homestead, which already share some roadways with the nearby municipality. Additionally, the city would be permitted to store salt in Munhall’s salt dome.
The legislation will be up for a final vote next week, though it appears unlikely to pass. During Wednesday’s preliminary vote, only Councilwoman Barb Warwick and Council President Dan Lavelle voted in favor of the agreement.
During the discussion, some council members voiced concern about union support for the agreement.
“You’re taking jobs from city workers and opportunities for them to earn overtime pay,” Councilman Anthony Coghill said of the agreement.
Public Works employees, who manage the snow and ice removal, and street sweeping, are represented by the Teamsters and are not supportive of the agreement, Mr. Coghill said.
“The unions adamantly oppose [the agreement],” he said.
However, Mr. Lavelle, said the agreement wasn’t taking work away from city employees, but giving them additional resources.
Other members said that snow removal was a problem the city had the ability to solve itself, starting with allocating more resources to upgrading the fleet. Previously, city officials have estimated that it would cost about $20 million annually just to upkeep the vehicles, not including replacing outdated ones with newer models.
Mr. Coghill also appeared incredulous at the fact that Pittsburgh was offering street sweeping to other municipalities when he said he gets calls each week from his residents that their streets were not swept.
“How is it that we can offer it to a suburb when we can’t fulfill our own obligation?” He asked during Wednesday’s meeting.
Public Works Director Chris Hornstein explained that both Pittsburgh and Munhall would be allowed to refuse services if resources didn’t allow it. On the city’s side, that would likely mean if the street sweepers were out of service.
Ms. Warwick, who represents those neighborhoods and introduced the legislation this week, said that in her conversations with the employees, it wasn’t a staffing problem but a resource problem.
“The city of Pittsburgh has been failing its workers by not providing the equipment for the workers to do their jobs effectively,” she said. “Showing up to work and not having enough trucks is not fair to our workforce.”
She also introduced legislation this week to authorize the purchase of four new snow plows, though it's unclear if the city will have them in time for this upcoming winter.
Ms. Warwick and Mr. Coghill debated multiple times during Wednesday’s meeting about the legality of the agreement, which Mr. Coghill said violated the city’s collective bargaining agreement with the union.
Ms. Warwick, who said she also spoke to the union, agreed they were not in favor of the contract with Munhall, but said she believed it was still legal. Mr. Hornstein compared it to the agreement the police department has with surrounding municipalities.
Snow removal has been a source of complaints from city residents for years. Mr. Hornstein said that in his study of the county and surrounding municipalities they, on average, commit four times the amount of resources Pittsburgh does to snow and ice removal.
Councilwoman Deb Gross suggested that the legislation be rewritten so that instead of creating an agreement with Munhall, City Council directs the mayor’s office to explore what the agreement would look like — which would include speaking directly with the union representatives to determine if this violated their collective bargaining agreement.
“I think it would help calm the fears [and] the hostile footing if we redid it,” she said. “We need to do a little fact-finding and get information first.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.