Passionate Pittsburgh residents turned out Wednesday afternoon to voice their opposition to a proposal that would convert the old Veterans Affairs hospital in Lincoln-Lemington into a public safety training facility, the latest in a yearslong debate over the site that has been largely abandoned for over a decade.
Dubbed by some residents as Pittsburgh’s version of a so-called “cop city,” many cited concerns that such a campus would facilitate the militarization of police. They’re also concerned about what they say is a high price tag.
Regina Hendley, a public speaker during Wednesday’s meeting, called the plan “an insult to Pittsburghers everywhere” and cited what she said were “deplorable conditions” in some of the city’s public housing.
“If this project is supposed to be about making Pittsburghers safe, it should go to improving our existing public housing and to building new units,” she said.
The city is working to determine a use for the former hospital on Highland Drive, which it acquired in 2021 after years of conversations between former Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration and the federal government.
City Council is deciding whether the city should spend $1.8 million over the next two years to create a master plan for the facility.
Read More
The draft proposal calls for the site to include training classrooms for police, fire and EMS, an evidence warehouse, an indoor firing range and a fire burn tower. It also includes space for the animal control administration and includes salt and winter weather equipment storage area.
Members voted to hold the legislation for two more weeks, delaying the vote again more than seven weeks after rescheduling it for Wednesday.
“No one is for this. Everyone is against this,” Squirrel Hill resident Alexandra Weiner told council during the public comment. “It really should be the easiest decision of your careers.”
A plan for the property must be finalized by the end of June 2026, according to the terms of the agreement. If they can’t come to an agreement, the city would have to return the land to the federal government or pay the full market rate to keep it.
The terms of the current agreement say Pittsburgh can use the facility only for public safety purposes or emergency management-like disaster assistance.
But residents are worried that the facility will turn into something that more closely mimics the controversial public safety training facility in Atlanta, which many have said is being used to militarize the police in the Georgia capital. That facility includes a mock city where police can train.
“The proposal that a facility anything like Atlanta's cop city, where police are militarized and trained in urban warfare, is inhumane,” said Millvale resident Miles Dennan during the public comment period.
Original plans for the East End facility from the Peduto administration also included a mock city, but that was not included in a recent list of possible amenities.
It cost the city of Atlanta about $118 million to build the facility.
Pittsburgh’s five-year financial plan has budgeted $86 million for the facility, but a final price tag wouldn’t be known until the master plan is completed.
The city is staring down significant budget constraints as revenues drop and expenses for things such as overtime pay for the understaffed police and EMS departments rise. Some council members have said the money should go to other, more immediate needs, such as public housing.
Pittsburgh has long planned for the old Veterans Affairs site to be used as a public safety facility, even before Atlanta’s cop city became a flashpoint. Some of the criticism of Atlanta’s facility was mirrored during Wednesday’s public comments in Pittsburgh Wednesday.
Many in Atlanta argued the price point of $118 million was too high and the money could be better spent on other initiatives.
“I think that the city does not have the money to spend, regardless of what this facility is used for,” Ms. Weiner said.
Beyond the $1.8 million price tag for the creation of Pittsburgh’s, it’s also unclear exactly how much the city would spend renovating the buildings, which have sat empty since 2013 when the VA closed the center and moved its operations to other buildings in Oakland and across the Allegheny River in O’Hara.
Some in attendance Wednesday noted they would support using the facility for public safety training, but only if it was primarily for fire and EMS. They also suggested adding spaces for the city’s social workers to operate out of and a place to increase the city’s natural disaster preparedness.
However, there has not been an opportunity for public input beyond the council meetings.
“No vote should happen without a public forum,” said Fawn Walker-Montgomery, the co-founder of Take Action Advocacy Group, a Western Pennsylvania-based activist organization.
Violent crime has largely dropped around the city and across the country, data shows, even as Pittsburgh’s police bureau faces a massive a staffing shortage.
That alone should show the facility is unnecessary, Emily Sawyer said during the public comment period.
“We’ve been training police for decades and haven’t gotten any results,” said Ms. Sawyer, of Manchester. “Why would more of something that isn’t working be a solution? Any investments in public safety should be further investments in violence prevention strategies we know are working.”
Some speakers also raised concerns about the architecture firm named in the city’s legislation.
Henningston Durham and Richardson Inc., which has offices in Pittsburgh and around the world, was sued in 2021 over claims that it was surveilling the social media pages of activists who opposed to the firm’s projects, including a jail in Greene County, Ohio, according to a 2021 Vice report.
The lawsuit was later dismissed after the courts ruled that social media was not protected under the federal Electronic Communications Privacy Act.
HDR said any social media analysis it performs is used to facilitate public engagement and provide transparency for the projects it's working on.
“I'm uncomfortable with my tax dollars going to this firm,” Ms. Hendley said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.