Sitting up on a hill above the often-flooded Washington Boulevard sits the long vacant campus that previously housed a Veterans Affairs hospital. Now owned by the City of Pittsburgh, which has been eyeing the site for a public safety training facility, residents are concerned it could become Pittsburgh’s version of a “cop city.”
The abandoned site on a 170-acre plot of land in Lincoln-Lemington has been a topic of city discussion for years. Talks to acquire the site from the federal government began in 2018 and were finalized in 2021, when the city officially acquired the property.
From the beginning, the city’s plans were to use the vacant property as a public safety training facility. Former Mayor Bill Peduto said it was prime ground to consolidate, streamline and modernize the facilities where the city educates and trains first responders, which are currently scattered across the city.
The term “cop city” is in reference to a nickname given to a public training facility in Atlanta. The Atlanta facility, which cost about $115 million to build, includes a mock city and firing ranges.
“Promise us there will not be a tactical training village where they can practice tear gassing me and my friends,” Eliana Beagle, who said she was present at the 2020 protests in Pittsburgh where police deployed tear gas, said to council members during public comment Wednesday.
Original plans for Pittsburgh’s facility outline similar features, including a mock city, but representatives from Mayor Ed Gainey’s office have indicated that the plans are changing.
Read More
Pittsburgh City Council is currently considering spending $1.8 million on an architecture firm to create a master plan for the facility which will assess the condition of the existing buildings and underground infrastructure, according to Jake Pawlak, the director of the Office of Management and Budget.
“It’s a necessary foundation to any preliminary design work to construct a facility,” he told council members during a meeting two weeks ago. “We wouldn’t be able to advance any project here without this.”
Council members, who held the legislation until September to explore more options, said they would like to see if they can lobby the federal government to change the parameters for the use of the facility.
The price tag alone has some council members balking at the idea.
“Just from a dollars and cents perspective … this just seems entirely unnecessary,” Councilwoman Barb Warwick said. “We have pools that need to be fixed, we have ambulances that we need. I just don’t think that this is a wise use of money right now.”
The city’s five-year plan has $86 million budgeted for the facility, but Mr. Pawlak said last week an accurate price won’t be known until the master plan is completed.
The request for qualifications notes that many of the departments within public safety are scattered throughout the city and “it is the city’s intention to consolidate most of these functions onto one site to create a state-of-the-art training and administrative complex.”
As far back as 2014, the city’s capital budget set aside $100,000 to fund “the design and planning of” a public safety training center. That money was kicked ahead to the 2015 capital budget.
A string of council votes in 2022 rerouted more than $1.4 million set aside in the previous administration’s budgets toward resurfacing and other roadway projects. Officials said at the time that those projects were “shovel-ready,” whereas the training facility was nowhere near ready for work to begin.
Not consolidating the operations also comes with a cost though.
Police, fire, EMS, the Office of Emergency Management and Homeland Security, animal control, community services and violence prevention, and the Office of Community Health and Safety all fall under the umbrella that is the city’s Department of Public Safety. Offices for most are scattered throughout the city: Public safety’s administrative offices are in the City-County Building in Downtown, police headquarters are on the North Side, the Bureau of Fire is headquartered in the Strip District, and the main officers for EMS are in Shadyside.
The city owns the buildings in Shadyside and the Strip District but pays about $1.3 million a year to lease the police headquarters building on Western Avenue — about $27 million over the past 20 years. City council begrudgingly signed off on another six-year lease in late 2023.
Councilwoman Deb Gross said Wednesday that she and her staff have been monitoring similar training facilities across the country and has spoken with a public defender in Atlanta.
She wants to explore other options to the training facility, or include caveats to the master plan for things like, ensuring de-escalation tactics are taught or allowing social workers to be part of the training.
Ms. Gross also said that beyond the concerns with the facility itself and the price tag, she didn’t want the city contracting with the architecture firm, Henningson Durham & Richardson of Pennsylvania Architects & Engineers P.C., which has offices across the globe, including in Pittsburgh.
She said the company has “developed their own division for counter intelligence and surveillance,” and has deployed those in certain situations where people have been protesting their developments.
“I don’t think we should do business with that kind of company and I’ve written a letter to the mayor already saying that,” Ms. Gross said.
Council members stressed a need to look into the plans further.
“I think in many ways we need to go back to the drawing board and look at what options we have for the use of the land,” Councilman Khari Mosley said.
But the city is under a time crunch.
If the plan isn’t completed by next June, the city could lose the property, according to the agreement signed with the federal government when the city acquired the land. That agreement also stipulated that the site must be used for public safety purposes.
Losing the ownership of the facility, Mr. Pawlak said, could mean the federal government seizes it for a detention facility for use by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Ms. Warwick said she felt like that claim was “vague” and an “excuse.”
“The federal government is figuring out quickly how to set up those facilities without us using this as an excuse for moving forward with a training facility,” she said.
Megan Guza contributed to this report.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.