As the city of Pittsburgh struggles to find funding to update the vehicle fleet, newly imposed tariffs by President Donald Trump are likely to exacerbate the problem, although just how much of an impact is yet to be seen.
The city manages about 650 vehicles from police cruises to ambulances, firetrucks and garbage trucks and nearly half of them are beyond the recommended lifecycle.
For years those closest to the problem have been describing the status of the fleet as in “dire condition.” Near constant breakdowns have led to delays in trash pickup and even ambulances breaking down on their way to the hospital.
It will cost the city – which is already facing significant budget constraints – millions of dollars to even put a dent in the city’s vehicle needs and the price tag is only likely to go up with new tariffs imposed by President Donald Trump that will impact foreign-made vehicles and parts for domestic-made ones as well.
“We’re starting to see a ramp up of prices, but it hasn’t completely hit yet,” said Brendan Duke, a senior director for federal fiscal policy at the D.C.-based Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
In early August, Trump imposed another round of import taxes on dozens of countries including 15% tariffs on Japan and South Korea, where a significant portion of the U.S.’s automobile parts come from. This comes on top of widespread tariffs imposed earlier this year that have already started raising the prices of some goods.
In just the last six months, prices for fire trucks have gone up about $100,000, according to Firmin Maurice, the city’s fleet manager. In the first week of August, the city received its first tariff-related price increase on fleet equipment, to the tune of an additional $7,000 per unit, Mr. Maurice told Equipment Leasing Authority Board members during their meeting this month. The authority handles all fleet purchases and leases.
Mr. Maurice said he was fearful of what next year might bring in terms of pricing for new vehicles, which the city desperately needs.
“Everything is going to cost more,” City Council Budget Director and ELA Board member Pete McDevitt said during the board’s latest meeting. “We just don’t know how much.”
Mr. Duke agreed that prices are likely to continue to rise, there’s just no telling how far right now.
At the end of July, a federal appeals court heard arguments challenging Trump’s legal basis for his tariffs and a decision is anticipated to be released by the end of September. Though Trump has warned the results could be "catastrophic" if the courts overrule the tariffs, it could lead to price stabilization in some sectors.
“Hopefully the political climate changes,” Mr. Maurice said.
A 15% tariff could lead to increases in the tens of thousands of dollars for vehicles like ambulances and firetrucks that cost upwards of $400,000. Pittsburgh needs more than just one vehicle.
The ELA is in the process of creating a priority list for which vehicles should be replaced first, based on age and mileage as well as other considerations like how long it takes to receive a vehicle. For firetrucks, the turnaround time is three years – meaning the ELA has to think about what condition the trucks will be in by 2028, when new ones would arrive if purchased soon.
The goal is to have at least 80% of the fleet operating within the lifecycle of the vehicles. That would be about 370 new units purchased costing about $138 million, according to projections from the ELA board.
That would just stop the decline of the fleet. To fully replace every vehicle it would cost more than $200 million – money the city doesn’t have.
In 2022 when the Fern Hollow Bridge collapsed, it cost about $25 million to repair the bridge, most of which came from the federal government. It would be the equivalent of nearly five Fern Hollow Bridge rebuilds, with little to no help from state or federal governments to fix the fleet.
In the past, a number of vehicles have been purchased with state grant money but most commonly the city is on the hook for fully funding the purchases.
To reach the 80% goal, the city would have to allocate about $2.5 million next year and purchase at least 5 new vehicles. Those numbers continually increase over the next five years, until it reaches $54 million in 2030 and purchasing 155 new vehicles that year, according to ELA projections.
Those projections, however, do not currently factor in future tariff-related price hikes.
The gamble to take with tariff increases is either buy now, while before the price catches up with the most recent round of tariffs or wait out the court decision which could reverse the price hikes. Pittsburgh, though, doesn’t have the luxury of time.
“The longer we wait, the more expensive this gets and the less reliable our fleet becomes,” Mr. Maurice said.
In 2025, the city budgeted just $6 million to purchase new vehicles and five year projections show that number decreasing over time.
“That’s going to become very expensive for the city,” said Terrence Guay who teaches international business at Penn State University.
And the question becomes, he said, where does that money come from?
For most cities, the easiest way to increase revenue is to raise taxes, but "that's not going to be a very popular sell, even if it’s for a very in-demand need like this,” Mr. Guay said.
As Pittsburgh nears its budget season, there have been no public discussions at this point about raising taxes to help bolster the city’s revenue, which has already seen a decrease due in part to lowered property tax rates.
The first draft of the 2026 budget must be released by the end of September and has to be approved by City Council by the end of December.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.