Pittsburgh officials and immigration advocates were unsurprised to hear that the city and Allegheny County appeared on a list of “sanctuary jurisdictions” the Department of Homeland Security is putting on notice, but still fear for the immigrant population living here.
Pittsburgh and Allegheny County have both appeared on a list the Department of Homeland Security released Thursday outlining municipalities that the federal government believes are “deliberately and shamefully obstructing the enforcement of federal immigration laws.” These places could lose federal funding for violating immigration law.
The department said every jurisdiction on the list will receive “formal notification of its non-compliance” and be asked to review and revise their policies to align with federal immigration laws.
Monica Ruiz, the executive director of Casa San Jose, a local nonprofit dedicated to helping immigrants in the region said she wasn’t shocked to see this pressure tactic come from the Trump administration.
“Instead of doing the things that the federal government should be doing right now, like focusing on people that need services and help, they’re focusing on things that are not benefitting people at large,” she said. “They’re focusing on targeting innocent people that are in this country trying to live good lives.”
The list is latest in President Donald Trump’s efforts to make good on his campaign promises of deporting millions of people who are in the country undocumented.
Read More
Neither Pittsburgh nor Allegheny County have ever been formally designated as sanctuary areas, but elected officials for both have been very open about welcoming immigrant populations.
Both former Mayor Bill Peduto and current Mayor Ed Gainey, both Democrats, have strongly supported the city’s immigrant population and have said that Pittsburgh will welcome them.
Despite the lack of a formal designation by the mayor or city council, Pittsburgh has appeared on multiple lists of sanctuary cities including from the Center for Immigration Studies and now, the Department of Homeland Security.
Multiple times since Trump’s inauguration, Mr. Gainey said his administration would not cooperate with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
“I am not going to be working with ICE. My administration will not work with ICE,” said Mr. Gainey, speaking in a downtown Harrisburg hotel to the Pennsylvania Press Club in late January. “We will do whatever is necessary to make our city more welcoming.”
Mr. Gainey’s office did not respond Friday when asked about the list.
Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, a Democrat who is likely to be the city’s next mayor, has also said he won’t support “policies that separate families, rip communities apart and target honest, hardworking people.”
Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato has also emphasized that the county welcomes all people and in February, promised funds to support local refugee resettlement agencies after federal funding was cut off.
County Manager John Fournier said Friday afternoon that the county hasn’t received any formal communication from the federal government regarding policies “they would like us to revise.”
He said the county won’t have any further comment until they can evaluate the federal government’s recommendations.
Ms. Ruiz said there weren’t any formal policies at the city or county level she was aware of that the Trump administration could want revised.
In 2019, about 27,100 city residents were immigrants, about 4,100 of which were undocumented, according to data collected from the American Immigration Council. Across the state, there were about 153,000 undocumented immigrants in 2019, according to the Migration Policy Institute. The state has a population of about 13 million people.
“[Trump] doesn’t even know what he’s talking about,” Ms. Ruiz said. “This is ridiculous. I’m a social worker, I’m not an attorney, I’m not a government official and it seems like I know more about the laws than the people that are trying to enforce them.”
At this point, no further action has been threatened by the federal government for what it has deemed as noncompliance, but an April executive order signed by Trump that mandated the creation of this list, said federal funding to these sanctuary jurisdictions could be suspended or terminated.
A coalition of elected officials from across the country and a nonprofit called Public Rights Project called the list a fear tactic designed to bully local governments into cooperating with ICE in a statement shared with the Associated Press.
“Sanctuary policies are legal and make us all safer,” the statement said.
While the state is not listed as a sanctuary jurisdiction as a whole, in addition to Allegheny County and Pittsburgh there are 10 other Pennsylvania counties and four other Pennsylvania cities on the list. In total 36 states appear on the list.
“As Governor Shapiro has made clear, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is not a sanctuary state,” Gov. Josh Shapiro’s spokesperson Manuel Bonder said. “We continue to follow all state and federal laws, comply with court orders and coordinate with law enforcement partners at all levels when appropriate in order to keep our communities safe.”
For the first time in three years, Allegheny County has seen a slight uptick in population, largely due to more than 10,00 immigrants who have moved to the area, according to recent census data.
In Pittsburgh, Beechview is one of the neighborhoods that has seen a significant influx of immigrants.
“They brought life back to this town,” said Councilman Anthony Coghill, who represents the neighborhoods. “I appreciate and have a lot of faith in the immigrant population in Beechview. Their documentation status doesn’t matter to me.”
Mr. Coghill said when he heard about the list, he immediately thought about Beechview.
“There are good people that live here,” he said. “They’re hard workers, and they’re family oriented.”
Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith, who also has a significant immigrant population in her district, said that she knows some of her residents, despite being law abiding citizens, are worried about being deported.
“We need to be mindful that there are people that are really good people, being affected by this,” she said.
She said she would like to get a group of elected officials together from the local, state and federal level to work on a more expedited process for citizenship.
“As long as they’re obeying the rest of our laws, if the only illegal thing they’ve done is come here and they want to be in the United States... we could work through that,” she said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.