County Council approved a $600 million economic development plan Tuesday that aims to revitalize an industrial site in Pittsburgh’s North Side, a project recently OK’d by Pittsburgh’s school board.
The Transit Revitalization Investment District, or TRID, is a funding mechanism to support almost $54 million in infrastructure upgrades for the $600 million Esplanade development in Manchester. Council voted 14-0 for the project, after its economic development committee reviewed the proposal last month.
Typically, there are 15 members, but Councilman David Bonaroti recently resigned from council, leaving one seat temporarily vacant until council appoints a replacement.
Some Manchester residents have opposed the multi-phase proposal for there and Chateau, saying it would gentrify their neighborhood. All told, the redevelopment plan for the site — just west of the West End Bridge — includes a Ferris wheel, a 408-unit apartment tower up to 19 stories high with as many as 308 parking spots, retail space and a food emporium.
Other components include a marina, 17 homes similar to houseboats that would be built on barge-like bases, retail and a 651-space parking garage.
A few council members spoke in support of the agreement Tuesday. They said that although there were concerns from some residents, the economic benefits of the development, combined with increased tax revenue, infrastructure improvements, the new housing and revitalization of the riverfront, were a net positive for the community.
Read More
It was in some ways a difficult decision for Councilwoman Bethany Hallam because of her family’s roots and her residence in the area, and for Councilman DeWitt Walton, who said he has been in many rooms citywide where development is fiercely debated. But they and others agreed the project helped the community more than it harmed it.
Councilman Jack Betkowski, who chairs council’s economic development committee, said he has worked with many developers during his time as an elected official, dating back to his time as a commissioner in Ross. But Piatt Companies, the company leading the Esplanade development, stands out, he said.
“The Piatt group has been the most honorable, professional, straightforward [and] just an incredible group to work with,” Mr. Betkowski said.
But those who spoke Tuesday night were divided — mainly along two groups: the Manchester Citizens Corporation, in support, and Manchester Neighbors, which was against. Many who spoke Tuesday had appeared at Pittsburgh's school board meetings on the matter.
That board voted 5-1 last week to approve it, with school board Director Dwayne Barker — who represents Manchester — voting against. Fellow school board Director Sala Udin abstained.
Those who oppose the project fear it will displace longtime residents, and won’t be the economic and housing boom its supporters tout. Others said the developer has not held community meetings with them, and Manchester Neighbors said it had petitions from more than 300 people with concerns.
One person against, Dan Holland, is a local historian and professor who has studied the Manchester area since 1991. He said it’s not the first time a large project has been touted for the area, noting a development project from the 1950s where hundreds of families were displaced.
“I just want to know — is history repeating itself here?” said Mr. Holland, who is a fellow for Carnegie Mellon University’s Center for African American Urban Studies & the Economy. “So I think you have a great opportunity to make a better decision here, to move forward with more caution and care.”
But some union workers at a recent public hearing and Tuesday said the project was key to bringing jobs and critical training to the area. And some residents agreed.
Reggie Smith, a 20-year resident of Manchester, was brief in his support as public comment wrapped up Tuesday.
“I’ve been at these [community] meetings … Piatt has conducted itself with class, and explained the program they’re going to put out,” Mr. Smith said. “This project is going to be a boon for the Manchester and Chateau area.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.