Community organizers and staff from Mayor Ed Gainey’s re-election campaign, along with a number of other elected officials, gathered Monday afternoon to condemn a mailer issued in support of Mr. Gainey’s opponent, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor, that circulated late last week. 

On one side, the mailer showed a photo of a dilapidated building with the words “The Ed Gainey Legacy. Wasting millions. Rewarding cronies. Hurting neighborhoods” underneath. The other side detailed allegations that the mayor had irresponsibly increased his staff size and used public money to pay for consultants, among other things.

Sent to voters in the city, the mailer appeared to tap into previous City Hall controversies and it set off accusations that supporters of Mr. O’Connor had crossed a line.

The mailer was paid for by the Common Sense Change Action PAC, an organization that is not directly affiliated with Mr. O’Connor’s campaign but has sent out multiple mailers in support of his candidacy. The political action committee, created earlier this year, has raised $264,500 — primarily from donations from local labor organizations and from politicians who have endorsed Mr. O’Connor.

Advertise with us

The two Democrats will face off in a primary for the mayoral race on May 20.

The first-term mayor’s supporters took to social media over the weekend to voice their displeasure and met Monday afternoon outside the City-County Building, calling the mailer racist, “anti-DEI” and said it echoed divisive rhetoric used by President Donald Trump. 

“Hateful rhetoric in any form is unacceptable,” Mr. O’Connor said in a statement released by his campaign Monday evening. “It has no place in this race and will have no place in Corey O’Connor’s administration if elected.” The statement did not directly address the mailer.

“The O’Connor campaign is committed to tackling the very real issues facing Pittsburgh — looming bankruptcy, overwhelming public safety departments and a lack of affordable housing,” the statement said. “This is the discussion that Pittsburghers deserve.”

Mr. O’Connor’s campaign did not respond to questions from the Post-Gazette. 

Advertise with us

Many of the speakers Monday repeatedly called on Mr. O’Connor to denounce the mailer.

“Corey O’Connor, his campaign and the organizations supporting him have been engaged in a long-term campaign of racialized and anti-Black attacks on Pittsburgh’s first Black mayor,” Brandi Fisher, the president and CEO of the Alliance for Police Accountability.

“This mailer is a clear demonstration of these tactics, which are unacceptable in our city, especially now given the attacks on diversity, equity and inclusion coming out of Washington, D.C.”

They argued that the mailer contained inaccuracies. For example, Ms. Fisher and other speakers said the building featured on the front of the mailer, which is in Uptown, was a photo from about 2018. Mr. Gainey wasn’t in office. The building has since been renovated and currently has tenants living in both rental units.

Multiple speakers also said the mailer was particularly harmful to Black women because of the insinuation it makes about a “sweetheart contract” to Fantasy Zellars, the business partner of Mr. Gainey’s wife, Michelle. Ms. Zellars, the founder of Bounce Marketing and Consulting, worked with Ms. Gainey on an art curation project last year and organized Mr. Gainey’s inauguration and gala in 2022.

Advertise with us

Ms. Zellars last year won a contract to run a city-sponsored Juneteenth celebration. The contract, which was awarded via an open request for proposals, drew criticism from William B. Marshall, who had been organizing a similar event for over a decade. City officials ended up approving funding for both events. 

The mailer also was critical of Mr. Gainey’s spending, particularly around $6 million allocated to consultants and public engagement. The money was allocated in February 2024 to create a comprehensive plan intended to guide long-term planning in the city. At the time, City Council members balked at the price tag.

Speakers Monday didn’t address spending on the plan, but they pushed back on the claim that the mayor had added staffing that increased costs $5 million. Part of that increase came from merging the 311 information line and neighborhood services employees into the mayor’s office, the speakers argued.

However, Mr. Gainey added new positions to his office, including at least five new communications positions.

Mr. Gainey and Mr. O’Connor faced off in a heated debate last week, hosted by WPXI TV and political observers are expecting the intensity of the race to continue to escalate over the next month. Another debate is scheduled for Tuesday evening.