Pittsburgh City Councilman Bob Charland wants Gov. Josh Shapiro to issue a disaster emergency declaration over the state of litter and illegal dumping in the city, but it’s a move that Mayor Ed Gainey called “political grandstanding” and other council members thought was too drastic.  

Mr. Charland held a news conference along an alleyway in Knoxville Tuesday morning, using the trash that lined the street as an example of the need for action. 

During an appearance on a KDKA morning radio show Tuesday morning, Mr. Gainey claimed that Mr. Charland’s focus on littering was “a diversion” to distract from the mayoral race.

Mr. Gainey is facing a tough opponent in Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor for the Democratic primary next month.  During his time on council, Mr. Charland has been a vocal critic of Mr. Gainey and has campaigned for Mr. O’Connor, including donating to his campaign.

Advertise with us

Declaring a state of emergency for Pittsburgh is a rarity and has only happened a handful of times in recent years. One was declared in 2010 for “snowmageddon” when the city saw nearly 2 feet of snow over a two-day period. There were other ones because of the COVID-19 pandemic hit, the Fern Hollow Bridge collapse and the Second Avenue Commons shelter fire last year.

Mr. Gainey swiftly pushed back on Mr. Charland’s request. 

“Governor Shapiro has been a great partner,’ Mr. Gainey said during an impromptu news conference later in the day Tuesday. “For him as a governor to deal with a garbage situation that we’re already addressing really doesn’t make any sense at all … I can guarantee you that the governor got more important issues.” 

A request for comment from Mr. Shapiro’s office was not immediately returned. 

Mr. Charland submitted a will of council during Tuesday morning’s council meeting, that would have served as the official request to the governor. Multiple other members of council asked that their names be removed – not because they disagree with the spirit of the bill, but because they feel there are more pressing issues to ask the state for assistance with. 

Advertise with us

“We really should be asking our governor and our state delegation, at this moment in time, to stay laser focused on the funding crisis that we are facing that could result in the complete dissemination of our public health systems,” Councilwoman Barb Warwick said. 

Councilman Khari Mosley also said that if the city were to make a request to Mr. Shapiro, it should be for funding for Pittsburgh Regional Transit, which is considering significant cuts to its routes as it faces a growing budget deficit. 

Mr. Mosley, along with Ms. Warwick and Deb Gross asked that their names be removed as sponsors from the will of council. The three have all been staunch supporters of the mayor’s re-election campaign.

After a recommendation from City Council President Dan Lavelle, who said he supported the spirit of the bill, Mr. Charland agreed to remove the verbiage asking the governor to enact a state of emergency. 

The new will of council reads in part: 

Advertise with us

“The Council of the City of Pittsburgh calls on the Governor to render essential the Commonwealth's supplementation of municipal resources to remove trash debris from publicly- and privately-owned land and to restore public health in our most livable city.”

Despite the change, Mr. Charland maintained that the situation warranted a state of emergency.

During the appearance on a KDKA morning radio show Tuesday morning, Mr. Gainey said that he hasn’t had any conversations with Mr. Charland regarding litter.

“I’m not sure what Councilman Charland is doing, but I do understand the difference between concern and grandstanding,” Mr. Gainey said on the radio show. 

Mr. Charland pushed back on that and said he has talked with the mayor about littering. When being sworn-in to office Mr. Charland claimed that the city was “filthy” and has made it his mission to help clean it up. Mr. Charland declined to comment on Mr. Gainey’s “political grandstanding” comment.

Advertise with us

The city, as part of the 2025 budget, added eight more anti-litter inspectors and allocated $456,000 to a litter cleanup program that is scheduled to start this weekend in Homewood. 

Despite council’s approval of the program, during Mr. Charland’s news conference Tuesday morning, he said he was not familiar with the cleanup efforts. 

Mr. Gainey later on Tuesday claimed that there is less trash in the city now than before he took office in 2022. 

Last year, the city assisted with more than 337 volunteer cleanup events, Chris Hornstein, the director of the Public Works Department said. “Last year, public works investigated 7,500 complaints related to weeds, debris, and illegal dumping on privately owned property.”

Over 5,000 citations were issued and 600 of those ended up being criminal complaints that went to court, Mr. Hornstein said. 

Advertise with us

If the city needs help from the state, Mr. Hornstein said it should come in the form of  “legal action with stronger teeth” to deal with absentee landlords and unreachable limited liability companies. 

“The current system allows negligent property owners to avoid or ignore citations, leaving no court dates or fines and in the end the burden falls on residents,” Mr. Hornstein said. “We need stronger legal tools to hold irresponsible owners accountable and reduce the strain on our communities.”