Whether politics played a role in Christopher Ragland’s decision to withdraw his nomination for Pittsburgh police chief last week — and retire from the department altogether — isn’t really a question.

Mr. Ragland himself said the nomination became a “political football” that hindered his ability to lead the bureau even on an interim basis, with “political factions” waylaying his quest toward the permanent job.

Observers disagree, though, on whether the process of hiring a police chief has become too overtly politicized or whether it’s always been an inherently political process that just had the misfortune of playing out loudly and publicly this time.

There is agreement, however, that the fallout could linger, particularly when paired with the stream of turnover among top police brass in recent years.

Advertise with us

Former Chief Scott Schubert announced his retirement after years at the helm in May 2022 and officially left the bureau that July. It took the city nearly a year to bring in the next chief, Larry Scirotto, a process that involved a nationwide search. During that time, Assistant Chief Thomas Stangrecki led the bureau as acting chief. It’s unclear whether he wanted or was considered for the permanent position, and he retired shortly thereafter.

The nomination of Mr. Ragland, the acting chief, in February had already landed in the lap of a city council still feeling burned by former Chief Scirotto’s abrupt departure Nov. 1 under controversial circumstances. Some council members felt the process needed to be open to the public to prevent another mishap like the one that saw him leave just 16 months into the job.

Drawing out the process has been viewed as either a push for a more transparent process to a deliberate attempt to delay the confirmation process until after the May 20 primary election.

“There’s always going to be some degree of politics in a system in which the mayor appoints the chief and the chief serves at the pleasure of the mayor,” said David A. Harris, a University of Pittsburgh School of Law professor who has studied policing for more than 30 years.

As a police chief in such a system, he said, “You know you serve at the mayor’s pleasure, and the mayor can dictate your removal from the job.”

Advertise with us

Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum, a D.C.-based nonprofit research and policy organization, said some of the politics stems from a heightened interest in and attention to policing.

“Sometimes people will not look at the candidate as much as the process of selecting them,” he said. “If people don’t feel that they were involved, they will raise concerns.”

That may be, said Elizabeth Pittinger, executive director of the city’s Citizen Police Review Board, but in her view, the situation with Mr. Ragland was “the most exposed and controversial process” she’s seen in her 30 years leading the review board.

“A rudderless ship doesn’t get very far,” she said.

Under normal circumstances, the nomination and confirmation process could be rocky but would ultimately go through.

Advertise with us

What happened last week could be a combination of those extenuating circumstances mixed with a highly competitive Democratic mayoral primary between incumbent Ed Gainey and County Controller Corey O’Connor.

“With the pending election, the pending primary … one failed [police chief] nomination and another with a shortened tenure, you’ve got everybody pointing in different directions, some mad at others,” Mr. Harris said. “That would make it difficult to confirm anybody into this job.

“Given the disarray that things are in now, it’s hard to envision there being a permanent chief [anytime soon].”

A ‘minefield’

Some on council say no decision should be made until after the primary election May 20.

Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said, for example, that Mr. Gainey should not offer up another candidate for chief before then.

Advertise with us

“I think we owe it to the public to do our due diligence to take our time and do this right,” Ms. Kail-Smith said. “Public safety merits more respect.”

Mr. Wexler said certain selection processes are more political than others.

City of Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey discusses the retirement of Acting Police Chief Chris Ragland at the Downtown City-County Building on Wednesday, March 5, 2025. (Sarah Qu / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“Mayors can sometimes pick who they want. City managers, on the other hand, tend to be more process-driven,” he said.

“In some cities, city council has to approve of the candidate, and that makes the process more political … because you need to get the cooperation of the city council.”

That, combined with the other converging circumstances — a contested election, the continuing lack of long-term police leadership, Mr. Scirotto’s abrupt departure — has created a “minefield” in Pittsburgh, Mr. Wexler said.

Advertise with us

If Mr. Gainey loses the Democratic primary, the city will have a new mayor after the November general election. Two Republicans also are on the primary ballot, business owner Thomas West and a former city police officer, Tony Moreno.

A new mayor might want to take the police bureau in another direction. In many cases police chiefs, like department heads, leave their positions when a new mayor comes in.

That’s often played out with little fanfare in Pittsburgh.

Bob McNeilly was chief from 1996 until his retirement in early 2006, coinciding with new Mayor Bob O’Connor taking office. He was Corey O’Connor’s father.

Bob O’Connor tapped Dom Costa as his police chief, but he stepped aside less than 10 months later when Luke Ravenstahl became mayor after Bob O’Connor’s death.

Advertise with us

The Ravenstahl administration appointed Earl Woodyard Jr. as acting chief in the interim until the mayor selected Nate Harper for the permanent position.

“A political appointee is always going to have some politics attached,” Ms. Pittinger said. “But then, the chief of police, in terms of the line of accountability, reports to the public safety director, who’s in the middle and has nothing to say about who the appointee is.”

Similarly, the public safety director also is appointed by the mayor and confirmed by council.

“Right there, you have a conflict in terms of managing an individual who is expected to follow some political agenda,” Ms. Pittinger said.

As a fix to that problem, Ms. Pittinger said, the city could put the chief under a contract that clearly lays out job expectations. That would remove the “feeling of being beholden to whatever political whimsy happens to be the thing at the time,” she said.

Advertise with us

“We don’t have any clear rules now. It’s all the subjective political stuff.”

It’s a fine line to walk, Ms. Kail-Smith said.

“The mayor has his right to pick a nominee,” Ms. Kail-Smith said. “You don’t want to step on his toes in that regard, but [council is] also being held accountable by the public who feels that we should’ve watched what happened the first time around.”

An abrupt departure

“The first time around” is a reference to former Chief Scirotto, whose controversial departure last year left a bad taste with many on council — one that clearly still lingers.

Mr. Scirotto spent more than 20 years with the city before his first retirement in 2018, after which he applied for a number of top-cop jobs around the country and landed briefly in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. Mr. Gainey announced Mr. Scirotto as his pick for chief in May 2023. He retired about 16 months later amid controversy surrounding his side job as an NCAA basketball referee.

Advertise with us

Mr. Scirotto told City Council ahead of his 2023 confirmation that as chief, he would not pursue a return to college basketball officiating. A year later, however, he announced that he would return to the court part-time — with the mayor’s blessing.

He left the bureau as scrutiny of the decision grew, saying on the way out that he and Mr. Gainey had always had a gentleman’s agreement to revisit the question of officiating once Mr. Scirotto finished a year on the job. Mr. Gainey has denied there was any such deal in place.

From the outside looking in, Ms. Pittinger said, it appears that the rise and fall of Mr. Ragland’s nomination could be traced back to the Scirotto fallout.

The city paid an outside firm $80,000 to narrow a national search to three candidates. The city also organized three panels to meet with the candidates: One made up of the mayor’s top advisers, one of police union members, and one of community members.

Community members were named publicly, but they and the police union members were asked to sign non-disclosure agreements regarding the process.

Advertise with us

“I think that really created a much more political and polarizing process,” which then bled into Mr. Ragland’s nomination, Ms. Kail-Smith said.

The proposed process for Mr. Ragland would have included six public meetings with police officers and community members.

“You had two extremes here,” Ms. Pittinger said. “You had that very clandestine, secret process ... and now we have this very chaotic, open book craziness.”

Part of that process is a new requirement that candidates for chief must be under oath when interviewing with city council.

While this nominating process is the most politicized that Ms. Kail-Smith can remember – partly due to the overlapping nature with the primary race – it’s not the first controversial one.

Advertise with us

When Cameron McLay was appointed chief in 2014, Ms. Kail-Smith said she got numerous calls from people upset that the chief was chosen from outside the bureau — the first time in the more than 150-year history of the bureau. This time around, Ms. Kail-Smith said she received an influx of concern regarding Mr. Ragland’s nomination.

Mr. Ragland, in his resignation, cited certain “demands” made of him that he felt were unethical.

“All I’m going to say is that during this process, I didn’t feel that I could lead the bureau in a way that was morally and ethically in line with my thoughts and desires,” he said Tuesday.

Certain council members, including Ms. Kail-Smith, identified themselves as the ones Mr. Ragland might have been referring to, though they denied any type of wrongdoing. Councilman Anthony Coghill said he asked Mr. Ragland during a meeting whom he intended to promote to be his assistants and command staff.

“Not one conversation was had between me and another commander or anybody in any other rank as to a deal or something nefarious,” Mr. Coghill said, noting that he did “stress that it’s important for me to know who he surrounded himself with.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Gainey, though, implied that some council members told Mr. Ragland who they wanted to see promoted in exchange for their confirmation votes. He said the blame for Mr. Ragland’s departure “is squarely on them.”

The entire situation points back to what Mr. Harris said is the inherently political nature of a position appointed by the mayor and confirmed by council.

“The mayor is the elected public official, and the idea is that if the chief is not carrying out the job in a way that the mayor likes, the mayor will remove the chief and replace him with someone who will,” he said.

On the flip side, though, the mayor is accountable to the public.

“If the public doesn’t like what the chief of police is doing but the mayor retains that chief, there’s some possibility that the mayor will be voted out over that issue,” Mr. Harris said. “In a system like that, you always have some degree of politics as the system of accountability.”