Organizers of a ballot referendum seeking the city to divest from countries committing genocide, specifically citing Israel, conceded that they did not have enough signatures to make it on the ballot during a hearing Friday morning — ending the legal challenges it faced.
The Not On Our Dime campaign submitted petitions last month to try and get a referendum on the ballot that would amend the city’s Home Rule Charter to align the city’s finances with its “moral standards” which would include divesting from any country “engaged in genocide and apartheid — such as the state of Israel — and corporations doing business with them.”
The Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh, multiple leaders in the Jewish community and City Controller Rachael Heisler all filed challenges against the initiative — alleging that not only did it not have enough valid signatures, but that the referendum itself violated the state constitution.
The group claimed that when they submitted their petitions, they had over 21,000 signatures. But multiple reviews of the signatures found there to be significantly less and many of them were signed by people who are either not registered to vote or specifically not registered within the city.
Friday leaders with Not On Our Dime — a pro-Palestinian organization — attempted to withdraw the petition, but were blocked by Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge John T. McVay who required a document signed by the organizers acknowledging they did not have enough signatures to appear on the ballot.
“Once again, they have failed to demonstrate support from Pittsburgh voters for their divisive and anti-Israel referendum,” the federation said in a statement. “This is yet another decisive victory for our Jewish community, for local voters and for the City of Pittsburgh.”
Read More
The federation said that these efforts “posed a direct threat to our city’s values and financial stability.” If the referendum had passed, Pittsburgh would have to stop doing business with companies like Dell, Microsoft, Amazon and Google, as well as companies that provided emergency medical services with life-saving drugs like Narcan.
Ms. Heisler, in her court filing and during a news conference after the hearing, noted that while the language of the referendum specifically targets Israel, the language would also apply to a number of other countries like China and the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
“This would have impacted city procurement practices, city spending, city investments, city finances overall and the benefit guaranteed to city retirees,” she said. “We’re in a very tight period with the city finances, and that’s what these conversations should be focused on… instead of being distracted by this.”
Last summer, similar efforts to put divestment from Israel on the ballot ended in a nearly identical fashion, and the organizing group withdrew their petitions before a judge could rule on the legality. The Jewish Federation and Ms. Heisler had challenged that effort as well.
“I firmly believe that this is not the forum to determine complex matters of international law,” she said.
Not On Our Dime co-organizer Ben Case declined to comment after the hearing.
In an effort to prevent the Home Rule Charter from being amended in such a way in the future, Pittsburgh City Council has put forth its own ballot question, seeking to prohibit the charter from being used to add “duties or obligations beyond the lawful scope of the city’s authority."
Councilwoman Erika Strassburger sponsored the question, along with another that would prohibit various forms of discrimination.
“There are 10 other fiduciaries that are elected in city government that could have also filed legal objections and chose not to,” Ms. Heisler said, but advocated for the city doing anything “we can do to dissuade this from continuing.”
If Ms. Strassburger’s referendum passes, it’s unclear exactly what would happen should a group try a third round of petitions to require the city to divest from Israel.
Ms. Heisler said her interpretation was that it would require the city solicitor to act on behalf of the city — likely in the form of a legal challenge.
Mayor Ed Gainey did not direct the city’s solicitor to file a challenge for either attempt at divestment.
“I find it regretful that others didn’t file an objection, given how concerning this referendum was,” Ms. Heisler said.
Mr. Gainey previously acknowledged that the referendum would “bring nearly every function of city government grinding to a halt.”
Beacon Coalition Executive Director Jeremey Kazzaz, whose organization assisted the Jewish Federation in reviewing the signatures, said that Mr. Gainey’s lack of a challenge “allowed this destructive initiative to persist.”
“By twice refusing to take action against discriminatory measures, Mayor Gainey empowers this extremist group to continue to target our city and its residents,” Mr. Kazzaz said in a statement.
Mr. Gainey’s office did not respond to request for comment.
Many in Pittsburgh’s Jewish community also felt that the effort — and the effort last summer — had antisemitic intentions.
Jeff Finkelstein, president and CEO of the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh pointed to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of antisemitism, which gives as an example of antisemitism, Israel being held to a different standard than other countries.
“I think we saw that in this case clearly,” he said.
Though the language of the referendum included any country participating in genocide or apartheid, it only directly named Israel.
“I don’t understand why a group of people who live in the city of Pittsburgh would do things that would deliberately hurt the residents of Pittsburgh,” Mr. Finkelstein said. “Shame on them for doing this and for bringing in issues with Israel and other countries into local politics.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.