PG Politics is a weekly newsletter written by Hallie Lauer, the Post-Gazette's Pittsburgh politics reporter. Each Wednesday, she'll take readers inside the halls of Grant Street and deliver unparalleled reporting on Pittsburgh City Council and the hotly contested race for Pittsburgh mayor. You'll also see dispatches from our reporting teams all across Western Pennsylvania, Harrisburg and Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C.
To get this content exclusively a day earlier, use this link to subscribe to the newsletter.
A few months ago a friend asked me: Why does everyone care about that cop wanting to referee basketball?
In true Pittsburgh fashion, the actual question had a few more expletives in it, but it got to the heart of what has been a months-long discussion among city leaders.
In October, Police Chief Larry Scirotto stepped down from the position after it was made public that he would be refereeing NCAA basketball — again. Mr. Scirotto, during his previous stint with the bureau, had also refereed basketball.
What it boils down to in Pittsburgh is that city officials — and residents — aren’t mad that he wants to return to the basketball court. They’re upset that he said he wouldn’t and then did, allegedly via a “handshake deal” with Mayor Ed Gainey.
Read More
Members of city council, at a meeting Mr. Gainey did not attend, made their displeasure with the situation very clear. They felt lied to, left out of the conversation and as if trust between the mayor’s administration and council had been broken.
They all agreed that Mr. Scirotto had done a good job in his role, but not being included in a major decision like this had left a bad taste in their mouths.
Since the news became public in October, the administration had maintained that when Mr. Scirotto was being considered for the job, he asked if he could still ref. The mayor allegedly said if crime rates go down, they could revisit the conversation.
Multiple city officials, including Mr. Gainey and Mr. Scirotto had maintained that story across interviews with media and at public appearances for months after the chief’s departure.
Until earlier this month.
On Feb. 9, during a Q&A session with both Democratic mayoral candidates, representatives from the Young Democrats of Allegheny County, Mr. Gainey was asked about his response to a “backroom deal” made with the chief.
Mr. Gainey denied that there was a deal made during the hiring process. As part of his response, Mr. Gainey said that during the interview process, Mr. Scirotto had asked if he could also referee.
“And I said no,” Mr. Gainey said at the event. He went on to say that Mr. Scirotto had approached him in October and said that the NCAA had asked him again about reffing. At that time, according to Mr. Gainey, is when the city decided that Mr. Scirotto could ref again and the city would use this as an opportunity to get Pittsburgh youth to travel to games to improve community relations and teach them about “sports media” and “sports finance” and see “what the college environment is like.”
It was a stark contrast from the long-maintained company line that there had been an initial conversation. Two weeks ago, Mr. Gainey changed the story and said that there wasn’t a deal at the time of Mr. Scirotto’s hiring.
It’s an old adage that when you hear two sides of a story the truth is likely somewhere in the middle. Is there a world in which during that first conversation Mr. Gainey initially said no, but then agreed to revisit it later? Absolutely.
But multiple members of the Gainey administration, including Jake Pawlak who is officially the director of the Office of Management and Budget but fills in as deputy mayor on occasion, spoke before council and confirmed that they were aware of the “man-to-man” agreement Mr. Gainey had with the chief.
So where does the city go from here? Council members still very clearly feel upset about an agreement happening behind their backs. Councilman Anthony Coghill has instituted legislation that will require mayoral appointees to be under oath during their interviews with council.
Acting Chief Ragland will likely be the first to experience that when council schedules his interview. And if the rumblings on Grant Street are any indication, that interview process will be one to mark on your calendars.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.