Several months after Allegheny County Council rejected county Executive Sara Innamorato’s selections for an oversight board of the Highland Detention at Shuman Center — a facility housing juveniles in the region — some council members have taken the job on themselves.
Multiple members have selected eight people for consideration by the entire council, as of Tuesday. Ken Varhola, council’s chief of staff, said Wednesday that ultimately, council will send over one name for consideration by Ms. Innamorato.
The Highland Detention at Shuman Center Board of Advisors is tasked with ensuring the center, located in Lincoln–Lemington–Belmar in Pittsburgh, operates safely and efficiently. Adelphoi, a Latrobe-based nonprofit that has been contracted to run the facility, is currently working with county officials to renovate the space to add capacity after it reopened last July with a dozen beds. The plan is to expand to 60 beds, but work won’t be done for several months, officials have said.
Part of the issue complicating council’s vote last year was a lawsuit over the contract with Adelphoi. Council sued then-county Executive Rich Fitzgerald’s administration and court officials over a five-year, $73 million agreement, saying council members should have had a say in the deal, via the county charter. After months in court, and Ms. Innamorato taking office, the two sides settled. Council has the ability to terminate the contract after five years and the advisory board will get detailed reports on the center at least a week before each monthly meeting.
Mr. Varhola said that council members are going to, “in a perfect world,” narrow down the eight nominees to three finalists, and then they will vote to send over one of those to Ms. Innamorato for confirmation. That agreement was part of the settlement between council and the Innamorato administration, Mr. Varhola said.
Ms. Innamorato will then select four of her own picks for the board, pending council approval.
Read More
The eight people council members have selected for consideration to the advisory board are:
• Kimberly Dunlevy, by Councilman Bob Macey. Ms. Dunlevy is a paralegal and serves on the county’s ethics board.
• Rabbi Moishe Mayir Vogel, by Councilwoman Suzanne Filiaggi. Mr. Vogel is founder of executive director of Aleph Institute’s North East region in Pittsburgh. Aleph focuses on prison reform, connecting those in need with housing, social services, healthy food, health care and jobs,
• Robert Marc Davis, by Ms. Filiaggi. Mr. Davis is a psychiatrist practicing in New Kensington, who also serves as medical director for Wesley Family Services, a behavioral health services nonprofit in Pittsburgh.
• Lee Davis, by Councilwoman Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis. Mr. Davis has worked in violence prevention, including as a program director of Greater Valley Community Services, a social services organization in Braddock.
• Terri Collin Dilmore, by Councilwoman Dan Grzybek. Ms. Dilmore is a psychologist and professor at Howard University, whose research focuses on juveniles and how generational trauma impacts them.
• Whitehall police Chief Jason Gagorik, by Council President Patrick Catena. Chief Gogorik joined Whitehall’s police force in 2002 and became chief in 2021.
• Maria Guido, by Councilwoman Bethany Hallam. Ms. Guido is a licensed clinical social worker who focuses on therapy to help those with complex PTSD and developmental trauma, along other similar disciplines.
• Tanisha Long, by Ms. Hallam. Ms. Long is Allegheny County Community Organizer for the Abolitionist Law Center, a nonprofit focused on criminal justice reform. She also founded RE Visions, a nonprofit focused on improving educational opportunities for students of color.
Per state and county law, the county executive and County Council select five people to sit on the board. Council members’ picks are all referred to the appointment review committee before coming back to a full council meeting for a potential final vote.
County officials said they are waiting on council’s deliberations before deciding on who they might suggest. Ms. Innamorato and County Controller Corey O’Connor also each sit on the board, although they can each send a designee in their stead.
The county’s president judge also gets three picks to the 10-member board, which does not require council or executive approval. Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente selected:
• Jennifer S. McCrady, a county judge. She serves in the family division and was first elected in November 2015.
• Edward Mulvey, who serves as a professor of psychiatry emeritus and former director of the Law and Psychiatry Program at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine.
• Cheyenne Tyler, executive director of Café Momentum, a nonprofit and restaurant training program with a location in Pittsburgh.
Council President Patrick Catena said the new board members, once they are seated, will have an interesting job balancing the interests of several partners in government and the criminal justice field, who want to ensure juveniles who are detained at Shuman have bright futures once they are released.
“This is a board that’s basically never existed before, so it’s going to be a learning experience for them and Adelphoi, as well as all of us [council members] and the county executive,” Mr. Catena said.
Clarification, posted 9:45 a.m. Feb. 26, 2025: This article was updated to clarify the County Council and county executive’s appointment process for the Shuman advisory board.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.