Allegheny County’s manager and the budget and finance director defended county Executive Sara Innamorato’s proposed 2025 budget and tax increase on Wednesday, saying that an apparent counter-offer of a 1 mill increase on property taxes was an impossible position to negotiate from.
Ms. Innamorato wants to increase the millage rate by 2.2 mills from 4.73 mills to 6.93 mills. On a house assessed at $110,400, that would amount to $182 more per year in taxes, accounting for an increased homestead exemption, county officials have said.
County officials said during a news briefing before Ms. Innamorato presented her proposal earlier this month that the county is facing an operating deficit of about $81 million in 2024. The proposed budget in 2025 indicates a $148 million deficit if no property tax increase occurs.
That would make the county financially insolvent because it would not have the cash reserves to cover such a deficit, county officials said.
County Manager John Fournier told County Council members Wednesday that with just a 1 mill increase they would need to cut the budget by about $95 million. That would be “catastrophic” because of matching state funds they would have to forgo in the county’s Department of Human Services and other cuts that would need to be made in other departments and divisions.
Even if officials zeroed out multiple critical departments, they still would be many millions of dollars short of balancing the budget, Mr. Fournier said.
Read More
“We cannot really even begin to negotiate a budget proposal that is limited at a one mill increase. We need to find a way to bring this discussion to some point of reality,” he said.
Timothy Cox, the county’s budget and finance director, agreed. He said there is no way for county officials to cut their way out of the current deficit.
But some council members were unconvinced, setting up what will likely be many further negotiations.

County Councilwoman Suzanne Filiaggi asked multiple questions about specific line items in the budget, and how the money was being spent. She also pointed out that many property owners in her district would pay much more than the $15 per month increase in taxes, given their home values. Her district, District 2, covers much of the northern part of the county.
“That's not what's going to happen in District 2, in 3, in 4, in 5 … We have to be honest with the public,” Ms. Filiaggi said.
Mr. Fournier acknowledged that those with higher property values would pay more.
“I will say to your point about the council districts, it is true that wealthier homeowners will pay more under this proposal,” he said in response to Ms. Filiaggi’s questions.
But while some council members acknowledged that honest conversations about the budget, the looming deficit and proposed tax increase needed to continue, there still appeared be opposition from multiple members at the dais in the Gold Room of the county courthouse on Wednesday.
Perhaps no members were as explicit as Council Vice President John Palmiere, who said the administration had a long, uphill battle to get the 10 votes required to pass a tax increase. Several of his constituents are in tricky financial positions, and would be hurt by a 2.2-mill bump, Mr. Palmiere said.
“You guys didn't project this thing and put it out there very well, as far as I'm concerned,” he said. “The optics are terrible, absolutely terrible.”

Others were more measured. Council Member Nicholas Futules said that while a 2.2-mill increase was likely too high to reach 10 votes, some increase would need to happen.
“I don't know where the line is right now, or [where] it's going to be, or [what] it could be, but I think it's going to be up to the administration to prove to this council that necessary things have to be done in order to move forward. And that's difficult,” Mr. Futules said.
More than 20 people offered public comment in favor of the proposed budget and tax increase — and three against. Those in support of the tax increase said they were willing to pay their share in taxes for critical county services.
Per the county charter, the County Council has until early December to approve a budget. The council’s budget and finance committee will review Ms. Innamorato’s proposals in the coming weeks, before they go to the full council for a vote.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.