Allegheny County’s president judge said Monday that if a proposed property tax increase wasn’t approved and court officials had to cut 10% from their budget, it would be “catastrophic” for operations.

Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente told County Council members during the second of three scheduled public hearings for Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato’s proposed budgets and property tax rate, that reducing the budget by that amount would create havoc in the county’s courts.

“We'd have to cut a lot of personnel. Seventy-six percent of our budget is personnel, and we have a high-volume business, and if we cut all those personnel, we're not going to have the resources,” Judge DiLucente said. “We're not going to have the staff to process and move cases, and it's going to create a huge backlog.”

County Councilman Dan Grzybek has been asking county department and division heads about what they would do if they cut 10% of their budget during the council hearings because it’s what he estimates would need to be done if the county were to fund no property tax increase.

Advertise with us

Ms. Innamorato proposed a 2.2-mill increase to the property tax rate for 2025, as county budget officials say a $81 million deficit is facing the county by the end of 2024.

To cover that and an overall increase in county operating costs, Ms. Innamorato wants to raise the millage rate from 4.73 mills to 6.93 mills in 2025. On a house assessed at $110,400, that would amount to $182 more per year in taxes, accounting for an increased homestead exemption.

Homes with higher values would see a higher increase. County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam and O’Hara Township Auditor Darwin Leuba recently released an online tool where property owners can search the impact on their county property taxes. For instance, on a property with a taxable value of $770,000, the current proposal would raise taxes each month from roughly $304 to $443.

Ms. Innamorato, per the county charter, needs 10 out of 15 County Council members to approve any property tax increase. But at least six have already come out against it publicly, and County Council President Patrick Catena has said there are more who are privately opposed.

But the county executive told reporters recently that council members need to be more specific about where they were cut, and said any reductions in the millage would lead to vital services being cut.

Advertise with us

On Monday, Judge DiLucente said that any great cuts to the courts would create huge challenges. Ms. Innamorato’s proposed budget allocates about $97.4 million to the county’s Court of Common Pleas in 2025. The adjusted budget for 2024 is $93.3 million — so the upcoming year’s proposal reflects about a 4.4% increase.

The president judge said about $103.3 million was requested for 2025, but understood the financial challenges that county officials are facing when facing this year’s budgetary decisions.

Councilman Robert Palmosina, who chairs the council’s committee on budget and finance and is running the budget hearings, said it was up to him and colleagues to find the money that Judge DiLucente and others need to run operations.

Everyone wants more money, but it would be irresponsible to beg for any more given current fiscal conditions, the president judge said. She added, in response to a question to Councilman Jack Betkowski, that the state pays for county and magisterial judges’ salaries, while county coffers help fund operations.

“Hopefully, we recover as a county, and we do better next year. We can ask for more money … but everybody has to do their part, so I feel like it would be irresponsible to ask for more money,” Judge DiLucente said.

The third and final scheduled budget hearing is 5 p.m. Wednesday in the Gold Room of the county courthouse.